Re: Salford game : Wed Apr 29, 2015 7:36 pm  

Irregular Hoops wrote:

Not picking Naughton is criminal.
Disappointing we pick someone like Howarth rather than giving an academy player more of an opportunity.
Sums up the safety first approach we currently employ. Not working though is it.

Howarth is a complete waste of a bench spot. Comes on for the final 15 minutes and offers nothing

Re: Salford game : Wed Apr 29, 2015 7:36 pm  

paintman wrote:

It begs the question as to why Ben Crooks was shipped off to Aus yet Yeaman is getting picked no matter how he performs.

Yes it does.

Re: Salford game : Wed Apr 29, 2015 7:46 pm  

Jake the Peg wrote:

Howarth is a complete waste of a bench spot. Comes on for the final 15 minutes and offers nothing

The use of the interchange bench has been pretty woeful this year.

The fact that he hasn't changed things round either personnel or game plan wise, even though we've been very poor, indicates to me that he's incapable of turning things round.

Crooks has gone, Naughton will leave. Any players with flair are soon disposed of. Sad.

Re: Salford game : Thu Apr 30, 2015 6:23 am  

http://m.hulldailymail.co.uk/Hull-FC-re ... story.html

http://m.hulldailymail.co.uk/Hull-FC-re ... story.html

Re: Salford game : Thu Apr 30, 2015 6:48 am  

daveh wrote:

Where is Ellis? Wasn't he a possible for Sheffield?

That was the injury tmeline,
Understand him missing that one but another 3 games on?
Obviously keepin it quiet with enough bad news around.

Re: Salford game : Thu Apr 30, 2015 7:44 am  

The Milky Bar Kid wrote:

http://m.hulldailymail.co.uk/Hull-FC-reject-Salford-Red-Devils-approach-Jordan/story-26412448-detail/story.html

I hope for Abdull's sake that's because he's in line for a few first team games for us now.

Re: Salford game : Thu Apr 30, 2015 8:00 am  

carl_spackler wrote:

I hope for Abdull's sake that's because he's in line for a few first team games for us now.

Hope so. After Pryce's pi$$ poor display on Friday I'd stick him in at 6.

Saying that, I'd drop Yeaman and put Sa back in the centres, start Whiting in the back row and put Turgut on the bench instead of Howarth. But, this isn't RL Live. If it was, purely to give some of the players a kick, I'd go with:

Shaul
Lineham
Talanoa
Sa
Naughton
Abdull
Sneyd
Watts
Houghton
Feka
Whiting
Mini
Thompson

Cunningham
Turgut
BTW
Rankin

Re: Salford game : Thu Apr 30, 2015 8:10 am  

Errlee Berd wrote:

Hope so. After Pryce's pi$$ poor display on Friday I'd stick him in at 6.

Saying that, I'd drop Yeaman and put Sa back in the centres, start Whiting in the back row and put Turgut on the bench instead of Howarth. But, this isn't RL Live. If it was, purely to give some of the players a kick, I'd go with:

Shaul
Lineham
Talanoa
Sa
Naughton
Abdull
Sneyd
Watts
Houghton
Feka
Whiting
Mini
Thompson

Cunningham
Turgut
BTW
Rankin

I didn't see last week so I don't know how bad he was, but I wouldn't personally drop Pryce after one bad game, I think his other performances so far have earned him a second chance as long as he's fit to play.

I'd go very similar to you, but Pryce still in, Abdull 13, Thompson prop, Paleaaesina bench, Rankin out.

[Chris71]

Re: Salford game : Thu Apr 30, 2015 8:28 am  

Jake the Peg wrote:

Howarth is a complete waste of a bench spot. Comes on for the final 15 minutes and offers nothing

Its just like having Agar back, players on the bench not being used or very sparingly, poor tactics, lack of support play, no dummy or angled runners, shocking last play options (if we actually have any) and no real desire to get up and at the opposition. We seem far to happy to wait for the oppostition to come at us that actually go to them and the players are constantly stood closely grouped when they receive the ball instead of running onto balls which means we see players running along the line yet again with little or no options.

Its more depressing now than at any time I can remember and I've seen some tough times but then the club was in a shambles off the field but now we have the club in a great position thanks to Pearson but his decisions regarding on field matters are destroying any chance of bringing the club back to the top.

Whilst the players are not faultless in their own performances a lot has to said about what for me appears to be a total lack of direction and enthusiam from the Coach. Its doesnt matter whether you are in sport or part of a team in a regular job if you have a poor manager/leader then your own performance in your job role suffer and create a general apathy as it breeds. This for me is part of the problem and the so called cancer, I think Gentle was trying to instill better in the club and feel he was given the chop because Pearson backed the wrong Donkeys.

[Chris71]

Re: Salford game : Thu Apr 30, 2015 8:32 am  

carl_spackler wrote:

I didn't see last week so I don't know how bad he was, but I wouldn't personally drop Pryce after one bad game, I think his other performances so far have earned him a second chance as long as he's fit to play.

I'd go very similar to you, but Pryce still in, Abdull 13, Thompson prop, Paleaaesina bench, Rankin out.

To be fair to Pryce I would say he has earnt the right to have an off night, the guy has proved my wrong and has been for me a very good addition. His desire and effort is there to see and I honestly think he looked as though he'd had enough of trying to bust his balls for nothing and no support from other players who should know better.

With the exception of Pryce, Mini, Paea, Shaul and laterly Lineham the rest of the 17 players have just not performed. Minichello has been an absolute joy to watch just a shame he is in such a poorly coached team.