Re: Agar out : Thu Mar 17, 2022 8:37 am  

Id be very suprised if Tony Smith broke his contract with KR. Hes never done so before.

He approached Leeds very late in the process before Agar was officially appointed, at that time Smith had a kind of temporary contract with KR to see them to the end of season as a caretaker. He was the only coach interviewed for the job but it was already Agar's job.

Re: Agar out : Thu Mar 17, 2022 11:47 am  

Shabino wrote:

He would , but think the time to get him would have been before KR. Not sure he’s the right man to turn this around now. I’d prefer someone younger and more hunger. Looking at sport , how many times is a return to a club anything more than nostalgia…??

Yeah, i can see where you're coming from there. Interesting to see. I'd still have him back, but perhaps i'm being too nostalgic... i just want the good times to come back, it's been too long. The CC win was great but i think that was a red herring on where the club has been heading.

[Ex-Swarcliffe Rhino]

Re: Agar out : Thu Mar 17, 2022 1:17 pm  

I would rather have a total stranger come in, look the place up and down and size it up and take the job on regardless of who's nose is put out of joint in a managerial sense than listen to another boring interview with the same boring platitudes and waffle. 5 years of transition and its always jam tomorrow.

We have to appoint people who have the hunger and drive to push us on, regardless of what colour shirt they may have worn in the past. Stop harping on about a "golden generation", Rhinos DNA and all the other trite soundbites and get on with the task of creating a new dynasty at Headingley.

Re: Agar out : Thu Mar 17, 2022 1:25 pm  

Agree entirely. Someone to come in and remind everyone that the aim is to win trophies. Ideally entertaining as well, but do whatever it takes. It feels like the current setup is happy pottering around in an amateur kind of way hoping for the best but not being particularly upset if we lose. No passion, just a kind of slightly sad acceptance of garbage.

Re: Agar out : Thu Mar 17, 2022 1:39 pm  

Ex-Swarcliffe Rhino wrote:

I would rather have a total stranger come in, look the place up and down and size it up and take the job on regardless of who's nose is put out of joint in a managerial sense than listen to another boring interview with the same boring platitudes and waffle. 5 years of transition and its always jam tomorrow.

We have to appoint people who have the hunger and drive to push us on, regardless of what colour shirt they may have worn in the past. Stop harping on about a "golden generation", Rhinos DNA and all the other trite soundbites and get on with the task of creating a new dynasty at Headingley.

Indeed.

Re: Agar out : Thu Mar 17, 2022 2:50 pm  

Once were Loiners wrote:

Agree entirely. Someone to come in and remind everyone that the aim is to win trophies. Ideally entertaining as well, but do whatever it takes. It feels like the current setup is happy pottering around in an amateur kind of way hoping for the best but not being particularly upset if we lose. No passion, just a kind of slightly sad acceptance of garbage.

I agree and disagree with this. I think in life and sport, your greatest strength can also become your greatest weakness. The club seems incredibly loyal, at times to a fault. It's obvious that GH assured the golden generation that they would be offered a job following their playing careers if they stuck around. We've seen that now with JJB, Burrow, Sinfield, Peacock and I know Mags and Ablett were offered roles too. I don't think loyalty is a bad trait, and the club is not all about the first team.

At the same time, standards need to be met, and someone needs to drive them who is not afraid to upset a few people. It sounds like Furner got the wrong balance of doing this.

It also comes down to fans expectations. Under McDermott, we played a horrednous brand of rugby IMO, but managed to win loads of trophies. I'd rather we talk about Leeds DNA being a good style of play/open expansive rugby than going back to McDermott's way. Still, we have to win at the same time!

Re: Agar out : Thu Mar 17, 2022 3:05 pm  

Ex-Swarcliffe Rhino wrote:

I would rather have a total stranger come in, look the place up and down and size it up and take the job on regardless of who's nose is put out of joint in a managerial sense than listen to another boring interview with the same boring platitudes and waffle. 5 years of transition and its always jam tomorrow.

We have to appoint people who have the hunger and drive to push us on, regardless of what colour shirt they may have worn in the past. Stop harping on about a "golden generation", Rhinos DNA and all the other trite soundbites and get on with the task of creating a new dynasty at Headingley.

Don’t disagree but Dave Furner will tell you he tried that.

Re: Agar out : Thu Mar 17, 2022 4:51 pm  

We are back to where we were prior to Gary first coming in (apart from the financials obviously). Ground up restart. Overhaul of coaching, playing staff and general set up with regards to recruitment and player development. If we have good youth teams the senior squad certainly hasn't benefited much recently. Leeds need to be producing international standard players as well as just decent club players with performance consistency issues.
I said this years ago that McDermott was not the man to manage a transition. He squeezed the best out of the squad he had but did nothing to secure the future or transition the playing squad. He wasn't helped much by the people (person) above him either. We are now reaping the grim rewards of that period.

All good fun.

Re: Agar out : Thu Mar 17, 2022 4:56 pm  

Sir Gregory Parsloe wrote:

Don’t disagree but Dave Furner will tell you he tried that.

He did, and it was the fallout with JJB and then Kev that did for him. His coaching wasn’t brilliant either.

[Bullseye]

Re: Agar out : Thu Mar 17, 2022 5:10 pm  

Successful sports teams often have this problem when coming to the end of a dynasty and it can take years to become successful again see Liverpool FC after Dalglish left, Man Utd after Ferguson and Yorkshire County Cricket after the 1960s.

In RL look at Hull FC after 1985, Wigan after 1995 or the Bulls after 2005.

Success tends to be cyclical but I think those that cling onto the old memories with jobs for the boys seem to do less well.