Gary Wheeler/17 for Sunday? : Mon Sep 12, 2011 12:39 pm  

From all accounts on Saturday he was our man of the match. IF he stays fit, does he get back into 17 for Sunday? What if Eastmond is fit as well? Plenty of headaches for Royce if everyone bar Perry, Gardner and Magennis is fit.

For me, all being well and optimistic:

Wellens, Foster, Shenton, Wheeler, Meli, Pryce, Lomax, Graham, Roby, LMS, Wilkin, Soliola, TP: Subs: Clough, Moore, Eastmond, Flannery.

Very hard luck on Makinson and if it was for wing play only, I'd probably drop Foster but I'd stick with Foster for his kicking abilities shown this season. Not sure it's fair to ask Makinson to kick in a game of this magnitude despite his good kicking performance against Quins.

The big dilemna/risk is having both Wheeler and Eastmond in the 17. I'm not sure it's a risk that Royce will take and they will battle it out for a bench spot. I just get the feeling that Wheeler and Meli would be a lethal wing partnership and I would like us to take a risk.

It probably won't even come to this as I'm sure TP is still doubful and Eastmond must be rated the same as he's not played for about 4 weeks as well.

Re: Gary Wheeler/17 for Sunday? : Mon Sep 12, 2011 12:47 pm  

I think wheeler will take the bench spot we assign to a back.
Gaskell is probably most deserving of that spot, but perhaps would lose out to Wheels and Eastmong because they offer a little more electricity. I would think Wheeler will get the nod over Kyle since he's had a bit of a run in the reserves to get his fitness up and isn't leaving at th'end of the season.

Re: Gary Wheeler/17 for Sunday? : Mon Sep 12, 2011 12:53 pm  

Wheeler is our most naturally gifted player and would have a place in any 17 I was picking, if fit.

Wellens
Foster
Shenton
Wheeler
Meli
Pryce
Lomax
Graham
Roby
TP
Soliola
Flannery
Wilkin

LMS
Clough
Moore
Eastmond (if we MUST persist with this bloomin "back on the bench" policy)

Having said all that, I see the merit in the alternative of Eastmond out, Wheeler to the bench, Meli back to centre and Makinson on the wing (given the combination Meli/Foster have built up). But I think Wheeler is a better centre than Meli, even taking into account Meli's excellent recent form.

Above all, I hope we play two props on the bench. This means Flannery starting in the back row and TP prop.

Re: Gary Wheeler/17 for Sunday? : Mon Sep 12, 2011 1:01 pm  

Wheeler is nothing but a crock. If we play him, someone will have to cover for 60 minutes of the game. Meli can't be moved and Wheeler is not better than either Pryce or Eastmond in the halves.

1 - Wello (Horrific)
2 - Makinson
3 - Shenton
4 - Meli
5 - Makinson
6 - Pryce
7 - Lomax
8 - Graham
9 - Roby
10 - LMS
11 - Wilkin
12 - Soliola
13 - Puletua

14 - Flannery
15 - Clough
16 - Moore
17 - Eastmond

Hopefully Royston will rise above the mediocrity and put Eastmond in at fullback, but I doubt it. Comfortable for Wigan.

Re: Gary Wheeler/17 for Sunday? : Mon Sep 12, 2011 1:02 pm  

Saddened! wrote:

Wheeler is nothing but a crock. If we play him, someone will have to cover for 60 minutes of the game. Meli can't be moved and Wheeler is not better than either Pryce or Eastmond in the halves.

1 - Wello (Horrific)
2 - Makinson
3 - Shenton
4 - Meli
5 - Makinson
6 - Pryce
7 - Lomax
8 - Graham
9 - Roby
10 - LMS
11 - Wilkin
12 - Soliola
13 - Puletua

14 - Flannery
15 - Clough
16 - Moore
17 - Eastmond

Hopefully Royston will rise above the mediocrity and put Eastmond in at fullback, but I doubt it. Comfortable for Wigan.

I agree it will be comfortable for Wigan, no way Makinson is experienced enough to play on both wings.

Re: Gary Wheeler/17 for Sunday? : Mon Sep 12, 2011 1:03 pm  

FearTheVee wrote:

Wheeler is our most naturally gifted player and would have a place in any 17 I was picking, if fit.

Wheeler
Meli

I had this down as the best thing to do at the beginning of the season, but would it be wise to move Meli at this stage of the tournament? He's had a very impressive season playing down that channel, should we be disrupting what is possibly our main attacking threat?

Re: Gary Wheeler/17 for Sunday? : Mon Sep 12, 2011 1:05 pm  

Offside Monkey wrote:

I had this down as the best thing to do at the beginning of the season, but would it be wise to move Meli at this stage of the tournament? He's had a very impressive season playing down that channel, should we be disrupting what is possibly our main attacking threat?

It would still be our main attacking threat if it was Wheeler/Meli.

Meli has been very good at centre, but Wheeler is a better player. We would still have Meli's close range danger on the wing. Meli has shown good hands in the centres but Wheeler has that and also the ability and nouse to step and jink through the line.

My concern would not be around what we would lose in attack (we would gain IMO), but what Meli we would get on the day fielding kicks.

Re: Gary Wheeler/17 for Sunday? : Mon Sep 12, 2011 1:05 pm  

Offside Monkey wrote:

I had this down as the best thing to do at the beginning of the season, but would it be wise to move Meli at this stage of the tournament? He's had a very impressive season playing down that channel, should we be disrupting what is possibly our main attacking threat?

It wouldn't just be disrupting an attacking threat, either. If we moved Meli onto the wing now we'd be reintroducing one of our biggest weaknesses just in time for the playoffs.

Re: Gary Wheeler/17 for Sunday? : Mon Sep 12, 2011 1:08 pm  

Keep the Meloster combination, it's been great for us this season.

Re: Gary Wheeler/17 for Sunday? : Mon Sep 12, 2011 1:09 pm  

FearTheVee wrote:

I agree it will be comfortable for Wigan, no way Makinson is experienced enough to play on both wings.

Oops. On my phone so I can't be bothered fixing it. It might be the tactical masterstroke that can take us to glory.