Re: Team for Hull KR : Sun Feb 06, 2022 4:18 pm  

Marshall is a good finisher and obviously pretty quick (though he looked to have lost a yard of pace after his injury). I think his kick defence is actually pretty good in the main but dominated too much on the kick return for me. Also gets drawn in off his wing a little too often and I think some people overrate him off the back of that try at Huddersfield.

Re: Team for Hull KR : Sun Feb 06, 2022 4:23 pm  

I think we can rule Brad O’Neil out. He’s just scored a try for Newcastle Thunder.

Re: Team for Hull KR : Sun Feb 06, 2022 4:29 pm  

MadDogg wrote:

Marshall is a good finisher and obviously pretty quick (though he looked to have lost a yard of pace after his injury). I think his kick defence is actually pretty good in the main but dominated too much on the kick return for me. Also gets drawn in off his wing a little too often and I think some people overrate him off the back of that try at Huddersfield.

I’ve always liked the lad. I like his attitude and always did in the u19’s. I remember watching him once at Orrell and I just liked his fight and that he was a bit cocky and it was at the end of that season he was released. I couldn’t believe it on what I’d seen that day and a couple of other occasions but I was chuffed when they had a rethink.

Re: Team for Hull KR : Sun Feb 06, 2022 4:37 pm  

NickyKiss wrote:

I’ve always liked the lad. I like his attitude and always did in the u19’s. I remember watching him once at Orrell and I just liked his fight and that he was a bit cocky and it was at the end of that season he was released. I couldn’t believe it on what I’d seen that day and a couple of other occasions but I was chuffed when they had a rethink.

Yes terrific attitude - no-one could question that. Phrased it wrong saying I don't rate him - he definitely has strengths but I personally feel we have better options atm. As for O'Neill- I'm sure he'll get his chances this year. The most important thing is for him to play each week.

Re: Team for Hull KR : Sun Feb 06, 2022 4:37 pm  

Father Ted wrote:

Field,
Thornley, KPP, Hardaker, Marshall.
Cust, Leuluai,
Singleton, Powell, Ellis,
Farrell, Bateman,
Isa.

Mago, Byrne, Shorrocks, Smith.

We are starting with size and pace as we did v Wire. Having Thornley bringing us out of yardage worked well.If we get out of yardage on the front foot then we have the pace and ball playing ability to overcome HKR. They will rely on Abdull as well as Litten who both pose an attacking threat. Smith to replace Tommy.
Looking forward to it.

I’d go with that but I think Smithies will get the nod ahead of Shorrocks.
I suspect we won’t get more than 30 minutes out of Mago so Smithies to play covering prop and second row if required

Re: Team for Hull KR : Sun Feb 06, 2022 6:31 pm  

I think we will go
Field
Thornley KPP Bibby Marshal
Cust Tommy
Singo Powel Ellis
Batty. Faz
Willie
Mago Byrne Smithies Shorrocks
I could not argue with Zak, Smith, Partington or Miski being in the mix most likely is Zak for me.
With Bevan on his way back and Havard to return the depth of squad is so much better.
Bevan Field and Zak at full back
KPP has thrown a curve ball at the centre position we now could have four realistic options. We have the same for wing you throw Halsal in at 5th choice.
Same at half.
Pack we are well off in cover now without relying totally on kids. May take a few games before we see who plays where but that's what we need.
I do not get the issue with Marshal for me he's worked hard on his D and under the bomb. I also think he returns the ball well and wins us plenty pens. Ball in hand I rate him in top 5 finishers in the league.
In reality it's like we have 7 new signings with Field and Bevan back.

Re: Team for Hull KR : Mon Feb 07, 2022 1:06 am  

I agree with all of that, including the praise for Marshall, who I think has worked at his game and sought to improve the defensive side of it.

Re: Team for Hull KR : Mon Feb 07, 2022 9:29 am  

Great to have options.

If you’d told me a couple of weeks ago KPP/Thornley would be our centre/wing combo I’d have thought we’d had a major injury crisis. If playing centre gets KPP 80 mins every week I’m happy with that.

Amazing to think we’ll have the likes of Partington, Shorrocks, Smith, Miski all fit but probably missing out on the 17. Along with Havard, French and Hardaker to come back.

Depth seems much improved.

Re: Team for Hull KR : Mon Feb 07, 2022 9:59 am  

NSW wrote:

Great to have options.

If you’d told me a couple of weeks ago KPP/Thornley would be our centre/wing combo I’d have thought we’d had a major injury crisis. If playing centre gets KPP 80 mins every week I’m happy with that.

Amazing to think we’ll have the likes of Partington, Shorrocks, Smith, Miski all fit but probably missing out on the 17. Along with Havard, French and Hardaker to come back.

Depth seems much improved.

I think the depth is our greatest hope of success this season. We could be short of 7 or 8 players and not see a huge drop off but you certainly couldn’t say that about the favourites for the comp in Saints or Catalans. They’ll have better first 17’s than us and if things carry on for Saints as they have done for the past 4 or 5 seasons, their depth won’t get tested anyway but should they hit a bit of an injury crisis it could really close things up.

Re: Team for Hull KR : Mon Feb 07, 2022 11:45 am  

NSW wrote:

Great to have options.

If you’d told me a couple of weeks ago KPP/Thornley would be our centre/wing combo I’d have thought we’d had a major injury crisis. If playing centre gets KPP 80 mins every week I’m happy with that.

Amazing to think we’ll have the likes of Partington, Shorrocks, Smith, Miski all fit but probably missing out on the 17. Along with Havard, French and Hardaker to come back.

Depth seems much improved.

Everyone seems to be forgetting about Ramon Silva too who I thought went really well in his pre season appearance. Depth seems to be the best it's been in some time.

I don't get the criticism of Marshall. Obvious attacking threat (and you can't have too many of those!) but, more importantly, has worked hard on his weaknesses to the point they have become strengths. His carries out of defense are excellent for someone without natural size. A no-brainer for mine, although it's good to know that there are strong options waiting in the wings should any of that change.