Re: Forwards Meters per Carrie : Thu Mar 04, 2010 11:02 am  

Bertie wrote:

Or you could compare league positions, Challenge cup runs and play off appearances between our clubs comparing like on like after three seasons in super league.

Why? this is our 13th season. It's not our fault you weren't good enough during the vast majority of that period.

the fact remains that during the 14 years of superleague you have done better on 2 occasions and on both those occasions you have not won anything. You cannot compare previous years because circumstances were different (NO SALARY CAP)

Re: Forwards Meters per Carrie : Thu Mar 04, 2010 12:19 pm  

Willa wrote:

Why? this is our 13th season. It's not our fault you weren't good enough during the vast majority of that period.

the fact remains that during the 14 years of superleague you have done better on 2 occasions and on both those occasions you have not won anything. You cannot compare previous years because circumstances were different (NO SALARY CAP)

You can only count the years that we have been on an equal footing and so the past 3 years are the only years you can go on. Just because those years dont make you look better than us doesnt mean you can drag up the whole SL era that you have been part of! What happens if after the next 2 games you have a massive slump again like last year and once again we do better than you? Do you continue to use your "We've made a GF appearance (still not won it!) and won a CC" and then tell us we cant use the 10-5 argument because its 30yrs ago that it happened???

You Hull fans do love to contradict yourselves, I guess thats what makes West Hull "special"!!!

Re: Forwards Meters per Carrie : Thu Mar 04, 2010 1:09 pm  

nick hkr wrote:

You can only count the years that we have been on an equal footing and so the past 3 years are the only years you can go on.


We've been on an equal footing for about 100 years. You not being in superleague was nobody's fault but Rovers




Just because those years dont make you look better than us doesnt mean you can drag up the whole SL era that you have been part of! What happens if after the next 2 games you have a massive slump again like last year and once again we do better than you?

Then you do better than us, what do you want me to say?

Do you continue to use your "We've made a GF appearance (still not won it!) and won a CC" and then tell us we cant use the 10-5 argument because its 30yrs ago that it happened???

Banter? Truth?

You Hull fans do love to contradict yourselves, I guess thats what makes West Hull "special"!!!

I'm from Hedon, east of Hull, so last point is pointless. Unless your saying everyone who lives at my side of the river is an inbred fool, that may be true

Re: Forwards Meters per Carrie : Thu Mar 04, 2010 5:42 pm  

How can we be on equal footing for 100 years yet 14 years ago circumstances were different as you state.

By the way I will not look forward to 2091 now in the fear that Gordon is still alive and will drag this thread to the top of the pile to prove he was right.

Re: Forwards Meters per Carrie : Thu Mar 04, 2010 5:55 pm  

Basil Fawlty wrote:

Unfortunately tho' it appears you do!

C`mon Baz,that was quite funny.
I mean,he could have said she will burn the whole place down.

[R.B.A]

Re: Forwards Meters per Carrie : Thu Mar 04, 2010 6:04 pm  

In the unlikely event of this thread getting back on topic i will leave it open. Otherwise it is going.

Re: Forwards Meters per Carrie : Thu Mar 04, 2010 6:17 pm  

Willa wrote:

Why? this is our 13th season. It's not our fault you weren't good enough during the vast majority of that period.

the fact remains that during the 14 years of superleague you have done better on 2 occasions and on both those occasions you have not won anything. You cannot compare previous years because circumstances were different (NO SALARY CAP)

For much of our early time in SL we were operating way under the maximum salary cap due to the 50% rule, hence we were not playing on the level field that you find yourselves on now you smaller clubs are allowed to overspend. Therefore there is no reasonable comparison to be made as financially you are spending way more than we did at a comparable time in our SL lifetime

Re: Forwards Meters per Carrie : Thu Mar 04, 2010 6:19 pm  

Club
Meters

1 Hull
5619

2 Warrington
5502

3 Leeds
5452

4 Wigan
5386

5 St Helens
5383

6 Bradford
5161

7 Wakefield
5116

8 Huddersfield
4895

9 Castleford
4823

10 Hull Kingston Rovers
4614

11 Harlequins
4599

12 Celtic Crusaders
4201

13 Salford
3962

14 Catalans
3780

Re: Forwards Meters per Carrie : Thu Mar 04, 2010 7:14 pm  

R.B.A wrote:

In the unlikely event of this thread getting back on topic i will leave it open. Otherwise it is going.

Sorry,couldn`t resist.

Re: Forwards Meters per Carrie : Thu Mar 04, 2010 7:18 pm  

R.B.A wrote:

In the unlikely event of this thread getting back on topic i will leave it open. Otherwise it is going.

It'll be a blood bath this Carrie thread I tell you, a blood bath.