Re: MENZIE : Tue Sep 27, 2011 1:52 pm  

I don't really care if he plays or not ESO. BUT, I can't agree with Thaler/Griff on this one. Looking at it again, it looks reckless to the point of dangerous. I wouldn't be surprised at a ban but I'm not fussed either way to be honest.

Re: MENZIE : Tue Sep 27, 2011 4:06 pm  

He wants banning for a good spell before he seriously injures someone, i blame Aston when he smashed Hepworths head into the ground, Aston said it was nothing, well it was and maybe if he had took him to 1 side had a word and worked on his technique this may not of happened and he might of been playing in a final. Each player has a duty of care to his opponent, menzie doesnt

Re: MENZIE : Tue Sep 27, 2011 4:46 pm  

gingdong wrote:

He wants banning for a good spell before he seriously injures someone, i blame Aston when he smashed Hepworths head into the ground, Aston said it was nothing, well it was and maybe if he had took him to 1 side had a word and worked on his technique this may not of happened and he might of been playing in a final. Each player has a duty of care to his opponent, menzie doesnt

Don't talk wet - he is a hard hitting centre - he has played against some of the best sides in the world and they have high regard for him in Austrailia, he hits hard but fairly , he only gets pull up by refs who go soft for the opposition.

Re: MENZIE : Tue Sep 27, 2011 5:02 pm  

I don't believe for one second Menzie ever goes out to intentionally hurt someone, however he is a hard hitting player with a suspect tackling technique which can sometimes get him and his opponents into a spot of bother.

Re: MENZIE : Tue Sep 27, 2011 5:07 pm  

westridingeagle wrote:

Don't talk wet - he is a hard hitting centre - he has played against some of the best sides in the world and they have high regard for him in Austrailia, he hits hard but fairly , he only gets pull up by refs who go soft for the opposition.

Never mind wet, dont talk shiiiite, and it would appear the panel agrees with me. The bloke playing like he does is a liability, he charges in like a loony without any thought, how was it hard but fair against hepworth when he was playing with his head, above the neck is illegal may be not in PNG but it is here, likewise a spear tackle after the play has moved on 10 mins is also illegal, he needs a new tackling technique

Re: MENZIE : Tue Sep 27, 2011 5:08 pm  

E.S.O wrote:

I don't believe for one second Menzie ever goes out to intentionally hurt someone, however he is a hard hitting player with a suspect tackling technique which can sometimes get him and his opponents into a spot of bother.

Basically what im saying he needs a new technique, and if Aston had adressed this after the hepworth incident instead of sticking up for the player he could of avoided the latest challenge

Re: MENZIE : Tue Sep 27, 2011 5:55 pm  

gingdong wrote:

Basically what im saying he needs a new technique, and if Aston had adressed this after the hepworth incident instead of sticking up for the player he could of avoided the latest challenge

Team coach in sticking up for his own player shocker.

Grow up.

Re: MENZIE : Tue Sep 27, 2011 6:00 pm  

@garethwalker13: "Menzie Yere out of Championship Grand Final after picking up two match ban and £50 fine #rugbyleague"

Step up Corey lad.

Re: MENZIE : Tue Sep 27, 2011 6:03 pm  

Rotherham Fev Fan wrote:

I don't really care if he plays or not ESO. BUT, I can't agree with Thaler/Griff on this one. Looking at it again, it looks reckless to the point of dangerous. I wouldn't be surprised at a ban but I'm not fussed either way to be honest.

Hold on - it looks like I'm talking about summat else ......

Re: MENZIE : Tue Sep 27, 2011 6:25 pm  

E.S.O wrote:

@garethwalker13: "Menzie Yere out of Championship Grand Final after picking up two match ban and £50 fine #rugbyleague"

Step up Corey lad.

about right! If he keeps tacl;ing like that he'll keep getting banned! Daft but in gingdong's own inimitable style, he points out Yere's flaws. Until the rotund one addresses that with him properly he will continue to suffer at the hands of the disciplinary!