Re: Carvell Suspended. Morley Plays. : Wed Feb 17, 2010 10:58 am  

I think Morley is lucky, the more you see it, the worse it seems, it was a delibrate attack to the head.

Carvell is lucky its only 1 match.

The real problem though is the inconsistency of the panel and their decisions.

Re: Carvell Suspended. Morley Plays. : Wed Feb 17, 2010 10:59 am  

pedro17 wrote:

never seen him going toe to toe, not here or the NRL. HE was always doing the high shots over there.

He must have been toe to toe to get sent off for headbutting and punching.

Re: Carvell Suspended. Morley Plays. : Wed Feb 17, 2010 11:37 am  

not really, can be in a scrum and headbut and punch as you can be during and after a tackle. Doesnt need someone to retaliate.

Re: Carvell Suspended. Morley Plays. : Wed Feb 17, 2010 11:39 am  

Appeal: http://www.warringtonguardian.co.uk/wol ... ainst_ban/

Appeal: http://www.warringtonguardian.co.uk/wol ... ainst_ban/

Re: Carvell Suspended. Morley Plays. : Wed Feb 17, 2010 11:59 am  

AJ wrote:

I think Morley is lucky, the more you see it, the worse it seems, it was a delibrate attack to the head.

The real problem I have with the Morley one is that he didn't even get a fine and a warning. He got found not guilty! I mean come on Not guilty.............so they're basically saying it was a legal challenge

If thats allowed in the game now I hope we've got Briers and Myler lined up for a few this weekend. I wouldn't normally agree with challenges like that but they've obviously been legalised.

Re: Carvell Suspended. Morley Plays. : Wed Feb 17, 2010 12:16 pm  

pedro17 wrote:

not really, can be in a scrum and headbut and punch as you can be during and after a tackle. Doesnt need someone to retaliate.

But they wasn't, i recall the Saints player giving him a dig on the floor, Morley got up and smacked him, knocking him down and giving him a nice split eye in the process.

Re: Carvell Suspended. Morley Plays. : Wed Feb 17, 2010 12:17 pm  

hhmmmm think you'll find that only happened in your dream world

Re: Carvell Suspended. Morley Plays. : Wed Feb 17, 2010 12:23 pm  

pedro17 wrote:

hhmmmm think you'll find that only happened in your dream world

The game was on sky pal, i'm sure more than a few Leeds fans will remind you.

Re: Carvell Suspended. Morley Plays. : Wed Feb 17, 2010 12:24 pm  

I just read the verdict and they say it wasnt a high tackle....goes to show the RFL are a joke, they said that he could not pull out. So in that case does it mean that you can hit anyone high if you cannot pull out of the tackle?...clueless.

Re: Carvell Suspended. Morley Plays. : Wed Feb 17, 2010 12:32 pm  

pedro17 wrote:

I just read the verdict and they say it wasnt a high tackle....goes to show the RFL are a joke, they said that he could not pull out. So in that case does it mean that you can hit anyone high if you cannot pull out of the tackle?...clueless.

so if you are in the process of tackling someone (around the chest say)and they duck when you are already in motion, it is a high tackle?