FORUMS FORUMS






RLFANS.COM
Celebrating
25 years service to
the Rugby League
Community!

   WWW.RLFANS.COM • View topic - Smith - should he stay or should he go?
Hasbag 
User avatar
RankPostsTeam
International Star4613No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Feb 26 201212 years23rd
OnlineLast PostLast Page
15th Jun 24 21:3215th Jun 24 16:33LINK
Milestone Posts
2500
5000
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Hull

Re: Smith - should he stay or should he go? : Sun Mar 17, 2024 2:25 pm  
Offy1865 wrote:
I think Smith will only walk. I don't see him being sacked.
The reason I say this is, I remember AP saying "he will be the last coach I hire" doesn't sound like someone who will be sacking the coach.

Whether that was AP saying, no matter what smith is staying or was he saying I'll be gone soon so TS can take us up until then.

As I've already said,.I don't see the point in sacking TS, doesn't seem to matter who the coach is, it's always the same old stuff.
Maybe if we had TS after ladders, with that type of squad and money to spend, he would've taken us forward. But being so under the cap etc hence bringing in players that aren't good enough

I always interpreted the "last coach I hire" line as a way of Pearson saying he will soon have somebody in place who will make all those decisions, meaning he doesn't have to. The way I was expecting us to go was Smith to coach us for 2 or 3 years before moving into an upstairs 'Director of Rugby' type role. Smith would then be responsible for appointing his successor, whether from within or outside the club.
I can see us still following this route regardless of how bad results and performances get this year.
My opinion is that Pearson wants to maintain ownership of the club but wants to distance himself from having to actually do anything.
BP1 
User avatar
RankPostsTeam
Player Coach988
JoinedServiceReputation
Sep 04 200519 years140th
OnlineLast PostLast Page
15th Jun 24 20:5315th Jun 24 17:09LINK
Milestone Posts
500
1000
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
In the land of wishful thinking once more. Patiently waiting for our time to finally arrive.
Signature
I've been on the internet and have already got a sense of the fans' passion for the club. They are very fanatical - Peter Gentle 12th September 2011.

Money doesn't talk it swears, Obscenity who really cares, Propaganda all is phony.

I'm the son and heir of a shyness which is criminally vulgar.

Hanging on in quiet desperation is the English way.

A man who lives in hell can still aspire to heaven.

Re: Smith - should he stay or should he go? : Sun Mar 17, 2024 2:28 pm  
hull2524 wrote:
Smith must be on a very thin piece of ice. But my main problem is how many times can players throw the coach under the bus then just carry on. It's every year with hull . It's a never ending circle. Smith should have the bottle to drop those not performing which would be a lot. But at least it would show who's boss. For me the squad he picks for Huddersfield will say a lot.Our forwards yesterday where awful. Since I've been watching rugby if your forwards are getting mullered you won't win a match. Plus Smiths excuses are wearing thin. I'd have said that display is not acceptable there in training Sunday Some will be dropped next week the others are on last chance saloon.


I know, from reading other threads, that you and I are part of the group who have been trying to keep the faith, trying to see some positives (however minor), trying to see a least some chinks of light in the darkness. The fact that the likes of ourselves have just about reached the end of our tethers speaks volumes about the level of disenchantment within the faithful today.

I too have a couple of doubts about Smith's departure. Firstly, does Pearson have the finance to terminate Smith's tenure? I have a suspicion he can't remove him even if he wants to.
Secondly, if not Smith, then who exactly picks up the reins (poisoned chalice, more like) for the foreseeable future and beyond. There doesn't appear to be an obvious list of candidates right now.
Thirdly, would it make any difference? As you point out, there seems to be some entrenched issues at the club which no-one appears to be capable of shifting. Coaches come, coaches go, yet the same old problems seem to stay. We could make yet another coaching appointment and still find ourselves no further along the path.

