Re: Players next year : Sat Nov 05, 2016 9:48 pm  

Pickering Red wrote:

Although England were cackamalla, I thought Danny Addy had a half decent game for Scotland against England earlier imo. Some flashes of creativity and half decent in defence. He didn't look out of place that's for sure.

Anybody disagree?

Did Scott Taylor play?

Tbh Addy looked very busy in the first half and didn't shy away when it came to tackling . didn't seem to pack much punch if I'm being honest though !!

OK I'll nibble on the Taylor bait . IMHO I think he's done enough to keep his place in the 17 at the expense of Cooper .
Williams and widdup at 6+7
Bateman back in for Farrell for me ,not that it will matter as I dry bumming is on the cards I'd imagine

[Mild Rover]

Re: Players next year : Sat Nov 05, 2016 10:09 pm  

easthull fc fan wrote:

Class player Addy maybe why he's just signed a deal with a championship side. For one of the best coaches in the world, again at a championship side.

That you've used it twice might suggest that the entry level rhetorical trick that is the circular argument is a new and exciting discovery for you.

Sheens will be judged at Hull KR on the results his team delivers. He's got the pedigree and experience that his immediate predecessors lacked, which is encouraging and reassuring. Addy offers versatility and by championship standards (which are those it is most sensible for us to judge by) decent quality.
That, with the exception of Greenwood, we're seemingly going with a lightweight backrow again, does make me a bit nervous after the last couple of years. Balance or style of play, rather than class.

Edit - are interchanges still going to be reduced for 2017?

Re: Players next year : Sat Nov 05, 2016 10:21 pm  

Mild Rover wrote:

That you've used it twice might suggest that the entry level rhetorical trick that is the circular argument is a new and exciting discovery for you.

Sheens will be judged at Hull KR on the results his team delivers. He's got the pedigree and experience that his immediate predecessors lacked, which is encouraging and reassuring. Addy offers versatility and by championship standards (which are those it is most sensible for us to judge by) decent quality.
That, with the exception of Greenwood, we're seemingly going with a lightweight backrow again, does make me a bit nervous after the last couple of years. Balance or style of play, rather than class.

Edit - are interchanges still going to be reduced for 2017?

I suspect you lost him at "that".

Re: Players next year : Sat Nov 05, 2016 10:41 pm  

SirStan wrote:

I suspect you lost him at "that".

This post made me think that you are the Eric Morecambe to Mild Rover's Ernie Wise.

Re: Players next year : Sat Nov 05, 2016 10:47 pm  

Pickering Red wrote:

:lol:

This post made me think that you are the Eric Morecambe to Mild Rover's Ernie Wise.

That would make you Anthea Redfearn.

Re: Players next year : Sun Nov 06, 2016 9:37 pm  

Salty mouse wrote:

I thought it was less for some reason, you would of thought one would be used on a half back.... Can't remember where I read about Quinlan and Hastings but I can't see them coming

Hastings isn't realistic but Quinlan could be an option.

Re: Players next year : Sun Nov 06, 2016 10:10 pm  

I would imagine Tim will have some fringe young Aussie lined up, didn't Quinlan play full back while at saints?

Re: Players next year : Sun Nov 06, 2016 10:19 pm  

Yeah, full-back at Saints but utility player, sure he plays in the halves as well.

Re: Players next year : Sun Nov 06, 2016 11:03 pm  

Think I read he's without a club? We need some experience in the halves ideally but bobbys much better in the back row

Re: Players next year : Sun Nov 06, 2016 11:29 pm  

I like your name.