Roddy B wrote:
What's the verdict on Benteke then? Looks an absolute handful every time I've seen him. Before he came, the word from the Belgians seemed to be he was raw, both technically and mentally, and lacked the necessary attitude to make it in England, but he's been a huge hit since arriving.
Some people think he's ready for a CL side, I've not seen enough of him to say so but the Liverpool fans were more wet by Toure keeping him relatively quiet than they were by Sturridge's goal.
I've liked a lot of what I've seen of Benteke. But he's also been undisciplined, didn't know about the offside law during one of the games, and his scoring record at Villa isn't massively different to Demba Ba's record in England.
I reckon he might work at Arsenal. I don't think either of the Manc clubs would be interested in him, I think he'd struggle like Demba Ba at Chelsea.
Playing for a top 4 side is different to playing for Aston Villa. In theory you're playing with better players so will be given more chances, but in practice most of the time you are playing against the parked bus.
Personally I think he should stay at Villa for a few years and rack up more experience. He's only 22, which is still a kid in terms of centre forwards. He'll get played pretty much every week at Villa which he wouldn't be guaranteed at a CL club.
I think Mourinho could work with him and develop him. But I wouldn't to have him subjected to our fans in a million years.