Re: Ben Thaler : Fri May 05, 2017 12:40 pm  

[quote="brearley84"]and the tackle on macintosh when he was in the air was a bad one, lands on his head and its red card...we didnt eve get a sin binning[quote]

Abit like the crushed tackle on Webster in the first half, should of been a straight red but not even a penalty given! It works both ways, Webster should never of been penalised, let alone sin binned! There were a fair few head high tackles but Huddersfield that were missed aswel.

How about stop blamin the ref and look at your own inept attack in that second half where you should of atleast scored 3 tries!

Re: Ben Thaler : Fri May 05, 2017 12:42 pm  

Thaler was rubbish for both sides, we both suffered from bad decisions. Minikin maybe should have had 10 for the tackle in the air, but Jakes wasn't even a penalty. Brough maybe should have had a rest for the crusher. Neither side were onside most of the night, or square at the PTB. Numerous high shots from both teams went unnoticed. I've watched the game back this morning as you always see things different than when you are at the game, and my opinion is that the bad decisions were about 50/50 by the end of the game.

Re: Ben Thaler : Fri May 05, 2017 1:18 pm  

Minikin didn't have any action taken against him because if you see the replay he knows he's mistimed it horribly and pulls away so the only contact is his arms and not a full on tackle. If he went full on he would have rightly been sent off.

Re: Ben Thaler : Fri May 05, 2017 1:46 pm  

Losing team fans in blame the ref shocker

Thaler had nothing to do with it, in fact the game was pretty good to watch as a neutral as it was free flowing game with minimum penalties. The penalties that were given were rightly given.

Can't really win the Ref's. Thaler let the game flow last night and gets pinged on here for not giving penalties and other weeks gives all the penalties and then gets called whistle happy. I would rather it be like last night and allow the game to flow its a much better spectacle.

The only real dubious decision was the webster sin binning, which he got wrong. You could argue brough was a red card but at that stage of the game red/yellow didnt really matter.

Re: Ben Thaler : Fri May 05, 2017 4:01 pm  

brearley84 wrote:

maybe to do with having only one recognised half back in the side and most of our strike players out injured

yes cas had some missing too.

We had our hooker and 4th choice half back playing in the halves for most of the game. Still found a way to win and score 2 tries in the second half. Its what teams have to do with injuries. Find a way to win.

Re: Ben Thaler : Fri May 05, 2017 4:47 pm  

that mcshane cant half kick goals!!

something we have been lacking all season, cost us a few games those valuable extra points

Re: Ben Thaler : Fri May 05, 2017 6:20 pm  

RICHARD SILVERWOOD bring him back.

No shock he got Aus vs NZ

The only ref who watched both sides down at Fartown games.

Re: Ben Thaler : Fri May 05, 2017 6:52 pm  

mean_machine wrote:

Losing team fans in blame the ref shocker

Thaler had nothing to do with it, in fact the game was pretty good to watch as a neutral as it was free flowing game with minimum penalties. The penalties that were given were rightly given.

Can't really win the Ref's. Thaler let the game flow last night and gets pinged on here for not giving penalties and other weeks gives all the penalties and then gets called whistle happy. I would rather it be like last night and allow the game to flow its a much better spectacle.

The only real dubious decision was the webster sin binning, which he got wrong. You could argue brough was a red card but at that stage of the game red/yellow didnt really matter.

Agreed, Webster decision was a very poor one and Brough's was deserved.

Regarding your previous points, a penalty is a penalty, the ref isn't there to minimise them, he's there to uphold the laws of the game. And that is why they 'can't win' because as you have stated they have no consistency from one week to the next.

I think Thaler has grown to be possibly the best ref over the last couple of seasons, but he was poor last night, and unfortunately back to his centre of attention days when proudly dishing the yellow cards with maximum theatre. I think there were poor decisions against both teams, and unfortunately pretty key ones. He didn't lose us the game, but both sides are arguing over who was worse done to, not whether he was good or bad, which says enough about his overall performance really.

Re: Ben Thaler : Mon May 08, 2017 7:03 pm  

Cas 1st try (Monaghan) came from Chase knock on and forward pass which all crowd bar Thaler saw, winning margin was less than 6 points hence Thaler did lose us the game I'm afraid. Cas sit proudly at top where as it should be Hull and Giants still 3 points behind couple of teams where as should have been 1 point, pity how teams are being punished by crap decisions with nothing ever getting done about it. Do these refs gamble?

Re: Ben Thaler : Mon May 08, 2017 8:40 pm  

As an outsider Huddersfield could've and should've won. Whatever went before it the rush of blood to Danny Brough's head did ultimately cost you the win. I actually really rate him as a half back and believe his temperament has prevented him being even better.