Shenton to HKR : Tue May 15, 2012 7:38 am  

http://www.thisishullandeastriding.co.u ... story.html Looks like he's off then

http://www.thisishullandeastriding.co.u ... story.html Looks like he's off then

Re: Shenton to HKR : Tue May 15, 2012 7:52 am  

As harsh as it may sound, let's hope so. Turner for Shenton is a no-brainer.

Re: Shenton to HKR : Tue May 15, 2012 8:05 am  

Doesn't really improve us too much though does it.

Turner in is one of 7 backs spots, Lomax another. We're still 5 short of having a decent lineup.

Re: Shenton to HKR : Tue May 15, 2012 8:10 am  

Saddened! wrote:

Doesn't really improve us too much though does it.

Turner in is one of 7 backs spots, Lomax another. We're still 5 short of having a decent lineup.

As always, I shall take your 'negative for the sake of being negative' attitude with a pinch of salt!

I agree our back line needs shaking up, but we don't need another 5. Jones and Makinson are very good players in the making.

Next year I'd love to see:

Lomax
Swift/Gardner
Turner
Jones
Makinson
NEW SIGNING
Gaskell/Wheeler

So shipping Hohaia out and signing Finch for example would make our back 7 look a whole let better.

Re: Shenton to HKR : Tue May 15, 2012 8:30 am  

Saddened! wrote:

Doesn't really improve us too much though does it.

Turner in is one of 7 backs spots, Lomax another. We're still 5 short of having a decent lineup.

So are you suggesting we should just stick with being 6 short?

Re: Shenton to HKR : Tue May 15, 2012 8:49 am  

Dux wrote:

So are you suggesting we should just stick with being 6 short?

No, I just think having Shenton around might not be a bad idea. He's not a bad player by any means. Turner looks a decent player, but in reality he's not proven himself to be any better than Shenton. A lot of Saints fans are judging him on his gallop against us and he hasn't been getting positive reviews for his performances until this season and his defense seems to be a major issue.

We'll go into next season with Wellens at fullback no doubt. The club has shown no willingness to move him so far, so unless Brown has stated his desire to move him out, he'll be at fullback. Makinson, decent player though he is, doesn't score enough or do enough individually, nor do Josh Jones or Gary Wheeler who look set for the other centre spot (Jones no doubt winning that battle quite easily). We'll also be stuck with the same halves we have this season, unless the club can pull something out of the bag with Lance's P45.

It's not a 'bad' backline, but compared to the likes of Leeds, Wigan, Wire and Huddersfield it's definitely lacking.

Re: Shenton to HKR : Tue May 15, 2012 9:09 am  

Saddened! wrote:

No, I just think having Shenton around might not be a bad idea. He's not a bad player by any means. Turner looks a decent player, but in reality he's not proven himself to be any better than Shenton. A lot of Saints fans are judging him on his gallop against us and he hasn't been getting positive reviews for his performances until this season and his defense seems to be a major issue.

I think it makes real sense. Turner has only been playing centre for a couple of years, so it's no surprise that he's taken some time to hit the mark defensively, but he's looked good whenever I've seen him play this year, not just against us. I'm under no illusion that he is the finished article, but he represents a strike threat, which is something we sorely lack. Turner may not have yet proven himself to be better than Shenton, but he is young, is still learning, and, importantly, has the raw athleticism which Shenton lacks. Conversely, Shenton has proven himself not to be the test-standard player we paid for. I reckon if we pull this off we'll be getting a potentially much better player for quite a bit less money.

Re: Shenton to HKR : Tue May 15, 2012 9:27 am  

If Shenton does go then that's great for him (as he's been average here) and the club (opens up a huge chunk of the SC)

2. Gardner
3. Turner
4. Jones/Wheeler
5. Makinson/Swift

I think there's a lot of potential there for Brown to work with. If you looked at Hudds back-line before Brown came people were saying that it was average, but it had potential. This 3/4 has a lot of potential IMO.

Re: Shenton to HKR : Tue May 15, 2012 9:30 am  

Saddened! wrote:

No, I just think having Shenton around might not be a bad idea. He's not a bad player by any means. Turner looks a decent player, but in reality he's not proven himself to be any better than Shenton. A lot of Saints fans are judging him on his gallop against us and he hasn't been getting positive reviews for his performances until this season and his defense seems to be a major issue.

What has Turner actually shown? has had some decent games this year for them but in the previous 2 seasons has been very poor.

Re: Shenton to HKR : Tue May 15, 2012 9:34 am  

Rupert Pupkin wrote:

What has Turner actually shown? has had some decent games this year for them but in the previous 2 seasons has been very poor.

He's shown great potential this season under a good coach