Re: RD 1 | Salford Red Devils : Sat Feb 17, 2024 7:49 am  

Barrie’s Glass Eye wrote:

Scrappy and disjointed with and without the ball.

Some good individual performances, Lisone, Mik and Frawley in particular amongst some not so good from others.

I think there’s something there and can accept clunky play with a completely new spine, but we definitely looked better when we went direct.

FWIW I thought our much maligned prop rotation was good with the exception of Donno who tries hard but just doesn’t belong there. Mik and Goudemand were solid. Lisone was excellent and was complemented by Sangare imo.

Are you in cuckoo land , Mik was great , Lisone is Great in very limited minutes , the rest of the forwards were garbage , especially Donaldson (should never prop again) , Goudemand is not big enough or good enough and as for Sangare

Re: RD 1 | Salford Red Devils : Sat Feb 17, 2024 7:52 am  

Jrrhino wrote:

It was great to see Headingley rocking again a healthy 15k tonight and hopefully the team can keep bums on seats with wins like tonight. Lots to work on but it's round 1 and that's to be expected, Miller will be a real fan favourite he looks dangerous nearly everytime he returns the ball. Glad we got the 2 points, Momirovski sin bin is a joke and I think we'll be in for a long season if tackles like his are going to be a yellow card offences but ow we'll. One thing for sure is Sam Lisone is the best on earth.

Headingley Rocking ?

The Atmosphere was shocking , the south stand crowd is done !

Re: RD 1 | Salford Red Devils : Sat Feb 17, 2024 7:55 am  

Sir Gregory ParsloeP wrote:

As many have said , good we got a
Win but disappointed so much of it looked similar to last season.
Too much ball in Cam Smith’s hands and nowhere near enough in Croft’s and Newman’s.
Salford made it scrappy.
Handley, Lisone excellent, good bits from Millar.
Tough test next week, thought HKR were very good v Fc.

H.K.R were ordinary but Hull were terrible , unfortunatley an ordinary H.K.R will beat Leeds by 20 with home advantage

Re: RD 1 | Salford Red Devils : Sat Feb 17, 2024 7:58 am  

Loiner at large wrote:

Just watched the post match interviews. RS looked totally disinterested and not for the first time. He might be trying to appear nonchalant but you would hope he's a bit more convincing and passionate in front of the players.

Did we watch a different interview, I'm not sure where you're getting that from.

Re: RD 1 | Salford Red Devils : Sat Feb 17, 2024 8:00 am  

kjrhino wrote:

Totally agree on the Frawley front... Thought he was garbage.. along with the new centre.. Ackers did ok.. Newman runs up his own booty as normal... too much jumping... would love to have had Nene still in a leeds shirt.. was better than both our centres combined. Cameron smith stalls play... not sure what his role is gonna be.. Sangare is a big pudding, Miller looks class however.. Croft tackled well but not really in the game,,, Bentley is too light and we need James McDonnell back asap.. Other than that it was a win in the first game,,, Hopefully big improvements in the coming weeks. With the money spent, anything less than top 4 then Smith will be gone end of season. Think Wigan and Saints will be miles ahead in terms of quality. Onwards and upwards.

The reffing was bad for both teams, out of his depth. Salford did their best to slow the game to a plod which doesn't make for a spectacle for supporters.

Salford had done their homework on the ref and just came with the intention of spoiling the game , fortunatley he just gave enough penalties and six agains to see us home

Re: RD 1 | Salford Red Devils : Sat Feb 17, 2024 8:06 am  

ploinerrhino wrote:

Are you in cuckoo land , Mik was great , Lisone is Great in very limited minutes , the rest of the forwards were garbage , especially Donaldson (should never prop again) , Goudemand is not big enough or good enough and as for Sangare

I disagree and don’t think I’m in cuckoo land at all. When we got our heads down and focused on being direct we had a lot of joy, especially with the 2 players you mentioned. Like I said I agree with you on Bentley and Donaldson, but the rest of the pack went well enough, considering some of the doom and gloom we’ve had with our options. If no injuries return I’d give Ruan and TNW a run next week.

Also on Cam Smith, yeh he maybe needs to get out of the way a bit in good ball, but some of his carries were excellent and he did come up with the winning play.

Re: RD 1 | Salford Red Devils : Sat Feb 17, 2024 8:08 am  

ploinerrhino wrote:

Headingley Rocking ?

The Atmosphere was shocking , the south stand crowd is done !

Thought it was a good atmosphere. Take your earplugs out next time.

Re: RD 1 | Salford Red Devils : Sat Feb 17, 2024 8:09 am  

Trebor1 wrote:

Agree with all of that. Thought Salford were good to be fair to them, discipline cost them. Good game though and a wins a win early in the season.

As for new players. most were solid, not sure what to make of MOM thought he was all over place first half but improved. We lack punch when Donno Goudomomd on the field at same time. Lisone and Mik gave us much more.

Overall positive though in the main

I think perhaps we should look at who we are pair our props up with, so that it’s not the two smaller guys at the same time. Having said that I think goudemand ended up playing some 13 too.

Re: RD 1 | Salford Red Devils : Sat Feb 17, 2024 8:25 am  

I think we need to get shut of Fusi if we can, I’m sorry but he’s a complete liability. Out for 8 weeks or so and needs an Op… deary me.

Re: RD 1 | Salford Red Devils : Sat Feb 17, 2024 8:44 am  

Yeah he was in last chance saloon and that was his last chance. Sounds like an op was delayed too hoping hed be ok. Disappointing now all this considering the signing Salford have just made too. Bet Newmans delighted