Having said all that, something has to change, and soon. We cannot go on like this for much longer. Someone (Pearson/Smith/A N Other) has to take hold of the situation and bring about real change or we are finished as things stand. These are some of the most depressing times I've witnessed in my 50 years of following the club.
User avatar
RankPostsTeam
Player Coach3803
JoinedServiceReputation
Jan 11 200519 years199th
OnlineLast PostLast Page
15th Jun 24 23:0011th Jun 24 22:58LINK
Milestone Posts
2500
5000
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
West Hull

Re: Smith - should he stay or should he go? : Sun Mar 17, 2024 3:00 pm  
Doesn't help when the Head of Strength and Conditioning Calum Christopherson leaves for HKR, and is not replaced. Other clubs such as Salford employ 2 Strength and Conditioners, we don't.. Also Seamus McCallion our ex Head Physio, gone..
RankPostsTeam
International Star7243No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Apr 04 201410 years8th
OnlineLast PostLast Page
16th Jun 24 00:1715th Jun 24 18:17LINK
Milestone Posts
5000
10000
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530

Re: Smith - should he stay or should he go? : Sun Mar 17, 2024 4:16 pm  
mean_machine wrote:
Fundamentals. I sometimes think when a team is struggling why don’t coaches just focus on these things. You’d accept a fairly conservative game plan if it meant the starting point of

-play people in the positions they are best in. Hookers at hooker, props at prop etc. don’t overthink it
- kick well, chase hard and ask teams to go 100 metres
- be as fit as possible
- don’t cut corners or try and be clever for penalties
- small effort areas. Forming scrums quickly, celebrating small wins, kick pressure etc

Sounds so basic, but I just don’t see you lot doing much of this at the moment. What’s happening on the training pitch every week? What’s the plan? I think most can accept getting beat but if your senior players cba to do the above then it’s a coaching issue. I think sometimes as fans you can over complicate what is happening and think bigger picture but there’s a lot of low hanging fruit which can be dealt with immediately that just isn’t happening


Hit the nail on the head and why i have been critical of Smith for several months now.
Like in football when a team leaks goals and a new manager comes in what do they do? They concentrate on the defence and build the team from there, then slowly start to apply a pressing game and more attack.
Its the same in R/L Defence the priority,fitness to cope with the extra work,then start to apply an attacking structure
Smith has done nothing like this since he arrived apart from make this team into the most undisciplined in the S/L.
His time is up and Pearson has to climb out of his shell tomorrow,apologise to fans and sack Smith and his pal with immediate effect .
Cant say ive seen any difference since Grix has been here but i think fans will be prepared to give him a chance till the end of the season.
Also bring back Gaz Ellis as assistant coach
RankPostsTeam
International Star7243No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Apr 04 201410 years8th
OnlineLast PostLast Page
16th Jun 24 00:1715th Jun 24 18:17LINK
Milestone Posts
5000
10000
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530

Re: Smith - should he stay or should he go? : Sun Mar 17, 2024 4:23 pm  
hull2524 wrote:
Smith must be on a very thin piece of ice. But my main problem is how many times can players throw the coach under the bus then just carry on. It's every year with hull . It's a never ending circle. Smith should have the bottle to drop those not performing which would be a lot. But at least it would show who's boss. For me the squad he picks for Huddersfield will say a lot.Our forwards yesterday where awful. Since I've been watching rugby if your forwards are getting mullered you won't win a match. Plus Smiths excuses are wearing thin. I'd have said that display is not acceptable there in training Sunday Some will be dropped next week the others are on last chance saloon.


it will melt tonight
UllFC 
User avatar
RankPostsTeam
Club Coach16956No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Mar 27 200420 years35th
OnlineLast PostLast Page
15th Jun 24 20:4115th Jun 24 17:44LINK
Milestone Posts
15000
20000
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530

Re: Smith - should he stay or should he go? : Sun Mar 17, 2024 4:39 pm  
BP1 wrote:
I made this same point last night on the game thread.

When it's not going very well, go back to basics and start afresh from there. It is a truism in all sports, be they individual or team. Keep it simple, keep it direct, keep it straightforward.

Even if you are not the best in your sport, there are two aspects that everyone can work on and improve: Fitness and organization. If we could see positive indicators within our team that those two aspects were being addressed then there wouldn't be half the amount of criticism being aimed Smith's way that there is today.

