Rudd all the way.



Stewart needs to be shown the door at the end of this season or sooner if we can get someone else lined up.

I cant believe we signed Stewart on a 3 year deal





Total waste of money for what was supposed to be a big signing.

If it costs nowt then I would get rid now - not bothered if we aint got a replacement lined up - and anyhow, who could do any worse? I really do not know what value he is adding to our squad. He has had his day, thank-you very much and goodbye

I agree with all the above. Stewart offers very little in attack and defence while Rudd is a strong runner and great in defence.

Rudd all the way for me.......no disrespect to Stewart but he`s past his best and near to his careers end..............Rudd is young with plenty years ahead of him so I would sooner see this guy play, also never done anything wrong in the past to keep being overlooked for selection.

Rudd evertime! Stewart is passed it and done nothing since we signed him!!

Well up to now its a landslide victory in favour of Rudd.



Why has Stewart been picked before Rudd now that he is fit too play?

Kelly dont like him.

I've heard this about several of the players, a coach is there to do a job and make the team win not pick thm based on who he likes!! sort it yourself out NK as well as the team

Perhaps the question should be - Stewart or one of the mannequins from Burtons!!!!

Surely Kelly must now pick Rudd for your next match.

Common sense would say so, something Leigh have been lacking!!

I've heard one call to get Hatton back from Blackpool.



On current form we could probably do alot worse than give the kid a chance.

Hopefully so, to replace Higson, who for me ain't a centre in the memory of man!!

Too many times he could get the ball out to the winger and put him in a gap and he just runs straight into the tackle

He's a second rower

and

Donlans a full back

Morts a full back

Stewarts a has been

Maddens a never quite been

Alsteads a never quite been

Durbins a scrum half

Rudds a centre

Marsh is a last minute replacement prop

Watsons a slow motion, past his sell by date scrum half

Ridyard is an amateur half back



So what? Have a chat with N.Kelly

Does anyone think that Neil Kelly will select Rudd on Thursday? If not, why do you think that will be the case?

cos nk must be the only person on the planet that doesn't rate him

He was playing him last season so what's the difference now?

agree with everything leigh 24.7 says above and that sums it up perfectly and whatever we need some fresh legs and a change of game plan on thursday up the middle rugby is for big teams we should be running these big teams around the park and our kicking game needs to be improved

Think back to Haven in play offs, Rudd played in the A team that week.

Stewart = Never done one thing for this club end of story!



Rudd = Mmm thought he was going to be a world beater but then he annoyed me as he didn't seem to know where the tryline was BUT 1 thing he is is a quality DEFENDER get him in and get him TACKLING cos at the mo none of our threequarters are.

leave rudd where he is not a patch on stewart he is hardly setting the world alight in the reserves

Personally never seen Stewart as a Leigh player and not seen anything to change my mind so Rudd for me.Stewart naver brought the good player he was at STs with him.