Re: Is there any other sport... : Sat Apr 30, 2011 5:08 pm  

Let's get back to seeing all passes go backwards. Not level, not flat, not flat with momentum....backwards and backwards only. Until this happens, every game in the league is going to be marred by such decisions week in week out.

Re: Is there any other sport... : Sat Apr 30, 2011 8:06 pm  

sgtwilko wrote:

I never said that. Totally didn't get my post at all.
No neither are allowed pal. The passes over a meter are much tougher to see and rule on than the long passes!

twisting anothers point of view is never a good luck.

But isn't that what you implied,and if they're tougher to rule on lets ban all short passing within our game or legalise forward passes,that way the referee would never have to make a judgement call regarding them.

Re: Is there any other sport... : Sun May 01, 2011 12:46 am  

Surely the course of longer passes are more susceptible to being moved by wind, thus making them harder to judge too?

Come off it, whether it's 1 metre or 10 metres a forward pass is a forward pass. Flat, short passes are more likely to get pulled up I find because most of the time players are running at a slow pace - the runner is the one with the speed/impact.

Re: Is there any other sport... : Sun May 01, 2011 12:52 am  

007 wrote:

But isn't that what you implied,and if they're tougher to rule on lets ban all short passing within our game or legalise forward passes,that way the referee would never have to make a judgement call regarding them.

No I didn't imply that. I told it how it is. You are just talking nonsensical rubbish. ban all short passes indeed?

The short flat ball has been a part of our game for over 100 years. Cas get one 60/50 call go against them and you lot want the rules changing. You would think the Leeds pass was a me forward? It was debatable at best.

Re: Is there any other sport... : Sun May 01, 2011 12:56 am  

No, they were both 50/50 calls. But if you deny one, you have to deny the other. You can't have one rule for one team and one rule for another, regardless of distance.

Re: Is there any other sport... : Sun May 01, 2011 12:59 am  

Fully wrote:

Surely the course of longer passes are more susceptible to being moved by wind, thus making them harder to judge too?

yeah if the wind is strong that would make it worse too.

Fully wrote:

Come off it, whether it's 1 metre or 10 metres a forward pass is a forward pass. Flat, short passes are more likely to get pulled up I find because most of the time players are running at a slow pace - the runner is the one with the speed/impact.

I don't agree with that at all. Obviously one call has got you all fired up. I would say get over it, but it's not gonna happen

Re: Is there any other sport... : Sun May 01, 2011 1:04 am  

It wasn't one call, was it though. It was three - 2 for us and 1 for you.

Oh, and there was another blatant forward pass in the 2nd half when you were returning a ball and I think it was Watkins and Webb were together about a metre apart and one of them chucked the ball to other so blatantly forward yet that was missed too.

Re: Is there any other sport... : Sun May 01, 2011 1:07 am  

Fully wrote:

No, they were both 50/50 calls. But if you deny one, you have to deny the other. You can't have one rule for one team and one rule for another, regardless of distance.

I ve explained it. You just haven't got enough logic and reason to get past your anger, sadness, how gutted you are? I'm not sure which one it is?

This isn't a reasonable debate. You just think Cas were hard done to and that's it for you.

Did you find Leeds fans moaning when silverwood disallowed 4 first half Leeds tries against Wigan a few weeks back for the same thing Cas did on Friday? No we didn't. You just take it on the chin.

You basically have sifted through my posts ignored the bits that you can't debate and come up with cas robbed.

Poor poor show pal. My 4 year old god daughter has better debating skills than you! And better rl knowledge by the looks of it.

Re: Is there any other sport... : Sun May 01, 2011 1:11 am  

Fully wrote:

It wasn't one call, was it though. It was three - 2 for us and 1 for you.

Oh, and there was another blatant forward pass in the 2nd half when you were returning a ball and I think it was Watkins and Webb were together about a metre apart and one of them chucked the ball to other so blatantly forward yet that was missed too.

I repeat Leeds got the wrong end of the stick against the pies a few weeks ago. Some you get some you don't. You need to get over it.

Re: Is there any other sport... : Sun May 01, 2011 1:16 am  

Explained what? All you've done is try to say that Leeds' try was fine is because it was over a shorter distance?

Yes, I think Cas were hard done to. And judging by the other posts across the majority of other forums, other people would tend to agree. You seem to take this as some anti-Leeds thing; it isn't. I'd be the same whether it was against Wigan, Leeds or Catalans. My point stands and if the referee cannot judge it then there are two touchjudges, who can view it too.

I'm not a regular reader of the Leeds forum, so no, I wouldn't have seen if people had moaned about the decisions. But that's irrelevant in the grand scheme of things as it's a different game. As for sifting through your posts, how can I sift through posts that are two/three lines long and making one point?

As for the insult at the bottom, if that's the best you can come up with then it would suggest YOU have the issues, not me. My RL knowledge is quite good, thank you very much.