Re: Hull KR v Huddersfield... : Sat Sep 24, 2016 4:53 pm  

Seventies red wrote:

He's not wrong though is he.
Some of you from the other side do come over as moronic at times, he's simply saying it as he sees it really.

of course he's wrong. It's only his opinion the kick didn't go over. The video is inconclusive. If he had anything about him he'd stay off twitter but I guess he takes his lead from the boss so what do you expect? No class in your club at all. Hopefully sheens will bring about a significant change

Re: Hull KR v Huddersfield... : Sat Sep 24, 2016 5:12 pm  

The DG pictures aren't really that conclusive and are irrelevant, the result won't change.

Hicks's performance was woeful. Touch judges in first half had to award penalties that he saw and was going to ignore. Allowing play to go on whilst Greenwood was on the floor having treatment in the defensive line shows total disregard for player safety. Huddersfield constantly iffsode on 1st play the ball. Hudds given a 20m restart when we kick it out on the full. The guy is hopeless. Anywat, it's gone now.

Re: Hull KR v Huddersfield... : Sat Sep 24, 2016 5:12 pm  

Jake the Peg wrote:

of course he's wrong. It's only his opinion the kick didn't go over. The video is inconclusive. If he had anything about him he'd stay off twitter but I guess he takes his lead from the boss so what do you expect? No class in your club at all. Hopefully sheens will bring about a significant change

I think he's been taking twitter etiquette lesson from Koucash!

Re: Hull KR v Huddersfield... : Sat Sep 24, 2016 5:20 pm  

caslad75 wrote:

I think he's been taking twitter etiquette lesson from Koucash!

Trouble is, he's not the sharpest knife in the drawer not by a long way and that's always been the case. He must have had some coaching as he's been able to gloss it over until the pressure is applied. A great servant to the game but someone needs to keep his gob shut, and keep him away from keyboards.

Re: Hull KR v Huddersfield... : Sat Sep 24, 2016 5:53 pm  

Gallanteer wrote:

The DG pictures aren't really that conclusive and are irrelevant, the result won't change.

Hicks's performance was woeful. Touch judges in first half had to award penalties that he saw and was going to ignore. Allowing play to go on whilst Greenwood was on the floor having treatment in the defensive line shows total disregard for player safety. Huddersfield constantly iffsode on 1st play the ball. Hudds given a 20m restart when we kick it out on the full. The guy is hopeless. Anywat, it's gone now.

The kick out on the full was the correct decision. Both sides were offside most of the game and the only real contentious decision was the thornley try which was clearly a knock on by man tomato

Re: Hull KR v Huddersfield... : Sat Sep 24, 2016 6:16 pm  

Jake the Peg wrote:

Did anyone think brough's drop goal was wide?

Need to put this one to bed once and for all.

DANNY BROUGH'S DROP GOAL WAS JUST IN AS FAR AS I'M CONCERNED. BY NO MORE THAN 6 INCHES, THAT'S ALL.

My wife and I sit behind the sticks in the North Stand and we had a perfect DIRECT IN LINE VIEW of the kick from directly behind him on this occasion, as did Hicks. We were willing it to be blown wide by the wind, but although it was high it stayed in (Just).

Seventies Red said he got a good view of the kick from the East Stand. Total cackamallababshit, mate. As a former East Stander, you cannot see a drop kick trajectory from there unless the kick is directly in your line of sight.

It matters little anymore, the result stands. We got what we deserved after that woeful and embarrassing first half performance.

SO FOR THE AVOIDANCE OF ANY DOUBT, BROUGHS DROP KICK WAS.......IN.

Re: Hull KR v Huddersfield... : Sat Sep 24, 2016 6:56 pm  

Calm down chief.

You're right though, you can't tell from the east.

Personally, I thought we were the better team for the first twenty (ish) and the last forty, however, we were absolutely diabolical for the second twenty. I like Campese a lot, but Brierley had him on absolute toast today.

Re: Hull KR v Huddersfield... : Sat Sep 24, 2016 7:04 pm  

[quote="Pickering Red"]Need to put this one to bed once and for all.

DANNY BROUGH'S DROP GOAL WAS JUST IN AS FAR AS I'M CONCERNED. BY NO MORE THAN 6 INCHES, THAT'S ALL.

My wife and I sit behind the sticks in the North Stand and we had a perfect DIRECT IN LINE VIEW of the kick from directly behind him on this occasion, as did Hicks. We were willing it to be blown wide by the wind, but although it was high it stayed in (Just).

Seventies Red said he got a good view of the kick from the East Stand. Total cackamallababshit, mate. As a former East Stander, you cannot see a drop kick trajectory from there unless the kick is directly in your line of sight.

It matters little anymore, the result stands. We got what we deserved after that woeful and embarrassing first half performance.

SO FOR THE AVOIDANCE OF ANY DOUBT, BROUGHS DROP KICK WAS.......IN.[/quo

I site just left of the sticks in the north stand.
Myself and everyone around me agreed that it missed.

Re: Hull KR v Huddersfield... : Sat Sep 24, 2016 7:23 pm  

If its written in capitals it's a FACT

Re: Hull KR v Huddersfield... : Sat Sep 24, 2016 7:24 pm  

[quote="Keith_Lard"]
You're right Keith. It would look out if you were sitting left of us, but I and a few others around me thought it was IN. Wish it wasn't but not be be. History now. Result was a bummer. Tbh, we did well to fight back to get on equal terms, but we needed Campo 5 metres nearer for his drop kick.