Re: Derby week : Thu Jul 14, 2016 9:55 pm  

No arguing with that. Thaler did a lot of damage 1st half but we could've come back, instead just got worse & worse. Score flattered us in the end.

Re: Derby week : Thu Jul 14, 2016 10:41 pm  

You got a beating but well done to the hardcore of your supporters who stayed to the bitter end to support your team.

Re: Derby week : Thu Jul 14, 2016 11:19 pm  

Houghton try was offside..just watched it back.Thornley dragged in touch afrer ball carrying arm down should have been penalty to kr.3rd try off back of it. 18- 0 halftime thaler job done. Saying that rovers deserved nothing playing like that. Very disappointing Tilse Blair greenwood and walker were trying.the rest were poor.kelly and allgood worthy of particular criticism. That hull side had Bowden Thompson washbrook and ffs kebab dull. Amazed they are so high in league but the league don't lie at this stage of season.Watching it now I still can't believe how crap we were..needs ripping up and start again .2 big 2nd rows imperative.thaler was thaler but we didn't give a toss

Re: Derby week : Thu Jul 14, 2016 11:26 pm  

Pickering Red wrote:

Congratulations to the Black and Whites. Richly deserved victory.

The margin of victory was perhaps a bit flattering, aided by bizarre Thaler decisions yet again, some appalling composure from The Robins in attack, missed tackles, misreads in defence and some bad luck on 50-50 balls.

Marc Sneyd was pure class in the first half. He was the difference. On that form HE DESERVES A SHOT IN THE ENGLAND SIDE. ADD DANNY HOUGHTON TO THAT AS WELL.

We looked toothless in attack. Bombed too many opportunities and Hull's defence stifled us. Unhappy with the soft way we conceded the tries by Steve Michaels. Otherwise no complaints.

Hull will win at least one of the 2 end of season main trophies.

No chance, they don`t play for Leeds or Wigan.

Re: Derby week : Thu Jul 14, 2016 11:30 pm  

Got bummed by a far better side.
Still think Webster was an awful appointment.
Out of our pack Walker stood tall. The rest were battered like children.
Of our forwards only Walker, Lunt, Lawler and Greenwood are worth keeping. The rest can go. Too similar to each other or not good enough. Why have we re signed Donaldson. A trier, gallant and enthusiastic but....not up to it.
Clarkson...Jesus he's average and that's talking him up. What must the opposition think when he leads us out....
We've all on in the middle 8s which is a different competition than last year. Leeds Huddersfield and Salford are better teams than Wakefield, Widnes and Salford were. The championship teams will be better prepared. We've gone backwards.
We'll be favourites for the drop.
For me Peacock so far has been an awful idea and a shocking appointment when Chester rightly went cemented our season.
IF we stay up rumours of our possible recruitment so far are uninspiring.

Re: Derby week : Thu Jul 14, 2016 11:35 pm  

Houghton deserves a chance at international I suspect his distribution isn't good enough but he deserves a dig at it..shaul and sneyd not good enough at present but saying that if matty Smith can play half for England then why not snide? Anyway not my problem. .finished re watching game on sky after being there.lunt and Kelly were awol Minichello and ellis did us again

Re: Derby week : Thu Jul 14, 2016 11:50 pm  

Off to kip..can't argue with overall result but hudgell needs to bring some pressure on thaler That 1st half was influenced by ref far too much.its getting beyond joke now with him and rovers.as someone posted few day ago if we end up in million pound game which looks increasingly likely and thaler is ref we are gone

Re: Derby week : Thu Jul 14, 2016 11:52 pm  

Pickering Red wrote:

Congratulations to the Black and Whites. Richly deserved victory.

The margin of victory was perhaps a bit flattering, aided by bizarre Thaler decisions yet again, some appalling composure from The Robins in attack, missed tackles, misreads in defence and some bad luck on 50-50 balls.

Marc Sneyd was pure class in the first half. He was the difference. On that form HE DESERVES A SHOT IN THE ENGLAND SIDE. ADD DANNY HOUGHTON TO THAT AS WELL.

We looked toothless in attack. Bombed too many opportunities and Hull's defence stifled us. Unhappy with the soft way we conceded the tries by Steve Michaels. Otherwise no complaints.

Hull will win at least one of the 2 end of season main trophies.

I thought I was a closer game than the score line, and I have to agree you got few bad calls and the bonce of the ball did go our way I can not disagree with that but for me our will to win was excellent and for a change we looked like we really wanted it more than you which is not always the case in the end it was a good clinical performance from us with Jordon Abdul playing really well which was pleasing to see, the power we have all over the park told in the end we are a hard team to control when we get going forward, the 4 teams in the middle 8s from super league look very tasty and will dispense with the championship teams easily your only worry is injuries

Re: Derby week : Fri Jul 15, 2016 4:04 am  

Bullied and battered, we didn't look interested IMO. Until we learn how to do a basic tackle well keep missing 40 odd a game and we'll keep on losing. Defence wins you games, someone needs to tell our coaching staff that

Re: Derby week : Fri Jul 15, 2016 5:32 am  

LifeLongHKRFan wrote:

Nah. Hull to get their form back and seal our fate in the middle 8s. I can see Hull pushing 40 points with Rovers getting maybe 2 or 3 scores. We outplayed Hull in the derby at CP and for large parts at the magic weekend and still came away with nothing so I can't see past a Hull win on Thursday.

Looks like i was pretty spot on,