: Sun Mar 01, 2009 5:10 pm  

Kirk played half of his games at 2nd row in the reserves, still think he's a better hooker but saying that he had his best game for the club in the 2nd row in the CC against Hudds last year imo.

Pleased to see him doing well at Cas.

Bandito wrote:

You will be telling us that Fitzhenry is a hooker

Hasn't done too shabby so far Very impressed, got the penalty on Friday night that won us the game.

: Sun Mar 01, 2009 7:02 pm  

Gordon Gekko wrote:

Players can play out of position from time to time and i have no problem with that, but to say Kirk is a better back rower than hooker shows how stupid you really are and thats the end of it.

Considering all the FACTS you cant exactly call someone stupid for having an opinion!

In my opinion your a total pillock but I dont actually know much about you do I so I may be wrong and your actually much worse than you come accross on here!!!

The reason I feel he could be a better back rower is that his distribution from the ground isn't as snappy as other Super League class hookers yet his line running and upper body strength make him ideal to play at loose man or an attacking second rower.

I might not be a top coach but I do actually have a coaching badge in Rugby League so I cant be that stupid! Now trott on.

: Mon Mar 02, 2009 2:42 am  

nick hkr wrote:

Considering all the FACTS you cant exactly call someone stupid for having an opinion!

In my opinion your a total pillock but I dont actually know much about you do I so I may be wrong and your actually much worse than you come accross on here!!!

The reason I feel he could be a better back rower is that his distribution from the ground isn't as snappy as other Super League class hookers yet his line running and upper body strength make him ideal to play at loose man or an attacking second rower.

I might not be a top coach but I do actually have a coaching badge in Rugby League so I cant be that stupid! Now trott on.

Having a badge means you aren't stupid then does it
Level 1 takes about an hour and a half , reckon you could buy the badge on e bay for a couple of quid anyway. I have held a coaching badge for roughly 15 years so I guess that makes my dad bigger than your dad

: Mon Mar 02, 2009 8:50 am  

Big Spender wrote:

Just remind me who won the last game he played in

You've proved the point that playing players out of their natural position doesn't always work

Best have a word with nick hkr.

: Mon Mar 02, 2009 8:59 am  

nick hkr wrote:

Considering all the FACTS you cant exactly call someone stupid for having an opinion!

In my opinion your a total pillock but I dont actually know much about you do I so I may be wrong and your actually much worse than you come accross on here!!!

The reason I feel he could be a better back rower is that his distribution from the ground isn't as snappy as other Super League class hookers yet his line running and upper body strength make him ideal to play at loose man or an attacking second rower.

I might not be a top coach but I do actually have a coaching badge in Rugby League so I cant be that stupid! Now trott on.

Thank god you didn't coach the likes of Greg Inglis, Isreal Falou or Jamie Lyon, you'd have had them playing prop

: Mon Mar 02, 2009 9:30 pm  

Gordon Gekko wrote:

Thank god you didn't coach the likes of Greg Inglis, Isreal Falou or Jamie Lyon, you'd have had them playing prop

I have a Jim'll Fix It badge which my girlfriend gave me cos I fix everything for her.

That is the best badge of em all

My mate also lets me hold his badge once a week so I can feel good about myself

: Tue Mar 03, 2009 7:12 am  

Gordon Gekko wrote:

You've proved the point that playing players out of their natural position doesn't always work

Best have a word with nick hkr.

Lovegrove...Prop, Webster...Second Row, Cockayne....Wing

It works for the better coaches.

: Tue Mar 03, 2009 8:44 am  

Rover in Oz wrote:

Lovegrove...Prop, Webster...Second Row, Cockayne....Wing

It works for the better coaches.

Oh... ok then

: Tue Mar 03, 2009 9:20 am  

Gordon Gekko wrote:

Oh... ok then

Wait, so you'd still have Pryce playing on the wing? Lockyer at fullback?

Even Mick Vella started off on the wing, players change positions successfully all the time, look how well Cockayne did at hooker last season and Murrell changing from #6 to #13. It's up to the coach to spot the potential.

Netherton is just as suited at 2nd row as he is at hooker imo. Good player to have on the bench, should have kept him.

: Tue Mar 03, 2009 12:18 pm  

Matty wrote:

Wait, so you'd still have Pryce playing on the wing? Lockyer at fullback?

Even Mick Vella started off on the wing, players change positions successfully all the time, look how well Cockayne did at hooker last season and Murrell changing from #6 to #13. It's up to the coach to spot the potential.

Netherton is just as suited at 2nd row as he is at hooker imo. Good player to have on the bench, should have kept him.

Utter cock.