Levrier wrote:
I could see KIlner suprising a few this season alongside those who have already stepped up. It is probable a couple of seasons too early for some of the youngsters to play more than a bit part. Unfortunately I think that Saints and Wire may be pulling away from us for the lack of a top notch impact prop and a top class finisher outside. Personally I hope that we have enough confidence in Smith to bring him through. I was impressed with the way that he worked on his defence and some of his attacking play was exceptional.
Smith is the the best all round half back that we have in the squad particularly in terms of opening up a defence. He will hopefully continue to improve with age. Lam has to decide do we want a half back whose main priority is tackling or one who can run and dictate a game. As an Aussie I know that Lam will go with the former. Not sure if Smith lacks confidence but if I was him I'd ask for a loan next year if his first team appearances will be limited. If it goes well then don't come back. I wouldnt blame him if he went down that route.
I will be in the absolute minority, possibly of one,but I'd sooner play Smith than Hastings in the halfs next year. Put Hastings at 9 and play Smith & Tommy in the halfs with Field or Powell on the bench to come on to cover Tommy or Hastings. I;m assuming here that we cant not include Field in any starting 17.
Hastings will be gone by 2022 but hopefully Smith will develop and be with us for at least the remainder of the decade. Lets start building the team around a player capable of unlocking defences and has some longevity rather than a guy who will be gone by the end of 2021.
Our squad next year although exciting is totally out of sync at the moment and Smith may pay the penalty with limited appearances even though he is the best halfback to come through in a generation.
I'm pretty sure that if we knew that Hastings would take up his 2nd year option we would never have signed Field.
I don't know much about Kilner but his reputation seems to be growing and hopefully he can kick on and grab a few first team appearances in 2021