I'm a bit stuck in the middle, I think the Magic Weekend is a great concept and has undoubtedly been a success for the sport. I would however love to see another trophy up for grabs, losing the Regal trophy and Lancashire cup has always been a massive shame. 2 trophies is simply not enough to play for, we need more competitions!
There's no doubt in my mind that a 9s tournament would attract a sell out crowd for both days because you could have every team playing games on both days and have more clubs participate in the completion to begin with.
Have a £250k first prize for the winning club. If I was the RFL I would just try it at the Etihad next year, if it doesn't work simply revert back to the Magic Weekend.