The fact that we can't see even the basics being carried out to an acceptable level (in fact they would appear to be getting worse judged on the season so far) has to be the responsibility of Smith, and him alone. We would excuse/accept the fact that there is simply a lack of quality within the playing squad if this was to be the case, but fitness, organization, commitment and desire have nothing to do with being a world-class player.

Smith's position this afternoon looks, to me, the same as Peter Gentle the day after the Huddersfield play-off humiliation, untenable. I've tried to back him, given his track record as an experienced coach, wanting him to succeed, to turn our club around, I've tried to search for positives (even small ones) as I'm not someone who believes that sacking your coach/manager every time you hit a bump in the road is a way to find stability, but even I ran out of patience during yesterday's shambolic first-half.

My feelings about Smith this afternoon are exactly the same as I felt about Gentle after that Huddersfield game; he looks a busted flush I'm afraid. Whether replacing him (and with who?) will change matters (given the low-level squad we will still have) I have no idea, but this current situation simply cannot be allowed to continue or drift along aimlessly, we could disappear for good.

Reading this forum today, it's difficult to escape the feeling that something fundamental snapped with the faithful yesterday afternoon. The final straw being thrown in the bin. It's not even a saviour we are looking for, just someone to instil some pride and commitment into proceedings, to give us back a club to believe in once more, as we have all believed in for a large proportion of our lives (whatever our different ages, some older than others). We have reached the point of no return. We need a change, but I fear it might not be coming.


Tbf to Gentle he managed to finish 6th with a squad assembled at last minute in 2012 with I think our best home record ever at the MKM. Even though the 2013 playoff defeat was embarasing lets not forget it was a round 2 playoff defeat and we'd lost at Wembley in a game spoilt by a downpour. Legend has it the players downed tools, we never know what might have been had he stayed (2014 and 2015 were poor under Radford)

Id take the above level of league and cup finishes right now!
User avatar
RankPostsTeam
Moderator7944
JoinedServiceReputation
Jan 30 200420 years3rd
OnlineLast PostLast Page
16th Jun 24 01:1415th Jun 24 20:56LINK
Milestone Posts
5000
10000
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Never never land away with the fairies
Signature
I really enjoy long walks especially when they are taken by people I don't like!
Moderator

Re: Smith - should he stay or should he go? : Sun Mar 17, 2024 6:05 pm  
UllFC wrote:
Tbf to Gentle he managed to finish 6th with a squad assembled at last minute in 2012 with I think our best home record ever at the MKM. Even though the 2013 playoff defeat was embarasing lets not forget it was a round 2 playoff defeat and we'd lost at Wembley in a game spoilt by a downpour. Legend has it the players downed tools, we never know what might have been had he stayed (2014 and 2015 were poor under Radford)

Id take the above level of league and cup finishes right now!


Said it many times Gentle certainly wasn’t the problem and had AP backed him to do his job we certainly wouldn’t be anywhere to the mess we are in right now.

For me the way AP handled things then was probably the start of the problems that have become deep seated issues that are now ingrained in to the fabric of the club.

The one coach he needed to give time too he pulled the trigger on far too early and then hired the one who lead the revolt all because Gentle was a proper coach and made train hard
Steve0 
User avatar
RankPostsTeam
Club Owner1998No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Jan 03 200321 years33rd
OnlineLast PostLast Page
15th Jun 24 22:4915th Jun 24 15:13LINK
Milestone Posts
1000
2500
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Leeds

Re: Smith - should he stay or should he go? : Sun Mar 17, 2024 6:24 pm  
Smith saying that the players are fatigued after 5 games and that's why we're struggling puts Clifford's comments about pre season being a piece of pi$$ into context
User avatar
RankPostsTeam
Academy Player271
JoinedServiceReputation
Mar 16 20240 years155th
OnlineLast PostLast Page
8th Jun 24 11:418th Jun 24 11:24LINK
Milestone Posts
250
500
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530

Re: Smith - should he stay or should he go? : Sun Mar 17, 2024 6:38 pm  
Hi all,

This is my first post so wanted to just take a brief moment to say hello to all fellow FC fans and rugby fans in general. I have read posts on here before for quite some time and decided to join to get involved in the discussions. :WAVE:

I think the question of whether Tony Smith stays or goes isn't the right question to be honest. That's not in defence of Smith at all because, let's face it, yesterday's performance was pretty indefensible. No defensive structure, no attacking structure, no game plan. That all lays at the feet of the coach and the coaching staff.

