Re: Shopping list for 2025 : Sat Aug 31, 2024 9:27 pm  

Steve0 wrote:

Which makes it look like a desperation signing, he's a good player, but I'm not sure he's the right one to use our final marquee (and quota spot) on when we already have a capable fullback in Walker, two promising youngsters in Barron and Martin on the wing and briscoe as another reliable option there. Playing rapana in the centres will likely lead to fans turning on him quickly next season when he struggles there defensively

Totally agree. He is absolutely revered by Canberra fans for his attitude and determination and they are disappointed that he is leaving.

He would be a great acquisition for any SL club but he's as a winger who has played a few games this season at fullback.

The last quota place should have been used for a centre.

Re: Shopping list for 2025 : Sat Aug 31, 2024 9:45 pm  

Rapana just seems like another instance of us signing a name rather than a player we really need. Several, cust and ropana are poor quota options for us imo

Re: Shopping list for 2025 : Sat Aug 31, 2024 9:47 pm  

Marcus's Bicycle wrote:

Totally agree. He is absolutely revered by Canberra fans for his attitude and determination and they are disappointed that he is leaving.

He would be a great acquisition for any SL club but he's as a winger who has played a few games this season at fullback.

The last quota place should have been used for a centre.

Were there any NRL centres available, though?

Re: Shopping list for 2025 : Sat Aug 31, 2024 9:56 pm  

The club will know who else is leaving, hence Rapana probably replacing Walker and Cust probably replacing Smith.
I like Walker a lot, but he just misses too many games.
Hopefully Myler has a couple of domestic signings up his sleeve, one being a forward.
The thing I think is just as important, are the off field appointments. The club can also make a statement with who they bring in.

Re: Shopping list for 2025 : Sun Sep 01, 2024 12:23 am  

Sebasteeno wrote:

Disagree. That team today with Abdul and sezer in would of been massively better

I agree with that Seb but you cant compare Sezer/Abdul pairing to what we had today in Smith and Charles
There are far better halfback combos in the Championship than Smith and Charles
My point about Sezer was that if you look at how innefective he was at Leeds that surely should have been the indicator to Myler to say stay away.Thats why i said its a desperation signing.

Re: Shopping list for 2025 : Sun Sep 01, 2024 4:53 am  

Brad Schneider off contract end of this season. I generally don't know why we didn't speak to him. Killing it for Penrith.

Rapana will be good for the club off the field as well as on it. When you have Canberra fans raging they didn't offer a two year contract that's a good thing isn't it!?

Still don't get the Sezer signing. Him and Abdul are almost identical players!

Is it right Abdul has a target fitness/weight in the contract for pre season start?

Re: Shopping list for 2025 : Sun Sep 01, 2024 5:17 am  

Blackandwhitebigdog wrote:

Brad Schneider off contract end of this season. I generally don't know why we didn't speak to him. Killing it for Penrith.

Rapana will be good for the club off the field as well as on it. When you have Canberra fans raging they didn't offer a two year contract that's a good thing isn't it!?

Still don't get the Sezer signing. Him and Abdul are almost identical players!

Is it right Abdul has a target fitness/weight in the contract for pre season start?

He isn't off contract, also if he is killing it, Penrith wouldn't be letting him go. Plays a similar game to the two we have signed, a fit Abdul has a better running game than him

Re: Shopping list for 2025 : Sun Sep 01, 2024 5:18 am  

I’m as critical as anyone of this recruitment cycle and felt we needed a real X factor player at 6 or 7 but on reflection and yesterdays reminder just how much we lack organisation I think the negative reaction to Sezer (me being guilty) is quite silly now.

I don’t know what happened in that second season at Leeds I can’t remember if he was really that poor or not but that aside if you look at his stats he’s really been a handy player his whole career. He’s been a first choice 7 pretty much his whole NRL career and racked up not far off 200 first grade games despite spending 3 years over here. Put that in perspective with someone like Clune at Hudds and other SL players that end up doing well decent he’s obviously got quality and a smart player. At 33 I’d have still said you only get one year at first but maybe that is the reality of where we are.

Re: Shopping list for 2025 : Sun Sep 01, 2024 6:03 am  

Watch the game again yesterday, going from Charles (not ready) and Smith to Seizer and Abdul (plus cust) is a massive upgrade.

Re: Shopping list for 2025 : Sun Sep 01, 2024 6:12 am  

bonaire wrote:

I agree with that Seb but you cant compare Sezer/Abdul pairing to what we had today in Smith and Charles
There are far better halfback combos in the Championship than Smith and Charles
My point about Sezer was that if you look at how innefective he was at Leeds that surely should have been the indicator to Myler to say stay away.Thats why i said its a desperation signing.

How was he innefective at Leeds? In his first season they won 70% of games he played in.