The Nadir of English Rugby League : Sat Nov 12, 2022 6:50 pm  

A poor england team, losing to a secondary nation in a semi final on home soil, in a half-empty stadium.

It comes off the back of a period in which super league is just really really really really poor and everyone is crap apart from a half decent saints, who think they're a seminal team.

I don't think this world cup has achieved anything, just feels like going through the motions. ''oh we're supposed to have a world cup aren't we? that's what international sports do, ok go on then let's put one on''.

Good luck to Samoa in the final, hopefully they can keep it below 50. NRL team plays NRL team in the final. Kel-surprise.

Re: The Nadir of English Rugby League : Sat Nov 12, 2022 6:53 pm  

FlexWheeler wrote:

A poor england team, losing to a secondary nation in a semi final on home soil, in a half-empty stadium.

It comes off the back of a period in which super league is just really really really really poor and everyone is crap apart from a half decent saints, who think they're a seminal team.

I don't think this world cup has achieved anything, just feels like going through the motions. ''oh we're supposed to have a world cup aren't we? that's what international sports do, ok go on then let's put one on''.

Good luck to Samoa in the final, hopefully they can keep it below 50. NRL team plays NRL team in the final. Kel-surprise.

Stadium was two thirds full.

Re: The Nadir of English Rugby League : Sat Nov 12, 2022 6:59 pm  

Egg Chasing wrote:

Stadium was two thirds full.

Factually, maybe. But it looks half empty on tv.

Re: The Nadir of English Rugby League : Sat Nov 12, 2022 7:00 pm  

FlexWheeler wrote:

A poor england team, losing to a secondary nation in a semi final on home soil, in a half-empty stadium.

It comes off the back of a period in which super league is just really really really really poor and everyone is crap apart from a half decent saints, who think they're a seminal team.

I don't think this world cup has achieved anything, just feels like going through the motions. ''oh we're supposed to have a world cup aren't we? that's what international sports do, ok go on then let's put one on''.

Good luck to Samoa in the final, hopefully they can keep it below 50. NRL team plays NRL team in the final. Kel-surprise.

I think the attendances have been good and Samoa getting to the final is a great story. Plus exciting match today but from an England point of view it isn’t good enough. With that draw not making the final is a fail. Second best today.

We should be in the final and you talk about Samoa being a secondary nation but they’ll move above us in the rankings now, as will Australia.

Re: The Nadir of English Rugby League : Sun Nov 13, 2022 1:02 pm  

Problem we will have now is convincing the southern hemisphere sides to come over for test matches.
It's possible that Australia,N.Z, Tonga,Samoa,Fiji & PNG will create series between themselves...and why not?. Less travel for them and painful to say better competition for the Aussies/NZ.
We meanwhile have a poor quality league that's getting weaker filling up with sub standard overseas players. Also a national coach who picks his old mates regardless of form.
Summer rugby might be great for spectators but has made the product worse on the pitch. High percentage of tries scored is against tiring defences.
For me, we should run a season split between autumn & spring, with potential tours late may. Then have pre season in the height of summer, which I think would improve the skill work required & fitness.
Rant over!

Re: The Nadir of English Rugby League : Sun Nov 13, 2022 3:58 pm  

This was England's best chance for decades , the Aussie team definitely doesn't look as scary as any previous sides . Maybe Super League and the salary cap has been a dramatic failure and the quality of players has reduced globally . We have teams who are better at looking good on paper with tackles, metres gained , turnovers etc , we have just forgotten how to play rugby . I dont think many players for either England or Oz would make it into the 1994 sides.

[Bullseye]

Re: The Nadir of English Rugby League : Mon Nov 14, 2022 10:19 am  

doc999 wrote:

This was England's best chance for decades , the Aussie team definitely doesn't look as scary as any previous sides . Maybe Super League and the salary cap has been a dramatic failure and the quality of players has reduced globally . We have teams who are better at looking good on paper with tackles, metres gained , turnovers etc , we have just forgotten how to play rugby . I dont think many players for either England or Oz would make it into the 1994 sides.

Disagree. The Aussie team is definitely as good as ever in my view. The depth of players available in the NRL and the fact that players with islander heritage now make a larger proportion of them means we now have more tier 1 sides. The loss on Saturday was by the smallest of margins. No need to throw the baby out with the bathwater.

Re: The Nadir of English Rugby League : Mon Nov 14, 2022 11:19 am  

Bullseye wrote:

Disagree. The Aussie team is definitely as good as ever in my view. The depth of players available in the NRL and the fact that players with islander heritage now make a larger proportion of them means we now have more tier 1 sides. The loss on Saturday was by the smallest of margins. No need to throw the baby out with the bathwater.

The Aussies haven't been great. They were very lucky to beat New Zealand and they weren't in control of that game like they usually are. They will batter Samoa of course, their final was against England and they will have been enjoying that all week.

Re: The Nadir of English Rugby League : Mon Nov 14, 2022 7:53 pm  

Bullseye wrote:

Disagree. The Aussie team is definitely as good as ever in my view. The depth of players available in the NRL and the fact that players with islander heritage now make a larger proportion of them means we now have more tier 1 sides. The loss on Saturday was by the smallest of margins. No need to throw the baby out with the bathwater.

Not throwing the baby out , but the standard of rugby in my opinion seems to be dropping across the board , England dont have much competition for places , most of the side picks itself . I think its time to scrap the cap and let the sport grow. In my opinion there is no way on earth this Oz team would beat the 1994 team . They have always had multiple players who are impossible to deal with , I just dont see that in this side . GB also had players that were impossible to deal with like Offiah , Robinson but we are having to look back 20+ years .

Re: The Nadir of English Rugby League : Mon Nov 14, 2022 8:45 pm  

doc999 wrote:

Not throwing the baby out , but the standard of rugby in my opinion seems to be dropping across the board , England dont have much competition for places , most of the side picks itself . I think its time to scrap the cap and let the sport grow. In my opinion there is no way on earth this Oz team would beat the 1994 team . They have always had multiple players who are impossible to deal with , I just dont see that in this side . GB also had players that were impossible to deal with like Offiah , Robinson but we are having to look back 20+ years .

Wasn't the cap meant to improve things?