Re: New Coach, Who? : Thu May 28, 2015 10:35 am  

Mr Bliss wrote:

Dr Koocash would have his media team working overtime on this one, especially if there are some promising unexpected candidates

While it is quiet may I offer an opinion - after firstly suggesting that Dr Koukash,despite stating after the television deal was agreed that 'You don't marry the first girl you meet',did seem to offer Brian Noble the head coach position without interviewing anyone else.I would guess that 'figures at the RFL' suggested Brian Noble to him.

In the case of Wakefield Trinity Wildcats would I be correct in thinking that you require a temporary motivator and the same person who can nurture young players over the coming seasons?

Whomever it was who suggested telephoning Daniel Anderson and Mick Potter,and seeking their advice,may have called it absolutely correctly.

Good luck...

Re: New Coach, Who? : Thu May 28, 2015 10:40 am  

vastman wrote:

FWIW I don't want an Aussie coach. I don't think they are right for a club like ours, certainly not those straight off the plane. I'm not doubting their ability, far from it. However there are similarities between NRL clubs and the likes of Wigan and Leeds. There are no similarities between Wakefield and the NRL. I'm afraid and I feel the culture shock would take more time to get over than there is time available. I'll make an exception with Woods because he has done his time so to speak.

The beauty of a local British coach is they know the ropes and they actually know the players rather than their stats etc. Someone like Andy Kelly or JK will have been monitoring some players since they were 10 years old and they know what sort of players and individuals they are - they don't need the opinions of other possibly more biased people. They are not necessarily better coached just better coaches for the position we are in.

In the short term it's buy British for me.

I 100% agree, and by looks of it, so do the SL chairmen. There's only 1 Aussie head coach left in Super league and he has been over here for donkeys. Quite the change from years gone by.

Brits know our game and know our players.

Re: New Coach, Who? : Thu May 28, 2015 11:00 am  

Roonaldo6 wrote:

Thanks

You're still a good friend of the bookies I see - if you ever want to do the fanzine again you know where I am (free from restraints this time, within reason of course)

Re: New Coach, Who? : Thu May 28, 2015 11:06 am  

vastman wrote:

You're still a good friend of the bookies I see - if you ever want to do the fanzine again you know where I am (free from restraints this time, within reason of course)

Wouldn't say a good friend !!

Just thought this market might be one to have a go at considering the number of people who know what goes on at the club !

[PopTart]

Re: New Coach, Who? : Thu May 28, 2015 11:27 am  

Bet Victor have these options, in odds order:

Michael Monaghan
John Kear
Brian Smith
Glenn Morrison
JD
Dave Woods
Brian Noble
Willie Poaching
Andy Hay
Andy Kelly
Phil Vievers
Chris Thorman
Karl Harrison
Ian Millward
Paul Cooke
Bobby Goulding
Danny Orr

Re: New Coach, Who? : Thu May 28, 2015 11:28 am  

I agree with Vasty that an Aussie coach who doesn't know the players and where we've been going wrong isn't the short term fix we need. Having said that, if Brian Smith is in the frame, and the bookies are seldom wrong, that would be impressive. A coach with real calibre who has coached in this country before so won't have the accompanying culture shock. He will know what he's getting. If the players can't respond to someone like him, we've no hope.

Re: New Coach, Who? : Thu May 28, 2015 11:31 am  

PopTart wrote:

Bet Victor have these options, in odds order:

Michael Monaghan
John Kear
Brian Smith
Glenn Morrison
JD
Dave Woods
Brian Noble
Willie Poaching
Andy Hay
Andy Kelly
Phil Vievers
Chris Thorman
Karl Harrison
Ian Millward
Paul Cooke
Bobby Goulding
Danny Orr

Two to six all seem like good choices. Monaghan is a curious one. Has played under a very good coach but not been part of the coaching set-up with one, so not clear whether he can bring any great methods. And would anyone give up a good number in the south of france to risk everything on a basket case like us?

[PopTart]

Re: New Coach, Who? : Thu May 28, 2015 11:37 am  

Smith's son Keegan is also the strength and power coach at the Roosters
and other son Rohan is a coach who has worked as his assistant twice and coached the Tongan team.

Ready made team to bring over too.

Re: New Coach, Who? : Thu May 28, 2015 11:40 am  

Slugger McBatt wrote:

I agree with Vasty that an Aussie coach who doesn't know the players and where we've been going wrong isn't the short term fix we need. Having said that, if Brian Smith is in the frame, and the bookies are seldom wrong, that would be impressive. A coach with real calibre who has coached in this country before so won't have the accompanying culture shock. He will know what he's getting. If the players can't respond to someone like him, we've no hope.

and he would have a good idea of the workings of the club, including the culture etc from his brother and the Richard Agar connection - if, as you say, he is in the 'frame'.

Re: New Coach, Who? : Thu May 28, 2015 11:45 am  

I would be very impressed and happy if Brian Smith was our next coach.

Unfortunately, history says we are not that lucky