Re: Squad for Friday : Sat May 15, 2021 11:10 am  

If we’ve money to spend then it’s either a meter eating prop forward or a creative hooker we need not an injury prone 4th fullback. I say fullback as theres no way he’s getting picked ahead of Miller & Lino in the halves.

Re: Squad for Friday : Sun May 16, 2021 11:31 pm  

Arundlels attempt to tackle in golden point was terrible !

we lost the ball the next set after scoring point 3 times not to mention the disgrace when we got 12-12
another 2 points was there for the taking and we didn't get it done.
have nothing in attack whilst attacking their line and havent for 3 years

thought the penalty to win them the game was harsh but was a 50/50 call.

Re: Squad for Friday : Mon May 17, 2021 3:09 pm  

Vuniyayawa was clearly tackled, arm touching the floor and momentum stopped, then the ball is pulled out. Don’t know how that can be anything other than a penalty. Also adding that on linos drop goal Dwyer was taken out off the ball when trying to get in a block.

Re: Squad for Friday : Mon May 17, 2021 3:11 pm  

Seth wrote:

Vuniyayawa was clearly tackled, arm touching the floor and momentum stopped, then the ball is pulled out. Don’t know how that can be anything other than a penalty. Also adding that on linos drop goal Dwyer was taken out off the ball when trying to get in a block.

Well his ball carrying arm never hit the floor, that was quite obvious, but I thought the call could of gone either way to be honest.

Re: Squad for Friday : Mon May 17, 2021 3:16 pm  

Either way the tackle was completed as he hits the deck and the ref shouts ‘last’.

Re: Squad for Friday : Mon May 17, 2021 3:17 pm  

That must have been even Dwyer ran into the stationary wakey player and ended up diving like Tom Daley.

I’ve watched countless replays and at no time does Kings ball carrying arm or ball touch the floor or his momentum stop before the strip.

The ref called held before the tackle was completed technically and this is why Pitts was argumentative with the ref.

Its also reported today that Ganson has informed Wakefield that the decision to award a penalty was the incorrect decision. Not that it helps now ofcourse.

Re: Squad for Friday : Mon May 17, 2021 3:20 pm  

Seth wrote:

Either way the tackle was completed as he hits the deck and the ref shouts ‘last’.

Yes at the same time as the strip and without the ball carrying arm or ball being anywhere near the floor. It’s been reported Ganson has informed Wakefield it wasn’t a penalty. I’m assuming this is because although held was called he technically wasn’t tackled and Pitts was entitled to strip when he did.

Re: Squad for Friday : Mon May 17, 2021 3:23 pm  

Trojan Horse wrote:

Yes at the same time as the strip and without the ball carrying arm or ball being anywhere near the floor. It’s been reported Ganson has informed Wakefield it wasn’t a penalty. I’m assuming this is because although held was called he technically wasn’t tackled.

That`s what I was told with Ganson, but it makes no difference now to us and if it makes Seth feel better, we should let him have this one.

Re: Squad for Friday : Mon May 17, 2021 3:29 pm  

homme vaste wrote:

Trojan Horse wrote:

Yes at the same time as the strip and without the ball carrying arm or ball being anywhere near the floor. It’s been reported Ganson has informed Wakefield it wasn’t a penalty. I’m assuming this is because although held was called he technically wasn’t tackled.

That`s what I was told with Ganson, but it makes no difference now to us and if it makes Seth feel better, we should let him have this one.

It’s a shame though as the extra time would’ve continued and although we don’t know who would have won there would have been an opportunity. Like you say though, it matters not that Ganson states it was an incorrect decision because the mistake is in the history books.

Best to forget it and move on to Hull KR anyway now. I got my tickets and I’m hoping we can come out with that long awaited win!

Re: Squad for Friday : Mon May 17, 2021 3:29 pm  

Seth wrote:

Vuniyayawa was clearly tackled, arm touching the floor and momentum stopped, then the ball is pulled out. Don’t know how that can be anything other than a penalty. Also adding that on linos drop goal Dwyer was taken out off the ball when trying to get in a block.

Don't forget the forward passes for Konrad's try neither