Re: Who do we want now then : Fri Mar 13, 2020 10:30 pm  

Got a feeling it will be a british coach,cheaper than bringing an NRL coach over

Re: Who do we want now then : Fri Mar 13, 2020 11:19 pm  

Aswilco93 wrote:

Has to be Steve McNamara for me, has the right sort of pedigree, knows the club but will be more distant from the players (son in the academy aside) Would command the respect of the full squad, most realistic option IMO.
Also Catalans squad isn’t too dissimilar from ours so he will have an idea straight away in terms of style of play etc. hopefully if he is one we are keen on we can pry him away - whoever comes in I think needs experience dealing with ‘big name’ players and can manage a dressing room full of egos!

I'm guessing you weren't in the threeepenny stand when he deliberately kicked the ball at the Hull fans from fairly close range after leaving the club for Bradford Bulls in a similar way to the way Radford ditched his 'home town club' even though we were on the verge of promotion to super league.

The day McNamara is hired is the day i start a 'McNamara Out' thread.

(I don't rate his coaching skills anyway)

Re: Who do we want now then : Fri Mar 13, 2020 11:27 pm  

McNamara please no

Tbh im leading to Iain Watson if were going down the uk route. Wanes just another forward merchant

If we dont go in for Watson then i bet Warrington do when Price leaves

Re: Who do we want now then : Fri Mar 13, 2020 11:43 pm  

Ian Watson for me but would LOVE Shane Flanagan

Re: Who do we want now then : Sat Mar 14, 2020 3:46 am  

Personally my top 3 would be..
1.Shane Flanagan.
2.Nathan Brown.
3.Ian Watson.

For mine, we need someone who is experienced in man-management,
the attitude and culture needs a total reset...

At this moment in time, an inexperienced Head Coach, or a coach from a lower division would be a massive gamble - IMO

Re: Who do we want now then : Sat Mar 14, 2020 10:57 am  

weaver93 wrote:

Personally my top 3 would be..
1.Shane Flanagan.
2.Nathan Brown.
3.Ian Watson.

For mine, we need someone who is experienced in man-management,
the attitude and culture needs a total reset...

At this moment in time, an inexperienced Head Coach, or a coach from a lower division would be a massive gamble - IMO

Brown or Watson for me

Will Flanagan be able to coach over here? I know he cant get a top job in the NRL for a few years. The RFL might take a similar stance and uphold his ban.

The other name i've seen thrown about is Barrett, don't know enough about him coaching wise though. It all seemed to go very wrong towards the end of his time at Manly.

I'd look to move Last on too. He's been part of the pally pally culture that has been built.

Promote KP to assistant, reduce Ellis playing time and move him onto the coaching.

Re: Who do we want now then : Sat Mar 14, 2020 1:11 pm  

Flanagan will stick around for the St. George’s job.
Not sure about Brown. Would he be what we need?. Not sure he plays the expansive game AP is wanting.
Whatever happens, we need someone from outside the Hull bubble.

[Chris71]

Re: Who do we want now then : Sat Mar 14, 2020 1:29 pm  

Think Watson would be the one to go out for UK based. He has shown to be very astute and his teams play an open expansive style. If you look at the Salford teams they have mainly consisted of players other teams haven’t wanted. Yet he has managed to get them working together as one with structured play and in the face of major upheaval of playing personal throughout their seasons.

He’s probably the only one I’d go that’s involved in the British game. Flanagan is probably the pick of the bunch in Australia sure there’ll be interest from many.

Re: Who do we want now then : Sat Mar 14, 2020 1:43 pm  

If we don’t go for Watson I’m sure Wire will eventually.

Re: Who do we want now then : Sat Mar 14, 2020 3:08 pm  

mwindass wrote:

Brown or Watson for me

Will Flanagan be able to coach over here? I know he cant get a top job in the NRL for a few years. The RFL might take a similar stance and uphold his ban.

The other name i've seen thrown about is Barrett, don't know enough about him coaching wise though. It all seemed to go very wrong towards the end of his time at Manly.

I'd look to move Last on too. He's been part of the pally pally culture that has been built.

Promote KP to assistant, reduce Ellis playing time and move him onto the coaching.

I'd be looking to move Last on asap, the club needs a new sweep..
Cant see Watson coming imminently, maybe next season, personally I'd stick with Purtill & Ellis, until our main target is more easier to prise away..
until our targets are