Re: Rumours.... : Wed Sep 05, 2012 11:31 am  

JedRust wrote:

No would expect him to be one of the firsts though

Any one else you know of for certain?
You may have already mentioned it but with hundreds of posts and several threads can't remember who you said

Re: Rumours.... : Wed Sep 05, 2012 11:37 am  

Got a text saying same thing this morning but jedR says it's so take it as done.

Re: Rumours.... : Wed Sep 05, 2012 11:40 am  

Liam666 wrote:

Any one else you know of for certain?
You may have already mentioned it but with hundreds of posts and several threads can't remember who you said

i haven't mentioned it although the people i know and get a lot of my stuff off have, id say Chase, Holdsworth, Johnson, Crookes, Mcdonnell and then they have spoke to the likes of Amor Bateman Whitehead Taylor but i don't know about these or how likely they are

Re: Rumours.... : Wed Sep 05, 2012 11:46 am  

JedRust wrote:

i haven't mentioned it although the people i know and get a lot of my stuff off have, id say Chase, Holdsworth, Johnson, Crookes, Mcdonnell and then they have spoke to the likes of Amor Bateman Whitehead Taylor but i don't know about these or how likely they are

Am I adding two and two together and getting 5 or was the McDonnell signing Gentles plan from when he first took the job?

Reading the HDM article last week everything just fell into place.

Re: Rumours.... : Wed Sep 05, 2012 11:48 am  

Sheldon wrote:

Am I adding two and two together and getting 5 or was the McDonnell signing Gentles plan from when he first took the job?

Reading the HDM article last week everything just fell into place.

I had heard that out of the two Mckinnon and Mcdonnell Gentle would have signed Mcdonnell

Re: Rumours.... : Wed Sep 05, 2012 11:51 am  

JedRust wrote:

I had heard that out of the two Mckinnon and Mcdonnell Gentle would have signed Mcdonnell

Makes sense now, no wonder the hkr fans are upset.

It wasn't like we stole Dobson from them half way through a season but what goes around and all that.

Re: Rumours.... : Wed Sep 05, 2012 11:54 am  

Sheldon wrote:

Makes sense now, no wonder the hkr fans are upset.

It wasn't like we stole Dobson from them half way through a season but what goes around and all that.

agreed, Taylor next haha

Re: Rumours.... : Wed Sep 05, 2012 11:57 am  

JedRust wrote:

I had heard that out of the two Mckinnon and Mcdonnell Gentle would have signed Mcdonnell

Interesting, well I haven't seen much of McDonnell to compare him to McKinnon

If he signed yesterday that would mean that he wasn't one of the 6 AP was quoted saying months ago that was 'done' would it?

Re: Rumours.... : Wed Sep 05, 2012 12:02 pm  

Liam666 wrote:

Interesting, well I haven't seen much of McDonnell to compare him to McKinnon

If he signed yesterday that would mean that he wasn't one of the 6 AP was quoted saying months ago that was 'done' would it?

yeh it still the same thing id expect, agreed a deal to come months back as part of the six but officially signed it yesterday

[Mild Rover]

Re: Rumours.... : Wed Sep 05, 2012 12:03 pm  

Liam666 wrote:

Interesting, well I haven't seen much of McDonnell to compare him to McKinnon

If he signed yesterday that would mean that he wasn't one of the 6 AP was quoted saying months ago that was 'done' would it?

When AP said 'signed', he meant 'agreed', I'm sure. While the anti-tampering rule is clearly unenforcible, and thus pointless, if signed, dated contracts existed, even the RFL might feel obliged to investigate.