Re: Tonights Game V Castleford : Thu Aug 13, 2015 9:04 pm  

Poor Wire performance, average Cas performance, abysmal officiating performance and Sky needs as big a reshuffle as we do.

Re: Tonights Game V Castleford : Thu Aug 13, 2015 9:06 pm  

jj86 wrote:

Fair point. Definitely as important as gifting 2 tries to Castleford through penalty awards and a drop goal whilst denying us a try through an incompetent video ref?

Those situations that went in favour of Warrington could have easily been converted to points just happens that Warrington didn't capitalise on top of cas not having an opportunity to score off the foot in touch.

Disallowed try was touch and go whether atkins touches it on to the cas player, he certainly played it. I fancy if it was the other way round you'd be less certain it was incompetent.

Re: Tonights Game V Castleford : Thu Aug 13, 2015 9:06 pm  

Can't blame the ref when we had all the ball and all the territory and still never looked like scoring. Our season in 80 minutes. Mostly rubbish, a brief glimour of hope, ultimate inevitable disappointment. Admit it, when we equalised you knew we were going to lose.

Re: Tonights Game V Castleford : Thu Aug 13, 2015 9:09 pm  

But why can't Smith + the powers that be not see what we supporters can see?Cas dominated most of that match tonight so would have been unjust on them to end up losers but season ticket I will not be buying with this current crap team.Sandow must be wondering what the hell he's let himself in for.

Re: Tonights Game V Castleford : Thu Aug 13, 2015 9:10 pm  

Seth wrote:

Disallowed try was touch and go whether atkins touches it on to the cas player, he certainly played it. I fancy if it was the other way round you'd be less certain it was incompetent.

If you can't tell on 2 or 3 views, then it simply isn't conclusive. If you have to look 10-12-15 times from all sorts of angles and use 'super-zoom' then there is no way you can overturn the on field referees decision. That's twice in two weeks

Re: Tonights Game V Castleford : Thu Aug 13, 2015 9:12 pm  

Thought kev penny gave his all again ,if people had his heart and desire we would be top of the league

Re: Tonights Game V Castleford : Thu Aug 13, 2015 9:12 pm  

Seth wrote:

Those situations that went in favour of Warrington could have easily been converted to points just happens that Warrington didn't capitalise on top of cas not having an opportunity to score off the foot in touch.

Disallowed try was touch and go whether atkins touches it on to the cas player, he certainly played it. I fancy if it was the other way round you'd be less certain it was incompetent.

But we got no points from these errors. Cas did.

Re the video ref - what you have said is the point - touch and go so it must go with on pitch decision. I didn't even think it was touch and go - Atkins caught it with his left hand first and it went back.

Re: Tonights Game V Castleford : Thu Aug 13, 2015 9:15 pm  

Exactly. Try on the field is given absolutely no evidence to overturn it and yet no try just very very weird. I'm not quibbling about the loss as we were poo but that decision along with the Evans' perfectly good try and atkins' ball steal were killers. If someone can genuinely tell me what atkins was penalized for then fair play. Plus I'll have a pop at sandow for his huge missed conversion

Re: Tonights Game V Castleford : Thu Aug 13, 2015 9:20 pm  

You can't only call bad decisions out just when a team scores in that set (not same play) Warrington could have well scored off forward passes but couldn't convert, doesn't make one decision worse than the other.

Fair point re onfield call.

Warrington far from good enough though Is the bigger story which I'm sure you all agree.

Re: Tonights Game V Castleford : Thu Aug 13, 2015 9:24 pm  

Seth wrote:

You can't only call bad decisions out just when a team scores in that set (not same play) Warrington could have well scored off forward passes but couldn't convert, doesn't make one decision worse than the other.

Fair point re onfield call.

Warrington far from good enough though Is the bigger story which I'm sure you all agree.

I don't see how a decision that directly dissalows or allows a try to be scored isn't as bad.

We were crap but we had all the ball but couldn't convert and couldn't defend. Having two tries chalked off didn't help though!