Re: first team players : Fri Nov 06, 2015 7:32 am  

FickleFingerOfFate wrote:

Six clubs since 2011, he's done well to squeeze them in!
Got to go with Vastman on this one, been at Saints and Salford and also at Hull, so not really 'a not very good player'.
You don't stay in SL unless you got a bit of something about you.
Maybe a victim of his versatility, that he can do a job when asked.
Unfortunate to get injured not long after he signed, give him a chance under BS?

Who would you have picked him before last season, Godinet, Sio or Moore?

Re: first team players : Fri Nov 06, 2015 7:45 am  

imwakefieldtillidie wrote:

FickleFingerOfFate wrote:

Six clubs since 2011, he's done well to squeeze them in!
Got to go with Vastman on this one, been at Saints and Salford and also at Hull, so not really 'a not very good player'.
You don't stay in SL unless you got a bit of something about you.
Maybe a victim of his versatility, that he can do a job when asked.
Unfortunate to get injured not long after he signed, give him a chance under BS?

Who would you have picked him before last season, Godinet, Sio or Moore?

Howarth I believe was signed before Sio and Moore to give back up to McShane, as Godinet was struggling with an injury.
He got an injury, Sio came in and then Moore for McShane.
Moore got an injury also but Howath is still recovering from his injury.
Unfair to judge a player who is injured not long after he arrives and write him off.

[PopTart]

Re: first team players : Fri Nov 06, 2015 7:50 am  

cheshirecat57 wrote:

They 're on about Howarth .

Oh that makes more sense....... Doh!
I'll get my coat.

Re: first team players : Fri Nov 06, 2015 7:56 am  

FickleFingerOfFate wrote:

Howarth I believe was signed before Sio and Moore to give back up to McShane, as Godinet was struggling with an injury.
He got an injury, Sio came in and then Moore for McShane.
Moore got an injury also but Howath is still recovering from his injury.
Unfair to judge a player who is injured not long after he arrives and write him off.

I asked who YOU would have picked him before last season?

Re: first team players : Fri Nov 06, 2015 8:14 am  

imwakefieldtillidie wrote:

I asked who YOU would have picked him before last season?

And that question is hypothetical, as he was injured.
So on that basis, the answer to your question, is all of them

Re: first team players : Fri Nov 06, 2015 8:22 am  

FickleFingerOfFate wrote:

And that question is hypothetical, as he was injured.
So on that basis, the answer to your question, is all of them

So we agree he was 4th choice hooker? 4th choice hooker in a team that finished bottom by a long way? Not really a ringing endorsement.

And Sio was signed before Howarth got injured.

Re: first team players : Fri Nov 06, 2015 8:27 am  

imwakefieldtillidie wrote:

So we agree he was 4th choice hooker? 4th choice hooker in a team that finished bottom by a long way? Not really a ringing endorsement.

And Sio was signed before Howarth got injured.

Not what he said is it - we get it, he's your fourth choice, some of us can't make such a judgement call - maybe we are just not as smart as you.

Re: first team players : Fri Nov 06, 2015 8:29 am  

vastman wrote:

Not what he said is it - we get it, he's your fourth choice, some of us can't make such a judgement call - maybe we are just not as smart as you.

I don't think you are.

Re: first team players : Fri Nov 06, 2015 8:30 am  

imwakefieldtillidie wrote:

I don't think you are.

If you say so

Re: first team players : Fri Nov 06, 2015 8:30 am  

imwakefieldtillidie wrote:

So we agree he was 4th choice hooker? 4th choice hooker in a team that finished bottom by a long way? Not really a ringing endorsement.

And Sio was signed before Howarth got injured.

When did WE agree he was 4th choice hooker?
You may think he is but I'm willing to give a fit Howarth a chance to prove himself.