Re: Today’s game v Hull : Mon Aug 28, 2023 4:38 pm  

Fantastic Mr Catpiss wrote:

And was pretty mickey poor in defence iirc, looking like a stranger

As pointed out Matautia has been mickey poor in defence ever since he has arrived without the excuse of being young or recovering from an ACL. I don’t think anyone is saying he is the next Mal Meninga but he’s definitely been deserving of a starting berth ahead of Matautia and yes he would’ve made lots of mistakes etc but that’s the journey the top sides put their youngsters through.

Wrench may not be the answer but he’s a very gifted rugby player that needs persevering with.

Re: Today’s game v Hull : Mon Aug 28, 2023 4:43 pm  

He’s also scored (in the 6 games he’s played) more tries and made more clean breaks than Matautia.

Re: Today’s game v Hull : Mon Aug 28, 2023 4:43 pm  

I think what is true about Wrench and King is that neither is as good or as bad as their supporters or detractors make out. I'd be happy if our back line next year was Dufty, Thewlis, Wrench, King, Ashton.

I'm very happy (relieved) about Dwyer.

I really wish we could keep Mikaele, it's surely no coincidence our upturn in form has coincided with his return.

Vaughan and Mikaele starting props next year with Bullock, Harrison, Kasiano as first choice interchange and a back row of Currie, Fitzgibbon, Nicholson, Philbin looks good.

Williams is obviously class.

Re: Today’s game v Hull : Mon Aug 28, 2023 4:50 pm  

Mikaele isn’t going to hang around for a full season unfortunately. If we can get Tom Burgess instead that would soften the blow.

Re: Today’s game v Hull : Mon Aug 28, 2023 4:56 pm  

Wires71 wrote: No you are wrong as can be proved by bothering to watch the video. https://www.skysports.com/watch/video/s ... highlights Thewlis was level with Swift and facing the same direction. In fact he hesitated tackling him initially. Swift outpaced him dramatically Thewlis wasnt in the video frame when Swift scored in fact I think he stopped chasing. Maybe Thewlis is injured I am not making anything of it but we do need to make our comments accurate. No need, I saw the whole game. I’m not wrong if it was only my thought. I was not stating a fact. I thought he looked the liveliest when he came on. However I’m always welcome to correction. What does seem more solid, is the hot air blowing about Dwyer to Wire has clearly gone cold. I don’t expect him at Wire again. That too is just my opinion and not statement of fact.

Wires71 wrote: No you are wrong as can be proved by bothering to watch the video. https://www.skysports.com/watch/video/s ... highlights Thewlis was level with Swift and facing the same direction. In fact he hesitated tackling him initially. Swift outpaced him dramatically Thewlis wasnt in the video frame when Swift scored in fact I think he stopped chasing. Maybe Thewlis is injured I am not making anything of it but we do need to make our comments accurate. No need, I saw the whole game. I’m not wrong if it was only my thought. I was not stating a fact. I thought he looked the liveliest when he came on. However I’m always welcome to correction. What does seem more solid, is the hot air blowing about Dwyer to Wire has clearly gone cold. I don’t expect him at Wire again. That too is just my opinion and not statement of fact.

Re: Today’s game v Hull : Mon Aug 28, 2023 6:03 pm  

Fantastic Mr Catpiss wrote:

Why are we so set on moving King on?

Well in his Wire days ...

Pros
1. He could collect a cross field kick and score.

Cons
1. He lacked pace.
2. He didn't create opportunities for his winger.
3. His defensive positioning was all over the place, often shooting out of the line.
4. He insisted on training with his dog.
5. He's a little forgetful of essential ID documents.

Re: Today’s game v Hull : Mon Aug 28, 2023 7:50 pm  

Nantwich One wrote:

Where's the reference to new contract??? ... Again to reiterate I have suggested we use him within his existing contract rather than just sideline to see in regards to his value going forward rather than just let it go somewhere else ...we give established players all year to do not much such as matautia but won't take a punt on the potential of the young players

I didn’t say anything about him getting. a new contract. My point was that we have in the past overestimated how much “top” teams would want our younger players which has in the past led us to give them contracts above and beyond their worth. The fear of King going to Saints being the ultimate example.

Re: Today’s game v Hull : Mon Aug 28, 2023 7:53 pm  

Wires71 wrote:

Well in his Wire days ...

Pros
1. He could collect a cross field kick and score.

Cons
1. He lacked pace.
2. He didn't create opportunities for his winger.
3. His defensive positioning was all over the place, often shooting out of the line.
4. He insisted on training with his dog.
5. He's a little forgetful of essential ID documents.

6. The rest of the squad now have to hold their pee in, all the way home along the M62, just to prevent somebody going AWOL at Hartshead Moor services?

Re: Today’s game v Hull : Mon Aug 28, 2023 8:33 pm  

Maybe Wrench is being seen as a winger these days? If he was playing wing in the reserves that seems plausible…?

Re: Today’s game v Hull : Mon Aug 28, 2023 8:42 pm  

To be fair to Toby King he can also offload.

And as he shares the top three cons with Mata'utia I'd call it even.

I'd like to see Wrench stay and I saw his future more on the wing, when Thewlis moves to FB in 25 whether he would be content to hang around providing bench cover is another thing.