yeah a player saying a penalty is a penalty is exactly the same as a player photo shopping the referee into man united kit, and posting it on a social networking site, the two things are virtually identical really.

if you kick someone in the penalty area and they (choose to) fall over, it's a penalty.

it was soft, but he caught his ankle and he belatedly went over - it's a penalty, i'm not saying it's how it should be but it's how it is


some of the rawk mental cases are sensing a south yorkshire police conspiracy with Webb's involvement

Babel didn't photoshop it, it was doing the rounds well before that.


Nobody kicked no one. Did you watch the match, there was no contact.


No he didn't catch his ankle.

Your lot cried about it and had it taken down.

Lucky we had 10 man and you got a pen as your team was gash today.

knee then, I've just watched it again, i reckon agger just catches his knee

well posting it then - that makes it alright then?

Right, you've made me do this, on a popular video website, copy and paste, "Berbatov Dive Vs Liverpool - Fa Cup" and click the first one, 22 seconds. Then tell me at what second does he make contact?

Liverpool weren't great though were they?

looks like there may well be some contact (not his ankle) at about the 11 / 12 second mark, not the best of angles to definitively prove it either way though...

You asking or telling?

I thought we did well with 10 men against the team who do what they want *cringe*

No contact for me. Agger puts his foot out to catch up with Berbatov, Berbatov sees in the corner of eye his foot move then just falls over, theres no contact though, he doesn't even brush him.

I prefer to search that popular video site for "Steven Gerrard - Hypocrite" to watch his wonderful array of creative dance within the opposition penalty box. Really wound me up having half my Facebook friends ranting about the dive. So what if it was a dive? It's not like Liverpool have ever dived for anything is it? FWIW I thought there was contact but it wasn't enough for a penalty.

As did I. You couldn't fault our effort or commitment. We kept United at bay at OT with 10 men for over half of the game. Martin Kelly was impressive for me.