As good as Costin, Gibson or Shuttleworth were, being good in the second and third division against Chorley and kent invicta it is hard to compare them to what Hodgson is doing at the top table and against teams like Wigan and the Bulls.

Will say Brandon Costin as I saw him on a reg basis, haven't had the pleasure of seeing Brett yet, but hope that will change this summer, hoping to be back in the UK for a week or so, possibly for CC Final day

if not OT

Blasphemy


Go wash your mouth out Mick

Any length of ban you dish out is fine with me Codey, dont even ask, just bin him

it's funny but i was expecting this. unfortuntaley we have been so starved of success we hold on to the good memories from bad days.

You still posting?


Who the hell did i ban then

Haven't seen Barry Chuckle on here for a while

He'd kill me or cuddle me

Like DG said -different eras - different style of game - different levels - different positions

So - with this in mind - I`d go for :-

Ancient :Cooper
2nd Devery

Middle Ages :- Gibson
2nd Kerr / Brad Davis

Modern :- Danny Russell
2nd Costin

Current /Recent :- Hodgson B
2nd M D Vere/Drew

Can you not tell us about your experiences Rosenfeld and Ernie Mills

Id pretty much agree with this yeah

But. sure it was different times and different levels, but Gibson just had an excitement about him that only Stan has ever come close to matching (who I added in to the modern)

know I bent the rules a little Codey --but Stan --Aussie --and only 21 ?????.........................







sorry - re read Codey --thought it was Aussie signing !!