: Sat Feb 14, 2009 1:01 pm  

adam9641 wrote:

If i got elbowed I would last out too, think most players would. Just an instant reaction.

I know what your saying mate but ablett was already tackled and down so lashing out at someone down on the deck is pretty poor imo.
And IIRC ryan wasn't elbowed in that incident was he??

: Sat Feb 14, 2009 1:03 pm  

rhinoms wrote:

I know what your saying mate but ablett was already tackled and down so lashing out at someone down on the deck is pretty poor imo.
And IIRC ryan wasn't elbowed in that incident was he??

Pretty sure he was. He got elbowed so he smacked him. But both players were in wrong I guess, but I can see what you say. Could maybe of kept his cool. Did it all get put on report though?

: Sat Feb 14, 2009 1:05 pm  

adam9641 wrote:

Pretty sure he was. He got elbowed so he smacked him. But both players were in wrong I guess, but I can see what you say. Could maybe of kept his cool. Did it all get put on report though?

That one didn't but bailey did.
I'm sure the disciplinary panel reviw all the incidents automatically though because the peacock v peek incident was reviewed with no further action taken.

: Sat Feb 14, 2009 1:06 pm  

rhinoms wrote:

That one didn't but bailey did.
I'm sure the disciplinary panel reviw all the incidents automatically though because the peacock v peek incident was reviewed with no further action taken.

What went on with Bailey? I missed that one

When you get in sin bin I did not think you could get a ban? Like Mathers last week got put in sin bin but got 2 game ban thought you only got ban if you got red or put on report?

: Sat Feb 14, 2009 1:22 pm  

adam9641 wrote:

What went on with Bailey? I missed that one :?

When you get in sin bin I did not think you could get a ban? Like Mathers last week got put in sin bin but got 2 game ban thought you only got ban if you got red or put on report?

He was put on report for leading with the forearm/elbow on gleeson/henderson i think!!
The review board seem to check every incident from every match nowadays and TBF i think that's fair enough as long as the punishments fit the crimes and are consistent throughout the season.

: Sat Feb 14, 2009 1:25 pm  

rhinoms wrote:

He was put on report for leading with the forearm/elbow on gleeson/henderson i think!!
The review board seem to check every incident from every match nowadays and TBF i think that's fair enough as long as the punishments fit the crimes and are consistent throughout the season.

Agreed, that's all we ask for consistent decisions!

Well done on the win last night, well deserved. Enjoyed the game.

: Sat Feb 14, 2009 1:29 pm  

adam9641 wrote:

Agreed, that's all we ask for consistent decisions!

Well done on the win last night, well deserved. Enjoyed the game.

Same here mate good luck for the rest of year!!

: Sun Feb 15, 2009 8:42 am  

adam9641 wrote:

What went on with Bailey? I missed that one

When you get in sin bin I did not think you could get a ban? Like Mathers last week got put in sin bin but got 2 game ban thought you only got ban if you got red or put on report?

He pretty much complained about every decision and seems to think that if anyone dares tackle him he should get a penalty. About time someone sat him on his backside again like Sculthorpe did a few years back.