Re: Squad for semi : Thu Jul 28, 2016 3:01 pm  

PopTart wrote:

Warrington Squad is as strong as it could be:

If we are going to win we will deserve it beating that team.
Though there is some speculation that as Declan Patton has been named, there must be some doubt over either Ratchford, Sandow or Gidley

Please let it be Sandow, please

Re: Squad for semi : Thu Jul 28, 2016 3:04 pm  

Prince Buster wrote:

I really can't believe Bill tupou is fit so he would not be in my 17.

That leaves Yates, Walton and Crowther for the last two spots.
Size, age and experience rules, so Crowther to miss out for me.

Fully agree with this.
Walton can play second row, no problem and gives us some cover at centre.

Re: Squad for semi : Thu Jul 28, 2016 3:09 pm  

karetaker wrote:

What's wrong with Jack Hughes.

Looks to be a bit of a passenger at times. Just my opinion when watching Wire on telly. Maybe he saves his best for non televised games?

Re: Squad for semi : Thu Jul 28, 2016 3:25 pm  

Wollo-Wollo-Wollo-Wayoo wrote:

Looks to be a bit of a passenger at times. Just my opinion when watching Wire on telly. Maybe he saves his best for non televised games?

Just a good solid player but not spectacular,was a lot better before his injury.

[PopTart]

Re: Squad for semi : Thu Jul 28, 2016 3:43 pm  

karetaker wrote:

Just a good solid player but not spectacular,was a lot better before his injury.

I'm sure he'll have the game of his life against us.

In all seriousness, every team needs some steady players to go along side the superstars. Not being noticed at Warrington is probably a pretty good standard.

Re: Squad for semi : Thu Jul 28, 2016 4:00 pm  

Crowther a deffo no go for me nowt against him but wouldnt play him other depends on billy injury.yates would be a yes he never let us down

Re: Squad for semi : Thu Jul 28, 2016 4:10 pm  

leedscat wrote:

Crowther a deffo no go for me nowt against him but wouldnt play him other depends on billy injury.yates would be a yes he never let us down

I'd have no issue with either - there isn't a player under 30 (diplomatic) in the team who doesn't deserve a chance, nine have let us down.

Re: Squad for semi : Thu Jul 28, 2016 5:03 pm  

leedscat wrote:

Crowther a deffo no go for me nowt against him but wouldnt play him other depends on billy injury.yates would be a yes he never let us down

Crowther would be in for me. Never lets us down on the field. Very rarely misses a tackle too.
Plus, he doesn't deserve to be dropped after the Cas game. I think he missed like one tackle.

Yates and B.Tupou to miss for me.

Re: Squad for semi : Thu Jul 28, 2016 5:15 pm  

W.T.W wrote:

Crowther would be in for me. Never lets us down on the field. Very rarely misses a tackle too.
Plus, he doesn't deserve to be dropped after the Cas game. I think he missed like one tackle.

Yates and B.Tupou to miss for me.

All about opinions personnally i dont think jordan is good enough.cas game showed it only 2 things stick out where he dropped ball on 1st or 2nd tackle in there 20 and he misses moors on the line for his try.nothin against the lad just seen nothin in him

Re: Squad for semi : Thu Jul 28, 2016 5:58 pm  

leedscat wrote:

All about opinions personnally i dont think jordan is good enough.cas game showed it only 2 things stick out where he dropped ball on 1st or 2nd tackle in there 20 and he misses moors on the line for his try.nothin against the lad just seen nothin in him

Watch it again, the two at the side of him let him over, plus how many have stopped Moors from 2ft out, regarding the dropped ball, just has he gathered it he was hit and admits it was a good hit. One dropped ball in 60 mins wasn't bad I don't think. I'd like t see the tackling stats for the whole team, I don't think he'll be far away, but like you say it's all about opinions