Re: junior rugby 2014 : Sat Mar 22, 2014 5:42 pm  

muttley cat wrote:

It's always a sad occasion when such a nasty injury occurs .
Maybe its about time that match officials appointed for the game could make a decision on whom they think would go on and win . Taking into account that the team as lost that player but if its been as a result of foul play then judging the offending team to of had a man sent off.

A knowledgeable Ref could maybe look at the flow , chances , kick success etc and make a common sense call.
1 home/away win
2 if the scores are tied in last quarter call a draw
3 if there is only 1 try in it replay
4 refs call

its not hard and you could have standard results.

i mainly hope the young un gets well soon

Tbh I'm a bit surprised and also a little dissapointed that siddal are appealing. Make no mistake siddal were a beaten side and long before the injury they were dropping like nine pins.there was no foul play involved in the injury the lad just slipped going into the tackle.

Either way whatever happens regards the result you after accept it.

Panthers vs Crigg tomorrow is usually a good game and I don't think it will be any different in the morning.

Re: junior rugby 2014 : Sat Mar 22, 2014 11:39 pm  

braytontiger wrote:

Tbh I'm a bit surprised and also a little dissapointed that siddal are appealing. Make no mistake siddal were a beaten side and long before the injury they were dropping like nine pins.there was no foul play involved in the injury the lad just slipped going into the tackle.

Either way whatever happens regards the result you after accept it.

Panthers vs Crigg tomorrow is usually a good game and I don't think it will be any different in the morning.

I think the problem arises from the lack on consistency and the fact the league has discresion.
Last season Siddal v Shaw Cross was abandoned with 5 minutes remaining and Siddal winning by 8 points,No foul play involved with the injury to the Shaw Cross lad,noting though Shaw Cross didnt have any subs,so if play had resumed they would have played out the final 5 minutes with 12 men.
The points were awarded to Siddal,Shaw Cross appealed and the fixture had to be replayed.
In my view YJL set a precedent ordering the above match to be replayed.
I would agree Siddal were looking a beaten team at the point of the injury,but who knows, they were on the Cas 20/30 with 6 tackles in the bag,the elements at their back and over a third of the game remaining.

For the record i thought Panthers looked very good and have a built on last season.
BTW The injured lad will be out for 6/8 weeks - torn cartliage.

Re: junior rugby 2014 : Sun Mar 23, 2014 1:09 pm  

BARLA cup: East Leeds 40 - Oulton Vikings 16. Vikings leading 16-12 10 minutes in to the 2nd half more than matching East Leeds with the rugby we played, game got away from us as their physicality proved the difference. Pleasing performance from our boys.

Re: junior rugby 2014 : Sun Mar 23, 2014 3:12 pm  

Siddal u14s lost 10-6 against East Hull in Barla cup.

Re: junior rugby 2014 : Sun Mar 23, 2014 7:26 pm  

Panthers and Crigg fought out a 16-16 draw, I only saw the second half but it was certainly physical on what I saw!!!!

Re: junior rugby 2014 : Sun Mar 23, 2014 8:27 pm  

braytontiger wrote:

I only saw the second half but it was certainly physical on what I saw!!!!

Well if you only saw the 2nd half you saw most of the game, 38mins, dunno how a ref manages to find 8mins of extra time in a 30min per half game especially when you only play 25 mins in the first half

Good game though and 2 evenly matched teams fighting it out in the main in a sportsman like manner

Re: junior rugby 2014 : Mon Mar 24, 2014 9:53 am  

TURFEDOUT wrote:

Siddal u14s lost 10-6 against East Hull in Barla cup.

This game was recorded has a league game on Yorkshire juniors.

Re: junior rugby 2014 : Mon Mar 24, 2014 10:03 am  

financialtimes wrote:

Well if you only saw the 2nd half you saw most of the game, 38mins, dunno how a ref manages to find 8mins of extra time in a 30min per half game especially when you only play 25 mins in the first half

Good game though and 2 evenly matched teams fighting it out in the main in a sportsman like manner

Like I said I didn't see the first half but ill take your word that the second half lasted 38 mins. That Said there were a few stoppages during the half which would account for some time and it wasn't as though the panthers scored on the last play both teams had at least 3 sets to try and win the game.

I'll agree it was a good game with a bit of biff too. A lot of the lads get on off the field and I'm sure they are all mates again, it must be strange for the lads on training camps who are team mates on Saturday and best of enemies on Sunday it all makes for a good game.!!

Re: junior rugby 2014 : Mon Mar 24, 2014 12:24 pm  

braytontiger wrote:

This game was recorded has a league game on Yorkshire juniors.

Ay , and according to the guy who updates all leagues for Pitchero Under 14s Automated sites the YJL informed him it was a League game Along with East Leeds ect .

HE IS NOT A HAPPY MAN AND WILL CHANE THE TABLES ETC LATER SO STOP EMAILING HIM

Re: junior rugby 2014 : Mon Mar 24, 2014 12:33 pm  

muttley cat wrote:

Ay , and according to the guy who updates all leagues for Pitchero Under 14s Automated sites the YJL informed him it was a League game Along with East Leeds ect .

HE IS NOT A HAPPY MAN AND WILL CHANE THE TABLES ETC LATER SO STOP EMAILING HIM

Not guilty mutts I don't do emails