: Tue Apr 21, 2009 10:15 am  

Rocky Bobby wrote:

Deluded, utterly deluded....

What...so lets guess...you think he is world class dont you?

: Tue Apr 21, 2009 10:26 am  

Tried to put together a young, English 1-13 of potential transfer targets! Just on the games I have seen may have missed out others but nonetheless here it goes:

1. Richard Owen
2. Peter Fox
3. Michael Shenton
4. Michael Lawerence
5. Leroy Cudjoe
6. Sam Tomkins
7. Richie Myler
8. LMS
9. Scott Moore
10. Sam Burgess (Not a good season but the potential is still there)
11. Luke Adamson
12. Joel Tomkins
13. Joe Westerman

: Tue Apr 21, 2009 10:28 am  

RL Lover wrote:

What...so lets guess...you think he is world class dont you?

He's up there, yes. And he's just getting into form now gelling with a great team. To compare him to Tatupu is ridiculous - the only similarity is the physical build. I'm wasting my breath here. Keep dreaming kiddo.

: Tue Apr 21, 2009 10:34 am  

Not sure what people have got against Paul Sykes, up till recently everybody was saying that he's the type of player who should get a shot at international level rather than same old faces of Senior, Gleeson etc. Tony Smith rates him anyway.

Tony Clubb is another worth a mention as a younger option.

: Tue Apr 21, 2009 10:36 am  

I would really like Myler and Westerman. Westerman can kick goals although i am not sure how well.

I'll go along with all the hype surrounding Shenton, so i'll have him too. Same with Atkins

However said Sykes - You are Sykes agent and I claim my ten pounds (or has someone slapped you silly)

May as well have Graham, Roby and Eastmond too

: Tue Apr 21, 2009 10:39 am  

The problem when you sign good "young" players from other clubs is that they are coming to you because of the premium you pay on wages compared to what you pay players developed "in-house" eg incentive to move.

To be honest I do not think we have the need to look outside of the club for young talent at the moment.

Although Tony Clubb is a good call.

: Tue Apr 21, 2009 10:40 am  

Rocky Bobby wrote:

Deluded, utterly deluded....

Exactly. Tatupu had the odd moment, like that home win over Wigan but generally not in the same class as Puletua who has been the best forward in Super League so far this year IMO.

Like your sig by the way, one of the funniest shows on TV...

The Rhyme-nocerous and HipHop-apotamous. Genius.

: Tue Apr 21, 2009 10:58 am  

Puletua is indeed a big unit but IMO i dont think he is anything other than decent.

If you have other opinions of him then thats great.

Lets not get over excited about it tho

: Tue Apr 21, 2009 11:31 am  

FireWire wrote:

Exactly. Tatupu had the odd moment, like that home win over Wigan but generally not in the same class as Puletua who has been the best forward in Super League so far this year IMO.

Like your sig by the way, one of the funniest shows on TV...

The Rhyme-nocerous and HipHop-apotamous. Genius.

Tatupu had oodles of talent. Unfortunately, he had much more can'tbearsed.

: Tue Apr 21, 2009 11:41 am  

Paul Youane wrote:

The problem when you sign good "young" players from other clubs is that they are coming to you because of the premium you pay on wages compared to what you pay players developed "in-house" eg incentive to move.

To be honest I do not think we have the need to look outside of the club for young talent at the moment.

Although Tony Clubb is a good call.

Surely you pay the market rate, the influencing factor is going to be on whether the player is at or going to a club where he fancies his chances of winning trophies and enhancing his international aspirations.

Eg Saints Academy player comes through the ranks, plays in the first team, offered a new contract on £45000 a year. Warrington offer £50000 a year, he probably says no whats the point. Warrington offer £65000 a year, maybe he's tempted. He comes when we offer him £75000.

Reverse situation, Warrington Academy player comes through the ranks, plays in the first team, offered a contract on £45000 a year. Saints offer to match it at £45000 a year and promise him first team action. Do Saints need to offer a premium because he's not trained 'in house', or does he say cheers for the memories guys, I'm off to get some medals.