Re: gilmour to u!!!! : Thu Jun 28, 2012 4:33 pm  

brearley84 wrote:

wouldnt be sad to see gilmour leave now, started well this season playing at prop-yes prop! but gone backwards again just like last season and struggles to take a tackle without knocking on...all too often gets smashed and takes and age to get back up with hands on his hips.

had a great career though.

Rather like Luke O Donnell then,although in all fairness Gilmour has played a fair few games more than your big name NRL superstar.

Re: gilmour to u!!!! : Thu Jun 28, 2012 5:48 pm  

007 wrote:

Rather like Luke O Donnell then,although in all fairness Gilmour has played a fair few games more than your big name NRL superstar.

o'donnell gets smashed and knocks on?

looking forward to seeing o'donnell back this weekend v hull fc and hopefully staying injury free for the end of season run in shame he did ligaments last season....can see his class when he plays

Re: gilmour to u!!!! : Thu Jun 28, 2012 7:17 pm  

Told ya

Re: gilmour to u!!!! : Thu Jun 28, 2012 9:14 pm  

giantsrabbitoh wrote:

Told ya

With all due respect, he's been linked about a month/month and a half.

Re: gilmour to u!!!! : Fri Jun 29, 2012 7:27 am  

So what is the low down on Gilmours current fitness, speed etc etc?

I keep looking at his age of 34 and thinking, we've signed yet another player in the twilight of their career with their best years behind them. I hope I'm wrong...

Re: gilmour to u!!!! : Fri Jun 29, 2012 7:57 am  

giantsrabbitoh wrote:

Told ya

It's been old news for about 6 weeks now. Even Dave "Nosey" Parker saw fit to report this in the Sun a few weeks ago

Re: gilmour to u!!!! : Fri Jun 29, 2012 9:47 am  

the_grobs wrote:

So what is the low down on Gilmours current fitness, speed etc etc?

I keep looking at his age of 34 and thinking, we've signed yet another player in the twilight of their career with their best years behind them. I hope I'm wrong...

IMO its worth taking a risk on a "older player" is he's out of the Solomona/Menzies/Ali mould, other than that its a massive risk, he will bring a a quallity to the team no doubt but be warned he's a total pro and won't like anyone who's not.

Re: gilmour to u!!!! : Fri Jun 29, 2012 10:43 am  

I hope he can have at least another good year or so, nothing wrong in getting a seasoned pro or ex-International in for a year in theory, Menzies being a great example.

However, this is Cas after all so for every Guttenbiel there is at least one Newlove...

Re: gilmour to u!!!! : Fri Jun 29, 2012 11:16 am  

El Rey wrote:

but be warned he's a total pro and won't like anyone who's not.

Sounds good to me - just what we are lacking at the moment.

Re: gilmour to u!!!! : Fri Jun 29, 2012 11:21 am  

El Rey wrote:

be warned he's a total pro and won't like anyone who's not.

he wont like most of our team then!