Re: Squad for Friday : Fri May 14, 2021 8:23 am  

MOPSEY LIVES ON wrote:

I’m astounded by some posters on here, toupo In the team all day, he makes ground, he makes breaks and on his day he’s a match winner and we want as many match winners in the team as possible. Why on earth would anyone replace a player with a player no where near as good

I second that - even an off-form Bill is better that what is in the squad for tonight!

Re: Squad for Friday : Fri May 14, 2021 8:28 am  

Mary Millington wrote:

I second that - even an off-form Bill is better that what is in the squad for tonight!

Absolutely but in my opinion, not in the centre - Both Arundel and Lyne never let anyone down and either rarely have a bad performance.

On the wing - Yes. In my honest opinion both Kay and Kershaw have both shown they are targets and defensively are not great at this level and are both prone to silly errors that cost us dearly. I would have Tupou and Senior on our wings every time over these 2.

Re: Squad for Friday : Fri May 14, 2021 8:34 am  

homme vaste wrote:

Mary Millington wrote:

I second that - even an off-form Bill is better that what is in the squad for tonight!

Absolutely but in my opinion, not in the centre - Both Arundel and Lyne never let anyone down and either rarely have a bad performance.

On the wing - Yes. In my honest opinion both Kay and Kershaw have both shown they are targets and defensively are not great at this level and are both prone to silly errors that cost us dearly. I would have Tupou and Senior on our wings every time over these 2.

I can see why Tupou isn’t playing today with the defensive mate he had in last game but I also agree with this. I think Bill would still be in my team presently and I would definitely put him on the wing outside Arundel until TJ is back with Senior on the right. That to me is the best backline we currently have once Jowitt gets back to 1.

Re: Squad for Friday : Fri May 14, 2021 8:42 am  

MOPSEY LIVES ON wrote:

I’m astounded by some posters on here, toupo In the team all day, he makes ground, he makes breaks and on his day he’s a match winner and we want as many match winners in the team as possible. Why on earth would anyone replace a player with a player no where near as good

He does but Arundel is a better centre in my opinion, especially in a team out of form. However why the outrage, he's out injured apparently.

Frankly I'll take either Arundel or Tupou so long as they are fit and up for it.

Re: Squad for Friday : Fri May 14, 2021 8:43 am  

Sorry Bill in the centre for me .Trouble is we have got two wingers who are not S L standed and are not helping our defence at all

Re: Squad for Friday : Fri May 14, 2021 8:44 am  

Mary Millington wrote:

I second that - even an off-form Bill is better that what is in the squad for tonight!

I get the feeling that no matter what CC did you'd disagree, you're clearly another person on here with total access to the squad on a day-by-day basis.

Re: Squad for Friday : Fri May 14, 2021 8:46 am  

alegend wrote:

Sorry Bill in the centre for me .Trouble is we have got two wingers who are not S L standed and are not helping our defence at all

But he's injured not dropped so what is the problem.

Re: Squad for Friday : Fri May 14, 2021 9:04 am  

vastman wrote:

I get the feeling that no matter what CC did you'd disagree, you're clearly another person on here with total access to the squad on a day-by-day basis.

You clearly don't know me and you're clearly wrong.

Re: Squad for Friday : Fri May 14, 2021 9:09 am  

alegend wrote:

Sorry Bill in the centre for me .Trouble is we have got two wingers who are not S L standed and are not helping our defence at all

Anyone who thinks it was just the wingers fault for that defending the other week needs to take a look at the video again. Nearly every attack from under the posts
Players not working hard enough and pushing out, players not numbering off, players shooting across others, players going to high and getting knocked off. You've got to trust your inside man to do their job and you do yours

Re: Squad for Friday : Fri May 14, 2021 9:43 am  

Mary Millington wrote:

You clearly don't know me and you're clearly wrong.

Perhaps, but the point remains, Bill is injured according to CC.