Sounds to me we have brought in a square peg to fit in to a round hole again Smith a hooker who can play stand of ,This coaching staff have lost the plot big time more money wasted .As a post said ,a 6 with half a brain would have been better We needed a player to strengthen the team not a player were we have 4 or 5 players for that posion

So you know where this half is then?

Thought not.

There is no round peg at all, he’s been signed to cover Kelepi at a guess I was just pointing out he can play centre.

As for cost I doubt there is one for just two weeks don’t you? I suspect it’s a mutual favour, game time for him, cover for us.

I’ve no idea how you find a lose in that.

Don't know if we have extended his loan yet, but he has picked up a 1 match ban for that crusher tackle on Friday. Didn't see him play in the Salford game, but I wasn't impressed with him on Friday !! We had other players cited too, but luckily no further bans picked up... https://www.rugby-league.com/governance ... nary-cases

Don't know if we have extended his loan yet, but he has picked up a 1 match ban for that crusher tackle on Friday. Didn't see him play in the Salford game, but I wasn't impressed with him on Friday !! We had other players cited too, but luckily no further bans picked up... https://www.rugby-league.com/governance ... nary-cases

Quote FIL="FIL"Don't know if we have extended his loan yet, but he has picked up a 1 match ban for that crusher tackle on Friday. Didn't see him play in the Salford game, but I wasn't impressed with him on Friday !! We had other players cited too, but luckily no further bans picked up... https://www.rugby-league.com/governance ... nary-cases'" I was at salford and other than letting in a try i never noticed him.that said he was part of a team that prob put best performance of the season in

Quote FIL="FIL"Don't know if we have extended his loan yet, but he has picked up a 1 match ban for that crusher tackle on Friday. Didn't see him play in the Salford game, but I wasn't impressed with him on Friday !! We had other players cited too, but luckily no further bans picked up... https://www.rugby-league.com/governance ... nary-cases'" I was at salford and other than letting in a try i never noticed him.that said he was part of a team that prob put best performance of the season in

All I noticed on Friday was two daft penalties he gave away before his yellow. Send him back we have better at the club

Got himself a 1 match Ban, don't think he is any better than what he had, seemed like he was only brought in to cover the Proctor injury but would much rather Windrow was given a go

For all the build up he got on this post I'd say he turned out pretty disappointing!

That's not to say he isn't or won't be a top player...just not worked out and not been good enough for me...you could arguably say he's had two big involvements in both games played that have been major contributing factors to our defeats...

If the loan is costing us anything at all I just don't see the sense in extending it further with Proctor, Tanginoa and even Windrow available in the next few weeks...

Fair to say it’s not really worked out this one. Probably best to move on given players will be back by the Cas game.

I'm sure I've read somewhere that Mash wanted to extend his loan period, but that was probably said prior to the ban.

No need for me, Windrow, Tanginoa. Proctor are already employed by the club. Use them.

Young, injured, injured

Just more wasted money. The hole we are plummeting down just gets deeper. I guess someone also thought the hooker was useful. He’s really got a vested interest in Trinity hasn’t he? Stood out well too didn’t he, Hewitt certainly did with three penalties against his name.