2009 Match Rating Thread : Fri Feb 06, 2009 10:35 pm  

Smith 8 MOM- Took his tries well, good performance again.
Donald 7 - Great finish, didn't get much ball though.
Watkins - 7 - What a pass and some good steps, although some inexperienced moments is obvious.
Senior 6 - Made a good dummy for the try, few good carries.
Hall 7 - Good positioning, looks to be gaining confidence and a well taken try
Sinfield 7 - Good kicking game, controlled the game well
McGuire 7 - Same as above
Leulaui 6 - Solid performance
Diskin 8 - When he was on in the 1st half we looked very dangerous.
Peacock 6 - Solid as always, although the sin binning put wasn't needed
JJB 7 - Great break, good offloading.
Ali 7 - Good offloads, solid.
Ablett 7 - Well taken try, great carries

McShane 6 - Did nothing wrong, but nothing that stood out either
Allan 5 - Only on for 5 minutes as far as I saw
Burgess 5 - Good carries, didn't see too much of him
Kirke 6 - Good performance, nothing stood out but nothing wrong.

Re: 2009 Match Rating Thread : Fri Feb 06, 2009 10:38 pm  

rhino77 wrote:

Smith 8 MOM- Took his tries well, good performance again.
Donald 7 - Great finish, didn't get much ball though.
Watkins - 7 - What a pass and some good steps, although some inexperienced moments is obvious.
Senior 6 - Made a good dummy for the try, few good carries.
Hall 7 - Good positioning, looks to be gaining confidence and a well taken try
Sinfield 7 - Good kicking game, controlled the game well
McGuire 7 - Same as above
Leulaui 6 - Solid performance
Diskin 8 - When he was on in the 1st half we looked very dangerous.
Peacock 6 - Solid as always, although the sin binning put wasn't needed
JJB 7 - Great break, good offloading.
Ali 7 - Good offloads, solid.
Ablett 7 - Well taken try, great carries

McShane 6 - Did nothing wrong, but nothing that stood out either
Allan 5 - Only on for 5 minutes as far as I saw
Burgess 5 - Good carries, didn't see too much of him
Kirke 6 - Good performance, nothing stood out but nothing wrong.

How did kylie only get 6???????
For the first game of the season it was solid,some good moments and plenty to work on .

Re: 2009 Match Rating Thread : Fri Feb 06, 2009 10:41 pm  

rhinoms wrote:

How did kylie only get 6???????
For the first game of the season it was solid,some good moments and plenty to work on .

Never mind that... how did Senior and Peacock (especially) only get 6's? Plus Burgess a 5?? He got through a tonne of work in that game. Ran hard and hit harder. I think Rhino77 pressed his Sky+ by accident and watched the Quins game from last summer

Re: 2009 Match Rating Thread : Fri Feb 06, 2009 10:42 pm  

rhino77 wrote:

Smith 8 MOM- Took his tries well, good performance again.
Donald 7 - Great finish, didn't get much ball though.
Watkins - 7 - What a pass and some good steps, although some inexperienced moments is obvious.
Senior 6 - Made a good dummy for the try, few good carries.
Hall 7 - Good positioning, looks to be gaining confidence and a well taken try
Sinfield 7 - Good kicking game, controlled the game well
McGuire 7 - Same as above
Leulaui 6 - Solid performance
Diskin 8 - When he was on in the 1st half we looked very dangerous.
Peacock 6 - Solid as always, although the sin binning put wasn't needed
JJB 7 - Great break, good offloading.
Ali 7 - Good offloads, solid.
Ablett 7 - Well taken try, great carries

McShane 6 - Did nothing wrong, but nothing that stood out either
Allan 5 - Only on for 5 minutes as far as I saw
Burgess 5 - Good carries, didn't see too much of him
Kirke 6 - Good performance, nothing stood out but nothing wrong.

Leuluai was your best forward by a billion miles, the bloke is a wrecking ball. He's improved immensely during his stay over here, I actually think he doesn't get the plaudits he deserves.

: Fri Feb 06, 2009 10:46 pm  

Leuluai v Perry

: Fri Feb 06, 2009 11:57 pm  

I was very impressed with Watkins. Great performance. Leuluai, Burgess and Peacock were fantastic also IMO.

Re: 2009 Match Rating Thread : Sat Feb 07, 2009 12:01 am  

rhino77 wrote:

McGuire 7

Your Joking Aren't You?, The Amount Of Errors He Made In That Match And He Comes Away With A 7...

Re: 2009 Match Rating Thread : Sat Feb 07, 2009 2:08 am  

The Joker® wrote:

Your Joking Aren't You?, The Amount Of Errors He Made In That Match And He Comes Away With A 7...

MCGUIRE?????

Re: 2009 Match Rating Thread : Sat Feb 07, 2009 2:15 am  

Steve-O wrote:

MCGUIRE?????

Yes. He made a number of errors tonight.

Re: 2009 Match Rating Thread : Sat Feb 07, 2009 7:24 am  

Hollywood Harrigan wrote:

Never mind that... how did Senior and Peacock (especially) only get 6's? Plus Burgess a 5?? He got through a tonne of work in that game. Ran hard and hit harder. I think Rhino77 pressed his Sky+ by accident and watched the Quins game from last summer

Peacock was marked down because of his sin binning. Senior was a bit quiet. Did Burgess come on after his injury?