Re: Tindall Confirmed : Tue Oct 03, 2023 7:47 am  

Impossible to replace Swift like for like without a quota spot, so better signing younger players and using the Swift money for a forward.

Re: Tindall Confirmed : Tue Oct 03, 2023 7:48 am  

Props win you Grand Finals, not wingers. Look at Ade Gardner. Very average winger, won how many titles? He has pace and strength so lets just see how he goes

Re: Tindall Confirmed : Tue Oct 03, 2023 2:41 pm  

Irregs#16 wrote:

Props win you Grand Finals, not wingers. Look at Ade Gardner. Very average winger, won how many titles? He has pace and strength so lets just see how he goes

Thats why Wigan will run away with S/L next season
Not only the power in the forwards but they have the speed accross the park to take advantage

Re: Tindall Confirmed : Wed Oct 04, 2023 10:06 am  

Ade Gardner scored tries for fun.

Admittedly Tindall was not in a good Leeds team but his inability to get over the try line given the number of appearances for the club is a worry for a winger. Lisone (a prop forward) scored more tries in one game against you lot than Tindall managed this season (and possibly in his first team Leeds career). Olpherts got over the try line more and most Leeds fans think he was a dreadful signing... You see where this is going.

I hope you find a way to give him better service so that he can have a proper career in the game.

[Chris71]

Re: Tindall Confirmed : Wed Oct 04, 2023 1:01 pm  

Exeter Rhino wrote:

Ade Gardner scored tries for fun.

Admittedly Tindall was not in a good Leeds team but his inability to get over the try line given the number of appearances for the club is a worry for a winger. Lisone (a prop forward) scored more tries in one game against you lot than Tindall managed this season (and possibly in his first team Leeds career). Olpherts got over the try line more and most Leeds fans think he was a dreadful signing... You see where this is going.

I hope you find a way to give him better service so that he can have a proper career in the game.

To be fair playing against us at the tail end of a season is no yardstick to use as Barrie Mc could have come out of retirement and scored those.

Being honest both ourselves and Leeds are way off and this season have been pretty poor to put it mildly.

Tindall is not going to be a miracle signing we know that, but could well prove to be a decent & astute signing for us.

Re: Tindall Confirmed : Wed Oct 04, 2023 1:35 pm  

Chris71 wrote:

To be fair playing against us at the tail end of a season is no yardstick to use as Barrie Mc could have come out of retirement and scored those.

Being honest both ourselves and Leeds are way off and this season have been pretty poor to put it mildly.

Tindall is not going to be a miracle signing we know that, but could well prove to be a decent & astute signing for us.

I'd rather have Tindall than Olpherts and wouldn't be happy keeping an overseas winger who has been ok at best and is injured half the season.

Re: Tindall Confirmed : Wed Oct 04, 2023 2:19 pm  

Tiinndaaallll, Tiinndaaallll, hope he's as good as their Keith was!