Re: Dream Team 2023 : Wed Sep 27, 2023 3:27 pm  

Pieman wrote:

Farrimonds a Leyther

And Harry's neither

Re: Dream Team 2023 : Wed Sep 27, 2023 3:44 pm  

Jukesays wrote:

And Harry's neither

Don’t know how I forgot that, I always say “he’s not a Wiganer” when they sing “he’s one of our own”

Re: Dream Team 2023 : Thu Sep 28, 2023 5:26 am  

As a Saints fan I like Harry Smith. Admittedly I don’t see him as often as you all do. But I would definitely have him at Saints. I think he currently offers more than Dodd does and whilst Dodds ceiling may be higher, it’s irrelevant if he doesn’t reach that ceiling. I notice a poster mentioned earlier that he’s not a big game player but I disagree. The vision and execution for that kick to Marshall in the CC cup semi against Saints was the epitome of a big game play.

Re: Dream Team 2023 : Thu Sep 28, 2023 7:51 am  

RobRiches wrote:

As a Saints fan I like Harry Smith. Admittedly I don’t see him as often as you all do. But I would definitely have him at Saints. I think he currently offers more than Dodd does and whilst Dodds ceiling may be higher, it’s irrelevant if he doesn’t reach that ceiling. I notice a poster mentioned earlier that he’s not a big game player but I disagree. The vision and execution for that kick to Marshall in the CC cup semi against Saints was the epitome of a big game play.

The whole “he’s not a big game player” is a farce. How he didn’t win Lance Todd trophy in that game is still a mystery. He’s been brilliant in almost every big game since Peet has taken over. A lot of Wigan fans don’t rate him though cos he misses a few goals, but his in game kicking is for me the best in league. The amount of games we’ve won with his kicking game is immense for his age. Leigh on Friday was a perfect example.

Re: Dream Team 2023 : Thu Sep 28, 2023 9:12 am  

CJamesy wrote:

The whole “he’s not a big game player” is a farce. How he didn’t win Lance Todd trophy in that game is still a mystery. He’s been brilliant in almost every big game since Peet has taken over. A lot of Wigan fans don’t rate him though cos he misses a few goals, but his in game kicking is for me the best in league. The amount of games we’ve won with his kicking game is immense for his age. Leigh on Friday was a perfect example.

This is his first proper year as an our number 7.

Few growing pains which will happen with young halves (HKR away GP, Hull home GP first half) but he’s getting better and better.

Re: Dream Team 2023 : Thu Sep 28, 2023 12:11 pm  

NSW wrote:

This is his first proper year as an our number 7.

Few growing pains which will happen with young halves (HKR away GP, Hull home GP first half) but he’s getting better and better.

Really?

He played every single game in 2021 and majority of 2022...

Re: Dream Team 2023 : Thu Sep 28, 2023 12:47 pm  

Harry is up to 100 games now so this is the point when we find out whether he is the real deal or not. He can’t be classed as a youngster anymore.

He will, or a lt least should get better with more experience. I’m confident he’ll be a top player for years to come.

Re: Dream Team 2023 : Thu Sep 28, 2023 12:47 pm  

Harry is up to 100 games now so this is the point when we find out whether he is the real deal or not. He can’t be classed as a youngster anymore.

He will, or a lt least should get better with more experience. I’m confident he’ll be a top player for years to come.

Re: Dream Team 2023 : Thu Sep 28, 2023 1:46 pm  

nathan_rugby wrote:

Really?

He played every single game in 2021 and majority of 2022...

What number did he wear in them years?

Re: Dream Team 2023 : Thu Sep 28, 2023 1:50 pm  

I've never understood the criticism Harry gets from some of the wigan fans.

Form me he's one of the best in his position. His out of hand kicking game is probably the best in the league and his quality of passing often goes unnoticed due to the quality of players at the end of them. He's a young kid who has had the responsibility of being the senior half back for the past two seasons.

The only downside is his conversions - and IMO you don't really slag someone off for taking on that responsibility as obviously no one else wants to do it, or he's judged the best in the club.