Re: Shaun Wane : Sat Nov 20, 2021 8:50 am  

sergeant pepper wrote:

This isn't necessarily aimed at you, but I'm really confused by the apathy that gets directed towards Byrne by some of our fans?

Being a good prop is not somewhere in the lad. He's a good prop now.

He's 22 and has played more games, at his age, than other more established props had at the same point in their careers. I look at Walmsley, the best prop in a league, and when you compare the two at the age Byrne is - Byrne is well ahead of him in regards to SL games played and what they've achieved.

I'd pick Byrne over any of the youngsters in our squad. He'll improve massively, just like guys like Dudson, Mossop and Mulhern did but he's still a good option (for his age) now.

Perhaps I chose my words badly.
Maybe I should have said a much better player resides inside him.

Like yourself, of the current crop of youngsters I think that Byrne could be the best of them. I’ve only seen Nicholson once but wouldn’t be surprised if he ultimately could be the best youngster we’ve brought through the ranks in a generation.

I said in a previous post I think SW is probably using a bit of reverse psychology with Byrne. After watching the interview I’m even more convinced there is a few mind games going on.

Re: Shaun Wane : Sat Nov 20, 2021 8:56 am  

Jordan Rankin wrote:

Let’s face it, The whole league needs to see an improvement to try and catch and push Saints and Catalans, otherwise it’s just a race to the bottom.

Anybody who thinks Wane shouting “SmashUmUp” in training is going to make huge improvements is living in the past. In 2018 (not that long ago……) Wane somehow inspired a team to punch so far above their weight it was untrue, and winning that GF was an amazing achievement but it’s not likely to be repeated with the diminished team left at the DW, and are you Wigan fans not worried that Wane might undermine a new coaching setup who have the opportunity to build something new?

Yip
What a career he's had with no coaching/man management skills

Anyone who thinks Wane is nothing more than a shouts at players bully really hasn't got a clue.

Re: Shaun Wane : Sat Nov 20, 2021 10:10 am  

Itchy Arsenal wrote:

Perhaps I chose my words badly.
Maybe I should have said a much better player resides inside him.

Like yourself, of the current crop of youngsters I think that Byrne could be the best of them. I’ve only seen Nicholson once but wouldn’t be surprised if he ultimately could be the best youngster we’ve brought through the ranks in a generation.

I said in a previous post I think SW is probably using a bit of reverse psychology with Byrne. After watching the interview I’m even more convinced there is a few mind games going on.

I'm a big Liam Byrne fan, any prop that can play open age at sixteen years of age has something about him. The first time I really saw him was in the Capital Challenge game down in London. His first carry was manic.

As others have said we forget how young he still is especially for a prop forward, he along with a few others probably had to play too much without having a couple of old heads in the pack, I do wish we'd have signed Chrill Hill for a season or two.

Going to watch the Wane interview now, should be fun.

Re: Shaun Wane : Sat Nov 20, 2021 11:44 am  

Just finished watching that Wane interview, you get the impression that he wasn't happy with the discipline around the dressing room last season, timekeeping was continually referenced.

Re: Shaun Wane : Sat Nov 20, 2021 12:25 pm  

Bevan obviously should stay home as long as necessary - some things more important than throwing a rugby ball about. Sounds like his mum might be receiving end of life care so not sure how anyone would expect him to be back in those circumstances. I'm sure he'll be back in a Wigan shirt at some point.

Re: Shaun Wane : Sat Nov 20, 2021 1:31 pm  

You only have to listen to the podcasts he has been on to get the measure of the man. I have the upmost respect for him and his methods. Some of the things he says is worth a listen to any leader/manager and a lot of what he says I take into my job.

I have no doubt whatsoever he will drive the culture change alongside Peet. I haven’t watched this yet, hoping to soon but I am really, really encouraged by recent events and I for one cannot wait to get the season underway!

I am also going to take back what I said re Bevan and needing to be back. The circumstances he is under are impossible, circumstances we weren’t really aware of and in all fairness have no divine right to know. Thoughts are with him and his family.

Re: Shaun Wane : Sat Nov 20, 2021 1:37 pm  

Loved Wane when he was coaching. Thought of him as a Wigan man who loved the club and would get the message through to the players that they had to run through a brick wall to win.

Since he’s left and he’s starting these feature length interviews (Out of your league podcast, the high performance podcast, take flight podcast) I’ve seen a different side of him.

The level of detail he has and his mindset in life is amazing. He has constant improvement. Make good better.

Throwing Noble under the bus for not trying to improve Lockers because he was a good player. He wouldn’t have it.

No wonder big businesses pay him to do talks. What a bloke.

So confident we will see an improved performance next year.

Re: Shaun Wane : Sat Nov 20, 2021 1:43 pm  

Mentioned Noble a couple of times didn’t he?! Sounded like he’s not a fan.

Re: Shaun Wane : Sat Nov 20, 2021 2:10 pm  

Jukesays wrote:

Yip
What a career he's had with no coaching/man management skills

Anyone who thinks Wane is nothing more than a shouts at players bully really hasn't got a clue.

NickyKiss wrote:

He’s had a good career with that one phrase in fairness.

Is it enough nowadays?

He’s worked wonders in the past, especially 2018 but with a much better pool of players and leaders on the pitch (EG OLauchlin) but it will take some building/rebuilding to be anywhere near 2018 levels when Wigan did a Leeds and turned it on for exactly the right few games at the end of the season and won it.

Genuinely want to see Wigan improve, both in results and performance to push the top teams but going back to Wane (especially when most in this forum wanted him out and weren’t enjoying watching the anti-rugby and wrestle) seems like a backward step.

For the love of the game, there needs to be a step up in skill and play, and Wane’s cry for “intensity” doesn’t sound like a step forward and upward to me.

As I said, if teams don’t improve and challenge the top teams, those teams don’t need to play as well and it’s a race to the bottom.

No-one wants to see St Helens cantering to easy trophies every season, even Saints fans! Everyone wants to see a ding-dong challenge on Good Friday and in the Grand Final or CC….


A victory hard fought tastes sweeter than a walkover.

Re: Shaun Wane : Sat Nov 20, 2021 2:19 pm  

Jordan Rankin wrote:

Is it enough nowadays?

He’s worked wonders in the past, especially 2018 but with a much better pool of players and leaders on the pitch (EG OLauchlin) but it will take some building/rebuilding to be anywhere near 2018 levels when Wigan did a Leeds and turned it on for exactly the right few games at the end of the season and won it.

Genuinely want to see Wigan improve, both in results and performance to push the top teams but going back to Wane (especially when most in this forum wanted him out and weren’t enjoying watching the anti-rugby and wrestle) seems like a backward step.

For the love of the game, there needs to be a step up in skill and play, and Wane’s cry for “intensity” doesn’t sound like a step forward and upward to me.

As I said, if teams don’t improve and challenge the top teams, those teams don’t need to play as well and it’s a race to the bottom.

No-one wants to see St Helens cantering to easy trophies every season, even Saints fans! Everyone wants to see a ding-dong challenge on Good Friday and in the Grand Final or CC….


A victory hard fought tastes sweeter than a walkover.

I take it you don't get sarcasm???

The myth that shaun Wane is a coach who only screams at players to get the best out of them is that, an absolute myth

So no, it isn't enough, it hadn't been for 30plus years
But shaun Wane is far more than that