Re: Gale testimonial v Cas : Sat Jan 25, 2025 7:29 pm  

Towns88 wrote:

I'm under no illusions how difficult we'll find things. I have a similar view as you regarding the signings Rimbu could be electric but is playing behind the worst pack in the league. Everything about Cini screams he'll be in the reserves by Easter. At best a maverick, at worst a potential liability. Asi will take time and is under immense pressure early doors without Milnes, we have no goalkicker whilst Milnes is out. Simbiken replaces Ellie El Zakem, who was on the main one of our better players last year but bizarrely we've done absolutely nothing to improve our dreadful pack. Bookies have us to finish last. Think a few people perhaps got carried away with a few pics of the squad running up hills at Roundhay park.

Sam Wood made a good point in an interview saying there'll be weeks we'll just lose to a better team. That will be most weeks. Naturally I'm sure we will pinch some games at home.

Well I've always wanted Trinity and Cas to push one another along at the top end of Super League in a way that Wigan and Saints do and the way the Rhinos and The Bulls did .

I obviously want ourselves to come out on top every single time but that would be my wish for both our club's .

There's no reason why that can't happen with the new owners we both have in my opinion .

Re: Gale testimonial v Cas : Sat Jan 25, 2025 7:48 pm  

BarnsleyTrinity wrote:

Well I've always wanted Trinity and Cas to push one another along at the top end of Super League in a way that Wigan and Saints do and the way the Rhinos and The Bulls did .

I obviously want ourselves to come out on top every single time but that would be my wish for both our club's .

There's no reason why that can't happen with the new owners we both have in my opinion .

I’m of the same stance really. I would like nothing more than trinity and Cas to be fighting it out at the top but would want us to be top dog.

I don’t dislike them as a club unlike Leeds. There’s just a sense of entitlement about Leeds fans and preferential media treatment that belies their actual position.

Re: Gale testimonial v Cas : Sat Jan 25, 2025 7:52 pm  

BarnsleyTrinity wrote:

Well I've always wanted Trinity and Cas to push one another along at the top end of Super League in a way that Wigan and Saints do and the way the Rhinos and The Bulls did .

I obviously want ourselves to come out on top every single time but that would be my wish for both our club's .

There's no reason why that can't happen with the new owners we both have in my opinion .

The obvious difference being that our new owner can afford to splash his hard-earned squillions on our club whereas Cas' new owner is currently passing round the begging bowl asking for donations from wherever he can get them from

[PopTart]

Re: Gale testimonial v Cas : Sat Jan 25, 2025 7:57 pm  

BarnsleyTrinity wrote:

Well I've always wanted Trinity and Cas to push one another along at the top end of Super League in a way that Wigan and Saints do and the way the Rhinos and The Bulls did .

I obviously want ourselves to come out on top every single time but that would be my wish for both our club's .

There's no reason why that can't happen with the new owners we both have in my opinion .

I'm the same.
I don't mind them being a success. I just want us to be better.

Re: Gale testimonial v Cas : Sat Jan 25, 2025 8:07 pm  

No, no, no...I detest both Cas and the Whino's exactly the same...hope they both finish joint bottom of the table

Re: Gale testimonial v Cas : Mon Jan 27, 2025 9:11 pm  

PopTart wrote:

Walmesley, I really can't decide on him. Had some nice moments but I still worry about his confidence and size.
Hope he does well but there are some monster wingers in Super League and he's a long way from Jerry

About that..
Dunno if the comparisons I make in my own head with our recent wingers are colouring my judgement but, I decided a season ago, he just doesn't have that something that sets him apart.
He's competent, knows his job and does it well, but I keep expecting him to burn the touchline up when given half a yard, or to be in the air challenging for and winning more than his fair share of kicks in the corners, or to be a monster stepper kick returner, just something, anything, he's none of those.
He still has an air of fragility despite training with a full time squad.
He's dependable and a fair finisher but ultimately isn't outstanding in any facet.

Re: Gale testimonial v Cas : Mon Jan 27, 2025 9:32 pm  

Upanunder wrote:

About that..
Dunno if the comparisons I make in my own head with our recent wingers are colouring my judgement but, I decided a season ago, he just doesn't have that something that sets him apart.
He's competent, knows his job and does it well, but I keep expecting him to burn the touchline up when given half a yard, or to be in the air challenging for and winning more than his fair share of kicks in the corners, or to be a monster stepper kick returner, just something, anything, he's none of those.
He still has an air of fragility despite training with a full time squad.
He's dependable and a fair finisher but ultimately isn't outstanding in any facet.

Sounds like your writing a guy off before he even gets to play a single SL game.

Lads scored 110 in 109 games. Hes finished try’s with little space and from distance when put in space. He doesn’t miss tackles hardly and has held up very well against Hall and got the best of Senior in the past two games.

It all points that he can step up fine to me. I’m not expecting him to be a top winger in SL but he will defend well and score given the opportunities.

You look at Marshall at Wigan. He is none of those you listed and he just has the ability to be in the right place and finish chances Wigan create. Not every winger has to be a freak in in a certain area and most imo that do have something extraordinary about them tend to have a part of their game that is below par.

[PopTart]

Re: Gale testimonial v Cas : Mon Jan 27, 2025 10:50 pm  

My point was that I just don't know.
And I think that's kinda what Upanunder is saying.
Because he has got a particular skill it's hard to see where he'll excel.
Marshal is very fast and has a step.

Russell for example hasn't played yet but people know what he can do. Walmesley may well be better but people lean to what they know.

I hope he shows what he has got....I'm just going to have to see it to be confident.

Re: Gale testimonial v Cas : Tue Jan 28, 2025 12:32 am  

PopTart wrote:

My point was that I just don't know.
And I think that's kinda what Upanunder is saying.
Because he has got a particular skill it's hard to see where he'll excel.
Marshal is very fast and has a step.

Russell for example hasn't played yet but people know what he can do. Walmesley may well be better but people lean to what they know.

I hope he shows what he has got....I'm just going to have to see it to be confident.

Of course we don’t know and have to see how he goes but I don’t think a bit more confidence would hurt. Though I suppose with the unknown it’s only natural to have some reservations.

I’d think it you put Marshall and Walmsley in a foot race there’s not be much difference in the end. No way would Marshall have finished the Walmsley try in the corner either, he’s not got the athleticism. He’s not trying to be Marshall though and I wouldn’t expect him to be at that level either. If he gets the better of wingers like Senior snd other teams around us then I’ll take that for a debut year in SL.

We will see but I’m more confident in Walmsley after what I’ve seen but seems a few fans have reservations whether he’s SL level. We will see soon enough but hopefully he gets given a few games.

Talking about Matty Russell. Surprised we haven’t seen him yet. Wonder if he’ll feature his week with the likes of Cozza, Vagana etc.

Re: Gale testimonial v Cas : Tue Jan 28, 2025 3:24 am  

It probably didn’t help with him being played out of position at fullback or on the replacements bench. He has also been switched to the right wing for this season. What makes a good winger is a good centre who is able to create the space necessary and let’s not forget he with O’Rourke got back to stop the Leeds winger.