Re: NFL Chat 4 : Tue May 04, 2010 11:18 am  

Dead Man Walking wrote:

What will the Colts do when Manning retires though ?

Probably 2-14 or something, same with the Pats when Brady goes there's more chance of 5-11 unless both teams manage to find another HOFer in the draft.

Re: NFL Chat 4 : Tue May 04, 2010 2:18 pm  

Gaslight wrote:

Probably 2-14 or something, same with the Pats when Brady goes there's more chance of 5-11 unless both teams manage to find another HOFer in the draft.

The Patriots and Colts will not find a Brady or Manning again I think in the draft.

Re: NFL Chat 4 : Tue May 04, 2010 3:11 pm  

LFCRhino wrote:

Sometimes coaches find themselves in situations where they just cant do any wrong with the players they have Jim Caldwell would be a good example of this at the moment thats why I dont think 33-31 is such a bad record with the players/teams he had IMO and if your judging coaches on won/lost records I think that there would be a few head coaches in the nfl that shouldnt be in a job!!!

Bill Belichick had a 36-44 record with the Browns so Im glad people who do the hiring dont go by bad W/L records!!

Wasn't really my point. Only that i don't see his appointment as that outstanding given he hasn't been excellent in the NFL. He's brilliant in the college game though.

Re: NFL Chat 4 : Tue May 04, 2010 3:20 pm  

Dead Man Walking wrote:

What will the Colts do when Manning retires though ?

Colts would still be a play-off team, assuming they have a relatively decent starter. They could do with picking up a youngster pretty early in the next draft or two to have ready behind Manning. I'm not sure how old he is but he must be in his mid 30's?

As for the Patriots without Brady. They will go 16-0. Belicheat will have to take out the digicam when Brady is gone.

The same talk of a demise was suggested when we knew we were getting rid of Favre, and he is/was a better QB than either Brady or Manning. As it is we've not really lost anything at all and already have an QB at elite level two years after him leaving.

Re: NFL Chat 4 : Tue May 04, 2010 3:51 pm  

What would the Packers without Rodgers? Ah I know, they'd get to the NFC championship game(well thats what happened last time).

Tebow to be unleashed on the NFL in 2010 I think.

Re: NFL Chat 4 : Tue May 04, 2010 4:43 pm  

ST_CONROY wrote:

Wasn't really my point. Only that i don't see his appointment as that outstanding given he hasn't been excellent in the NFL. He's brilliant in the college game though.

I know what you were getting at, but my point was that Bill Belichick(as an example) was hardly first choice for Head Coaching jobs and apart from the Jests I dont think anyone else was after him after his previous head coaching stint. He had to go back to doing co-ordinator jobs and did well whilst getting more experience, I think the same has happened with Carroll and whilst I realise the college game isnt as tough as the nfl coaching wise I think he has gotten a hell of a lot more experience and as a head coach too so it can only do him good.

Like I said earlier I think he was far better than his 33-31 record suggests and the experience he has gained since can go a long way to help him as an nfl HC.

Re: NFL Chat 4 : Tue May 04, 2010 5:14 pm  

Looks like Corey Dillon has been arrested again this time for beating his wife up

You can take the player out of the Bengals but not the Bengal outta the players it would seem

Re: NFL Chat 4 : Tue May 04, 2010 5:31 pm  

LFCRhino wrote:

I know what you were getting at, but my point was that Bill Belichick(as an example) was hardly first choice for Head Coaching jobs and apart from the Jests I dont think anyone else was after him after his previous head coaching stint. He had to go back to doing co-ordinator jobs and did well whilst getting more experience, I think the same has happened with Carroll and whilst I realise the college game isnt as tough as the nfl coaching wise I think he has gotten a hell of a lot more experience and as a head coach too so it can only do him good.

Like I said earlier I think he was far better than his 33-31 record suggests and the experience he has gained since can go a long way to help him as an nfl HC.

Like all the great head coaches, Belichick learned his trade at the NRL's premier franchise..

Lombardi
Landry
Parcells
Coughlin
Belichick


All former Giants.

Re: NFL Chat 4 : Wed May 05, 2010 3:11 pm  

Jint wrote:

Like all the great head coaches, Belichick learned his trade at the NRL's premier franchise..

Lombardi
Landry
Parcells
Coughlin
Belichick


All former Giants.

They didnt all start out at the Giants though

Its a great stable of coaches to come from though thats for sure !!

Oh and NRL

Re: NFL Chat 4 : Wed May 05, 2010 6:44 pm  

Jint wrote:

Like all the great head coaches, Belichick learned his trade at the NRL's premier franchise..

Lombardi
Landry
Parcells
Coughlin
Belichick


All former Giants.

Wouldn't a list of all the greatest head coaches include Shula and Walsh they seem to be missing from your list