But this is a wider issue than the coach. Because this kind of performance is something we have witnessed for years and it doesn't seem to matter who the coach is. I think back to the comments made by Shaun McRae all those years ago about there been a cancer at the club. Those comments came after a similar hammering with questions being asked about players' desire, effort, commitment and pride in the shirt. It's affected every coach in-between him and Smith at some point and it's often been the eventual downfall of those coaches. And so it may prove with Smith too.

So instead of asking whether we need to change the coach again, what we have to be asking first and foremost as a club is why does this keep happening regardless of who the players are or who the coaches are? We've also seen ownership change hands in that time and multiple CEO's. They all change but the malaise, culture, cancer, whatever you want to call it always remains. Until someone can figure out what the club needs to do to eradicate that for good then all a change of coach is going to be right now is a reactive move, a shot in the dark in the hope that it provides short term relief until the cycle starts to repeat itself once more.

The club desperately needs a long-term plan for me.
User avatar
RankPostsTeam
Fringe Player510No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Sep 02 20231 year135th
OnlineLast PostLast Page
15th Jun 24 22:5515th Jun 24 22:49LINK
Milestone Posts
500
1000
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530

Re: Smith - should he stay or should he go? : Sun Mar 17, 2024 7:08 pm  
Chris71 wrote:
Said it many times Gentle certainly wasn’t the problem and had AP backed him to do his job we certainly wouldn’t be anywhere to the mess we are in right now.

For me the way AP handled things then was probably the start of the problems that have become deep seated issues that are now ingrained in to the fabric of the club.

The one coach he needed to give time too he pulled the trigger on far too early and then hired the one who lead the revolt all because Gentle was a proper coach and made train hard


Spot on…I went to a u-21s game and Gentle was there to watch as was some 1st teamers.Always felt he was unfairly sacked as had us playing good rugby but his assistant was wispering in Pearson ear.For me Smith,Gene,Davidson and Grix can go..mayoharsh on Grix but not seen anything different from him to what Ellis was doing.Doubt we have the money to do that or go all out for Rowley.Pearson got his fingers burnt with Hodgson But there must be a assistant down under who would relish it.Another Peter Sharp would do…stood no nonsense and had us playing well.
PreviousNext

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Brid B&W, Chris71, ComeOnYouUll, Costadelsolbill, DABHAND, Dave K., Google Adsense [Bot], Greavsie, Hasbag, hullandbroncos, Jake the Peg, Maninasuitcase, oooh Gravy!, tommyfinn and 318 guests

REPLY

Subject: 
Message:
   
Please note using apple style emoji's can result in posting failures.
Use the FULL EDITOR to better format content or upload images, be notified of replies etc...

