Re: NFL Chat : Mon Oct 18, 2010 8:22 pm  

Seen as he get it's done in the 4th, is Garrard a better QB than Rodgers?

Seen as he get it's done in the 4th, is Garrard a better QB than Rodgers?

Re: NFL Chat : Mon Oct 18, 2010 8:24 pm  

El Pac Carnegie wrote: Seen as he get it's done in the 4th, is Garrard a better QB than Rodgers? Nobody's questioning that. I know Eli isn't as good and he's very good in clutch situations. Just saying that Rodgers doesn't, that isn't an opinion it's fact.

El Pac Carnegie wrote: Seen as he get it's done in the 4th, is Garrard a better QB than Rodgers? Nobody's questioning that. I know Eli isn't as good and he's very good in clutch situations. Just saying that Rodgers doesn't, that isn't an opinion it's fact.

Re: NFL Chat : Mon Oct 18, 2010 8:31 pm  

Nikaed wrote:

Nobody's questioning that. I know Eli isn't as good and he's very good in clutch situations. Just saying that Rodgers doesn't, that isn't an opinion it's fact.

Not questioning that. Though I think Rodgers has proved, in my eyes at least, he is getting that clutch ability over the last couple of weeks. He's a hell of a lot further along in his development than Eli, IMO, just Eli had that team of destiny Giants the other year.

If he continues his development at his current rate I think we could see a HOF career from Rodgers. Bradford as well

Re: NFL Chat : Mon Oct 18, 2010 8:40 pm  

El Pac Carnegie wrote:

Not questioning that. Though I think Rodgers has proved, in my eyes at least, he is getting that clutch ability over the last couple of weeks. He's a hell of a lot further along in his development than Eli, IMO, just Eli had that team of destiny Giants the other year.

If he continues his development at his current rate I think we could see a HOF career from Rodgers. Bradford as well

Eli's a good steady 15 year career type QB but he sin't going to put a team on his back and carry them like a Brady, Peyton and Brees can.

Re: NFL Chat : Mon Oct 18, 2010 8:52 pm  

This is why you keep your head up in a tackle

This is why you keep your head up in a tackle

Re: NFL Chat : Mon Oct 18, 2010 9:12 pm  

Nikaed wrote:

Spot on. How you enjoying Spags defence anyway?

Looking good so far. Great to finally see a defensive line getting pressure and not just one player getting sacks (like with Leonard Little for the last 4 or so years). Considering we're still several pieces short of where we want and need to be, the defense is looking very good in terms of its progression.

The game against the Bucs should be a cracker this weekend. I feared for the worst for the rest of the season but we showed balls coming back from such a woeful effort and winning against San Diego.

It's good to feel like I can actually enjoy Rams games again rather than just watching them out of duty and only enjoying the other games I watch

Re: NFL Chat : Mon Oct 18, 2010 9:49 pm  

Nikaed wrote:

That's not having a pop at him that's simply stating fact. The last 3 times 1, Fumbled for a touchdown 2. Threw a pick 3. Failed to move his team down the field.

In his defence. 1. BLATANT facemask should be a penalty. 2. Helmet to helmet again should be a penalty. 3. No excuses

Nikaed wrote:

Nobody's questioning that. I know Eli isn't as good and he's very good in clutch situations. Just saying that Rodgers doesn't, that isn't an opinion it's fact.

Bookmarked and potential sig material Mark!

Re: NFL Chat : Mon Oct 18, 2010 10:35 pm  

El Pac Carnegie wrote:

Can't believe I'm standing up for Conroy again but this Rodgers bashing is getting a bit silly. To put their poor start to the season squarely on Rodgers is daft IMO. He's a good QB and getting better. Crosby missing a FG isn't Rodgers fault. Rodgers has kept his team in the game the last 2 weeks.

I have never once "bashed" Rodgers I was talking about QB`s in general, the debate started with Rodgers sure but I dont think anyone has said hes a bad QB, hes certainly not a bad QB. We are merely comparing the 4th quarter comebacks and game winning drives and saying he needs to be able to do that with time to become a better QB

Re: NFL Chat : Mon Oct 18, 2010 10:37 pm  

Adamjk wrote:

I think people on here know full well how good Rodgers is. My thoughts are that they sometimes get slightly exasperated with Conroy's Packer bias and penchant for exaggeration over all things Green Bay that they like to wind him up. All in good fun though

Correct

Re: NFL Chat : Mon Oct 18, 2010 10:41 pm  

DancingDodo wrote: This is why you keep your head up in a tackle Heard about that before, havent seen it but it sounds similar to what happened to the Bills TE Kevin Everett a few seasons ago FWIR Everett made a good recovery hopefully he will do the same!!

DancingDodo wrote: This is why you keep your head up in a tackle Heard about that before, havent seen it but it sounds similar to what happened to the Bills TE Kevin Everett a few seasons ago FWIR Everett made a good recovery hopefully he will do the same!!