: Fri Apr 17, 2009 10:36 pm  

None of you would have Burgess or Lynch?

: Fri Apr 17, 2009 10:46 pm  

andyed-wiganrl wrote:

Briscoe
Richards
Gleeson
Carmont OR Shenton
Ainscough
S Tompkins
Dobson
Peacock
Leuleui
Graham
Lauatiti
Tompkins
Westerman



Would honestly only take 6/7 improvements IMO to have by far the best squad in SL, which for me shows how near yet how far we are off.

For me it sums it up that the majority of our backs i wouldnt actually replace given the choice of the whole of super league, save for bringing back Dobson and Briscoe, and having shenton share the other centre birth with carmont for the next couple of seasons as carmont warmed down to retirement.

Shows for me the problems we have are with the coach and our forwards

You'd pick Gleeson and Carmont infront of Gidley? Tomkins infront of Pryce, Mcguire e.t.c. Leulai infront of Cunningham at hooker, when Leulai doesn't even start hooker at wigan? I would suggest an element of bias is in this post.

: Fri Apr 17, 2009 11:01 pm  

andyed-wiganrl wrote:

Briscoe
Richards
Gleeson
Carmont OR Shenton
Ainscough
S Tompkins
Dobson
Peacock
Leuleui
Graham
Lauatiti
Tompkins
Westerman

Would honestly only take 6/7 improvements IMO to have by far the best squad in SL, which for me shows how near yet how far we are off.

For me it sums it up that the majority of our backs i wouldnt actually replace given the choice of the whole of super league, save for bringing back Dobson and Briscoe, and having shenton share the other centre birth with carmont for the next couple of seasons as carmont warmed down to retirement.

Shows for me the problems we have are with the coach and our forwards

So you think Sam and Joel Tomkins are some of best in league? Tommy at Hooker, where he is unproved?

: Sat Apr 18, 2009 1:08 am  

Panda Antics wrote:

Amazes me how over rated Solomona is.

I wouldn't have him over any of our back rowers in the current squad.

Let alone in a dream team.

Did you watch the Bulls game tonight?

1.Greenshields
2.Ainscough
3.Carmont
4.Gleeson
5.Donald
6.Bosc
7.Monaghan
8.Graham
9.Cunningham
10.Feka
11.Locky
12.Wilkin
13.Bird

: Sat Apr 18, 2009 8:21 am  

Jeff the God of Biscuits wrote:

Webb
Pat
Gleeson
Carmont
Ainscough
Tomkins
Long
Graham
Leuluai
Peacock
Hock
O'Loughlin
Tomkins

Now before i'm strung up for suggesting Long...I think Sam could learn a hell of alot playing a year or two with him, Even if he is the Anti-Christ as far as we're concerned.

Come on Jeff???

9 wigan players??

: Sat Apr 18, 2009 9:32 am  

1- Webb
2- Roberts
3- Gleeson
4- Carmont
5- Richards
6- Bosc
7- Dobson
8- Morley
9- Newton
10- Burgess
11- Hock
12- Morrison
13- Menzies

14- Palea'aesina
15- T.Leuluai
16- Peacock
17- Solomona

: Sat Apr 18, 2009 9:50 am  

Ewwenorfolk wrote:

So you think Sam and Joel Tomkins are some of best in league? Tommy at Hooker, where he is unproved?

World Cup ring a bell?

: Sat Apr 18, 2009 11:37 am  

Greenshields
Fox
Gidley
Gleeson
Richards
S Tomkins
Long
Fozzard
Newton
Burgess
Hock
LMS
J Tomkins

Feka
Lynch
Berrigan
Solomona

: Sat Apr 18, 2009 11:47 am  

B Hodgson
Donald
Gidley
Carmont
Richards
Pryce
S Tomkins
Graham
Cunningham
Peacock
O'Loughlin
Hock
Wilkin

subs
Paleaaesina
Burgess
Lauititi
Roby

: Sat Apr 18, 2009 12:26 pm  

From a Saints point of view, mine would be :
Greenshields
Gardner
Gidley
Shenton
Tadulala
Pryce
Bosc
Graham
Cunningham
Peacock
Wilkin
Hock
Sinfield

Roby
Puletua
Lauititi
Elima