Return to Hull FC


RLFANS Recent Posts
FORUM
LAST
POST
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
2m
TV Games - Not Hull
Jake the Peg
1931
4m
Toulouse v Dons Saturday 15/6/24 6pm
Kick and cha
19
Recent
Game - Song Titles
Wanderer
37547
Recent
BORED The Band Name Game
Wanderer
59652
FORUM
LAST
VIEW
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
13s
Kevin Sinfield
Philth
4
18s
Transfer Talk / Rumour thread V4
Once were Lo
9153
21s
Andy Badrock - new signing apparently
Vancouver Le
2
30s
MND day at Laund Hill
H.G.S.A
2
30s
Leigh Leopards Resurgence Claims Dragons Scalp
RLFANS News
1
33s
7pm tonight
Shifty Cat
9
1m
Widnes away
Trojan Horse
68
1m
Oliver Russell
Prince Buste
48
1m
Leeds at Home
boardwalkemp
262
1m
Rhinos Sporting Director Announcement
Exeter Rhino
166
FORUM
NEW
TOPICS
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
TODAY
TJ on a diet
Trojan Horse
5
TODAY
Leigh Leopards Resurgence Claims Dragons Scalp
RLFANS News
1
TODAY
Kevin Sinfield
Philth
4
TODAY
Jon Wilkin
Chesterrhino
1
TODAY
Hull FC Get Second Win By Beating the Rhinos
RLFANS News
1
TODAY
Surely its all over now for Watson
Hangerman2
2
TODAY
Super Salford First Half Slays The Wolves
RLFANS News
1
TODAY
Tonights game v Salford
matt_wire
75
TODAY
7pm tonight
Shifty Cat
9
TODAY
Andy Badrock - new signing apparently
Vancouver Le
2
TODAY
OCarroll extends contract
smiffythebul
4
TODAY
Sintillins
BigTime
5
TODAY
Max Lehmann signs
Rafa9
4
TODAY
Squads - Dragons v Leopards
Cokey
1
TODAY
Whitehaven A
Bull Mania
4
TODAY
Round 13 Hull FC A
Once were Lo
98
TODAY
England to play Samoa in autumn Test Series
RLFANS News
1
NEWS ITEMS
VIEWS
Leigh Leopards Resurgence Clai..
189
Hull FC Get Second Win By Beat..
202
Super Salford First Half Slays..
340
England to play Samoa in autum..
326
Wakefield Trinity Show No Merc..
1352
Wigan Warriors Dominate Challe..
1052
St Helens Beat Leeds To Lift F..
1160
Rugby League to pay homage to ..
1247
2024 State of Origin - Game 1 ..
1282
Rob Burrow - The Passing of a ..
1784
Salford Red Devils Up To Six A..
1412
Leeds Into The Six After Derby..
1413
Weakened Wigan Beat Warrington..
1453
St Helens Extend Lead At The T..
1516
Wigan Warriors Back Level Top ..
2741
RLFANS Match Centre
Matches on TV
Sun 16th Jun
SL
15:00
LondonB-St.Helens
Thu 20th Jun
SL
20:00
Castleford-Hull KR
Fri 21st Jun
SL
20:00
Leeds-Leigh
SL
20:00
Wigan-LondonB
Sat 22nd Jun
SL
15:00
Hull FC-Warrington
SL
17:30
Catalans-Huddersfield
Sun 23rd Jun
SL
15:00
Salford-St.Helens
Wed 26th Jun
SOO
11:05
New South Wales-Queensland
Sat 29th Jun
MINT2024
17:00
France M-England M
WINT2024
14:30
FRANCE W-ENGLAND W
Wed 17th Jul
SOO
11:05
Queensland-New South Wales
Sat 17th Aug
SL
18:00
Warrington-Leeds
SL
15:30
Wigan-St.Helens
SL
13:00
Hull FC-LondonB
Sun 18th Aug
SL
13:00
Leigh-Salford
SL
15:30
Catalans-Hull KR
SL
18:00
Huddersfield-Castleford
Sun 27th Oct
MINT2024
14:30
England M-Samoa M
Sat 2nd Nov
MINT2024
14:30
England M-Samoa M
Sun 16th Jun
NRL 15 Manly30-14St.George
Sat 15th Jun
SL 14 Hull FC18-10Leeds
SL 14 Catalans2-10Leigh
WSL2024 6 BarrowW6-46WiganW
WSL2024 6 FeatherstoneW10-16Wire W
CH 11 Barrow28-38Halifax
CH 11 Toulouse52-0Doncaster
NRL 15 Wests18-10Gold Coast
NRL 15 NZ Warriors24-38Melbourne
NRL 15 Parramatta18-28Sydney
Fri 14th Jun
SL 14 Castleford8-10Wigan
SL 14 Hull KR32-6Huddersfield
SL 14 Warrington14-25Salford
NRL 15 Canberra16-34NQL Cowboys
NRL 15 Souths22-12Brisbane
Thu 13th Jun
NRL 15 Cronulla28-30Dolphins
Sun 9th Jun
NRL 14 Melbourne36-28Newcastle
NRL 14 Penrith32-22Manly
Sat 8th Jun
18956 Wakefield50-6Sheffield
NRL 14 Gold Coast12-46Souths
This is an inplay table and live positions can change.
Mens Betfred Super League XXVIII ROUND : 1
 PLDFADIFFPTS
Wigan 13 367 164 203 22
St.Helens 13 353 136 217 20
Hull KR 14 370 189 181 20
Warrington 14 334 195 139 18
Salford 14 275 270 5 18
Catalans 14 266 202 64 16
 
