Re: Kevin Proctor Staying On : Tue Jul 18, 2023 10:33 am  

PopTart wrote:

That's the bit I don't get. You say he can't pass and has no running game and even say he misses tackles but then say he might develop into a good 13?

In answer to the question about Proctor. He is clearly having a problem with fitness but he has a good pass and not only never misses a tackle but clear hurts opponents when he hits them.
I'd like him to do more minutes and make more yards but ultimately he is a second row playing as a middle.....and clearly, his lack of fitness is why he's at Wakefield not NRL.
I wouldn't renew but he clearly has more skills than Crowthervto me.

I’m giving more leniency with him being a trinity product than I’d afford others tbf with that comment. Some forwards really blossom late into their 20s, Crowther might be one of these so I don’t want to write him off completely. It’s perhaps a hope with Crowther that in what should be his prime years that he could develop those skills to make a good 13, I say might because it would be a gamble from where he is now in term of skill levels.

As for Proctor, he only does 25/30 minutes or so but during that he really does put himself about so I’ve no issue with him. Agree about his lack of fitness. He does put in repeat tackles one after another.

Re: Kevin Proctor Staying On : Tue Jul 18, 2023 11:02 am  

PopTart wrote:

That's the bit I don't get. You say he can't pass and has no running game and even say he misses tackles but then say he might develop into a good 13?

In answer to the question about Proctor. He is clearly having a problem with fitness but he has a good pass and not only never misses a tackle but clear hurts opponents when he hits them.
I'd like him to do more minutes and make more yards but ultimately he is a second row playing as a middle.....and clearly, his lack of fitness is why he's at Wakefield not NRL.
I wouldn't renew but he clearly has more skills than Crowthervto me.

For me he can pass, clearly or he would not have covered at 9. Distribution not as good as a natural 9 but okay for cover. Safe enough hands for a 13 at first receiver, but again never going to be quite as effective as say Westerman was.

We'll have to agree to disagree, I would have Crowther as more skillfull and contributing more in the squad and on the pitch over Proctor any day. Only thing I would have in Proctor's favour is that he doesn't seem to come up with many drop balls, which is something Crowther could improve on. That said, when you only take 4 carries in a game, you're less likely to knock on..

Re: Kevin Proctor Staying On : Tue Jul 18, 2023 11:25 am  

RWB wrote:

For me he can pass, clearly or he would not have covered at 9. Distribution not as good as a natural 9 but okay for cover. Safe enough hands for a 13 at first receiver, but again never going to be quite as effective as say Westerman was.

We'll have to agree to disagree, I would have Crowther as more skillfull and contributing more in the squad and on the pitch over Proctor any day. Only thing I would have in Proctor's favour is that he doesn't seem to come up with many drop balls, which is something Crowther could improve on. That said, when you only take 4 carries in a game, you're less likely to knock on..

Passing from 9 under little pressure for the most part is not the same as receiving the ball within a set play/move with runners and options available. 13 is rarely first receiver either, they are usually second/third and provide a link up or to engage the line and then pass to either a pivot to shift play to the edges or to a runner. Westerman often took the ball to the line and passed before contact once engaging defenders. That’s imo what a 13 should be doing. Not head down driving it in as Crowther does.

He’s a trinity product and honestly I want him to succeed. I’m not sure he will if he can’t improve this side of his game though. This is just my opinion ofcourse from what I’ve seen. He does have time on his side though over the next 5-8 years.

If we are looking at loose forwards then Jake Wingfield would be a good target though maybe not short of suitors.

Re: Kevin Proctor Staying On : Tue Jul 18, 2023 1:36 pm  

Crowther sis a decent utility player, always gives 100 percent , if he’s gone to cas to play in championship good luck to him.

Re: Kevin Proctor Staying On : Tue Jul 18, 2023 3:21 pm  

Surely "if "Jordan has signed for Cas there's a conflict of interest. Because of our current plight would it be better to put him on " gardening leave".

Re: Kevin Proctor Staying On : Tue Jul 18, 2023 7:45 pm  

poplar cats alive wrote:

Surely "if "Jordan has signed for Cas there's a conflict of interest. Because of our current plight would it be better to put him on " gardening leave".

Even if he were we wouldn’t and shouldn’t find out as fans. Something like that could likely be covered with injury news or a loan deal to another team.

Re: Kevin Proctor Staying On : Wed Jul 19, 2023 5:52 am  

I am a bit confused as to who’s in and out of contract This is a list published (I realise that some of the press don’t actually do any research pre publication ) https://www.loverugbyleague.com/post/ev ... nd-of-2023 But tanginoa and whitbread aren’t on the list - also eseh but am assuming that’s because he’s not a big name

I am a bit confused as to who’s in and out of contract This is a list published (I realise that some of the press don’t actually do any research pre publication ) https://www.loverugbyleague.com/post/ev ... nd-of-2023 But tanginoa and whitbread aren’t on the list - also eseh but am assuming that’s because he’s not a big name

Re: Kevin Proctor Staying On : Wed Jul 19, 2023 6:45 am  

Kirmudgeonlyisback wrote: I am a bit confused as to who’s in and out of contract This is a list published (I realise that some of the press don’t actually do any research pre publication ) https://www.loverugbyleague.com/post/ev ... nd-of-2023 But tanginoa and whitbread aren’t on the list - also eseh but am assuming that’s because he’s not a big name That’s because they are under contract. Thought it was common knowledge. From memory… Eseh - 2024 Whitbread - 2025 Tanginoa - 2024

Kirmudgeonlyisback wrote: I am a bit confused as to who’s in and out of contract This is a list published (I realise that some of the press don’t actually do any research pre publication ) https://www.loverugbyleague.com/post/ev ... nd-of-2023 But tanginoa and whitbread aren’t on the list - also eseh but am assuming that’s because he’s not a big name That’s because they are under contract. Thought it was common knowledge. From memory… Eseh - 2024 Whitbread - 2025 Tanginoa - 2024

[PopTart]

Re: Kevin Proctor Staying On : Wed Jul 19, 2023 7:40 am  

They don't need to research this. RFL publish it. So it should be right.