RU will overrun RL : Thu Mar 03, 2011 12:54 am  

I have just been on the Wigan site and there's a thread about union is going to be the only code of rugby eventually.

First of all will this happen

When(if)could it happen

I must admit I am concerned about this especially with the Kyle situation,or am I being paranoid as usual where union is concerned.

Re: RU will overrun RL : Thu Mar 03, 2011 1:14 am  

I voted yes for dramatic effect. I think in terms of media portrayal, crowd numbers, finances and player crossovers I think Union will and perhaps already is totally eclipsing League. In this country at least Union has been on the march since they formally admitted professionalism. They get bigger TV deals, their international game is vibrant and exciting and something everyone in league is extremely jealous of whether they care to admit it or not.

Of course in other countries the code isn't faring all that well. Australia seems content with League and AFL being the better sports and the NRL is IMO the benchmark rugby competition in the world in terms of the quality of the individuals playing it. It doesn't seem to be Union making the in roads it seems to be soccer over there.

Will Union being bigger stop league existing? Well no, of course not. F1 existing and being far, far, far greater doesn't stop the tiny motorsports existing and I'm sure League can mill along pretty much as it is. Even without a TV deal they could run a semi professional league. The main problems League has are money and the calibre of the people associated with it. The governing body in the UK for RL is the most embarassing collection of people you are ever likely to meet. Not one of them has any marketing ability or commercial acumen. Add that to the lack of money in the game as a whole and it's not a good recipe. We've been professional for decades and have reached 2011 with a gaggle of semi-decent clubs, 1 viable European club and that is it. Half of Super League and the entire NL system is made up of clubs that shouldn't really exist as they have no fan base to speak of.

The major difference is how well run Union is. It has management of a level league cannot even dream of. Their decision makers and publicists and their media controlling expertise is just brilliant. They could sell snow to an eskimo. Union will IMO continue to grow and evolve and will probably be football's main rival within 20 years IMO. They seem to be slowly bringing the US in, almost all US colleges now play Union. It's only a matter of time before that develops.

Re: RU will overrun RL : Thu Mar 03, 2011 1:52 am  

There has been topics in the past about the codes merging.

IMO if this happens RL will get completely taken over by the union juggernaut.

I know RL in Australia is king but after there RL is looked at (let's be honest here) as a second class sport,especially where union is concerned.

Re: RU will overrun RL : Thu Mar 03, 2011 3:50 am  

If there was one code RL rules would be used. The only reason Union doesn't play RL currently is to spite itself.

Re: RU will overrun RL : Thu Mar 03, 2011 9:18 am  

Will it heck.

This question has come up repeatedly in the twenty years I've been watching the game, and I've no doubt it's been bandied about before then. The truth is that no Union fan wants to go and watch a hybrid game, and neither does any league fan I know. The games would only merge if there was demand for such a thing to happen, and as far as I can tell there is none.

Re: RU will overrun RL : Thu Mar 03, 2011 12:40 pm  

I'd rather watch Wigoon playing league than Saints playing union.

Re: RU will overrun RL : Thu Mar 03, 2011 1:15 pm  

NO!!

I can see why people are saying it but are over dramatising things - so long as the support is there our game will be there, just not in such a big scale as RU unfortunatley.

Get RL going in America (as I think it will due to simalarities with Amercian Football) and get some big names in (like Russel Crowe in Oz) and we have a chance.

The big argument IMO is how the players are capped on their wages, but to pay them more the cap needs to be more and whilst some of the higher/more successful clubs can maybe afford a rise, the smaller ones certainly can't so the divide comes back as in the 90s.

A MASSAIVE injection of money is needed to bring us along side our southern counterparts and I can't see where it will come from in my lifetime (I'm only 30 btw!!! lol)

Re: RU will overrun RL : Thu Mar 03, 2011 1:27 pm  

It'll be interesting to see if the renegotiation of the TV deal for next year will bring in any substantial increase in revenue. If it does then I'd have thought we'll see an increase in the cap (not enough to put it on a par with RU, but enough to help).

Re: RU will overrun RL : Thu Mar 03, 2011 2:19 pm  

If they put the cap up at all we might as well say goodnight to about five or six clubs. At the moment with the lower cap in place it is there to protect teams from spending their way into oblivion.

Re: RU will overrun RL : Thu Mar 03, 2011 2:20 pm  

Saddened! wrote:

If they put the cap up at all we might as well say goodnight to about five or six clubs. At the moment with the lower cap in place it is there to protect teams from spending their way into oblivion.

My suggestion is that it would only go up if the TV money distributed to clubs goes up. Clearly we can't afford to make it any higher a proportion of clubs' incomes than it is now.