Leeds 14 256 260 -4 14
Huddersfield 14 280 295 -15 12
Leigh 13 254 208 46 11
Castleford 14 226 416 -190 7
Hull FC 14 180 450 -270 4
LondonB 13 134 510 -376 2
This is an inplay table and live positions can change.
Betfred Championship 2024 ROUND : 1
 PLDFADIFFPTS
Wakefield 10 384 100 284 20
Widnes 10 260 171 89 15
Sheffield 10 288 170 118 14
Toulouse 10 276 174 102 12
Featherstone 10 290 211 79 12
Bradford 10 229 184 45 12
 
Doncaster 11 215 279 -64 9
Swinton 10 226 270 -44 8
Batley 10 161 218 -57 8
Whitehaven 10 192 272 -80 8
Halifax 11 208 313 -105 8
Barrow 10 179 293 -114 8
York 11 201 251 -50 6
Dewsbury 11 144 303 -159 2
RLFANS Recent Posts
FORUM
LAST
POST
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
2m
TV Games - Not Hull
Jake the Peg
1931
4m
Toulouse v Dons Saturday 15/6/24 6pm
Kick and cha
19
Recent
Game - Song Titles
Wanderer
37547
Recent
BORED The Band Name Game
Wanderer
59652
FORUM
LAST
VIEW
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
13s
Kevin Sinfield
Philth
4
18s
Transfer Talk / Rumour thread V4
Once were Lo
9153
21s
Andy Badrock - new signing apparently
Vancouver Le
2
30s
MND day at Laund Hill
H.G.S.A
2
30s
Leigh Leopards Resurgence Claims Dragons Scalp
RLFANS News
1
33s
7pm tonight
Shifty Cat
9
1m
Widnes away
Trojan Horse
68
1m
Oliver Russell
Prince Buste
48
1m
Leeds at Home
boardwalkemp
262
1m
Rhinos Sporting Director Announcement
Exeter Rhino
166
FORUM
NEW
TOPICS
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
TODAY
TJ on a diet
Trojan Horse
5
TODAY
Leigh Leopards Resurgence Claims Dragons Scalp
RLFANS News
1
TODAY
Kevin Sinfield
Philth
4
TODAY
Jon Wilkin
Chesterrhino
1
TODAY
Hull FC Get Second Win By Beating the Rhinos
RLFANS News
1
TODAY
Surely its all over now for Watson
Hangerman2
2
TODAY
Super Salford First Half Slays The Wolves
RLFANS News
1
TODAY
Tonights game v Salford
matt_wire
75
TODAY
7pm tonight
Shifty Cat
9
TODAY
Andy Badrock - new signing apparently
Vancouver Le
2
TODAY
OCarroll extends contract
smiffythebul
4
TODAY
Sintillins
BigTime
5
TODAY
Max Lehmann signs
Rafa9
4
TODAY
Squads - Dragons v Leopards
Cokey
1
TODAY
Whitehaven A
Bull Mania
4
TODAY
Round 13 Hull FC A
Once were Lo
98
TODAY
England to play Samoa in autumn Test Series
RLFANS News
1
NEWS ITEMS
VIEWS
Leigh Leopards Resurgence Clai..
189
Hull FC Get Second Win By Beat..
202
Super Salford First Half Slays..
340
England to play Samoa in autum..
326
Wakefield Trinity Show No Merc..
1352
Wigan Warriors Dominate Challe..
1052
St Helens Beat Leeds To Lift F..
1160
Rugby League to pay homage to ..
1247
2024 State of Origin - Game 1 ..
1282
Rob Burrow - The Passing of a ..
1784
Salford Red Devils Up To Six A..
1412
Leeds Into The Six After Derby..
1413
Weakened Wigan Beat Warrington..
1453
St Helens Extend Lead At The T..
1516
Wigan Warriors Back Level Top ..
2741


Visit the RLFANS.COM SHOP
for more merchandise!