Tautai and Charnley FPN : Mon Jul 18, 2016 3:13 pm  

Both charged grade B for Tautai grade C for Charnley, I find it amusing that a tackle that could seriously injure a player is a lesser charge than touching the ref.

Re: Tautai and Charnley : Mon Jul 18, 2016 3:21 pm  

karetaker wrote:

Both charged grade B for Tautai grade C for Charnley, I find it amusing that a tackle that could seriously injure a player is a lesser charge than touching the ref.

Agreed. It's very odd.

Let's see if Charnley gets the same as Currie did, or whether certain ex-goon players are on the disciplinary committee again this week.

[Fantastic Mr Catpiss]

Re: Tautai and Charnley : Mon Jul 18, 2016 3:33 pm  

Paul2812 wrote:

Agreed. It's very odd.

Let's see if Charnley gets the same as Currie did, or whether certain ex-goon players are on the disciplinary committee again this week.

they weren't last week, that was innaccurate.

Re: Tautai and Charnley : Mon Jul 18, 2016 4:15 pm  

Fantastic Mr Catpiss wrote: they weren't last week, that was innaccurate. S Fielden was on last week . Is also on this week. http://media.therfl.co.uk/docs/DISCIPLI ... 20Copy.pdf

Fantastic Mr Catpiss wrote: they weren't last week, that was innaccurate. S Fielden was on last week . Is also on this week. http://media.therfl.co.uk/docs/DISCIPLI ... 20Copy.pdf

Re: Tautai and Charnley : Mon Jul 18, 2016 4:25 pm  

So lets see Charnley Grade C and he will plead guilty so the charge will be lowered to a B. Wigan will plead they need him for the challenge Cup game so reduced to grade A. He will then be told don't be such a idiot in future and get a 1 match ban and £300 fine mark my words. Tautai See above

[Fantastic Mr Catpiss]

Re: Tautai and Charnley : Mon Jul 18, 2016 4:59 pm  

Builth Wells Wire wrote: S Fielden was on last week . Is also on this week. http://media.therfl.co.uk/docs/DISCIPLI ... 20Copy.pdf apologies then, the tuesday line up was what has since been doing the rounds.

Builth Wells Wire wrote: S Fielden was on last week . Is also on this week. http://media.therfl.co.uk/docs/DISCIPLI ... 20Copy.pdf apologies then, the tuesday line up was what has since been doing the rounds.

Re: Tautai and Charnley : Mon Jul 18, 2016 5:14 pm  

Read league express and weekly this morning and going by the letters in there and other things I've seen this disciplinary will I'm sure be watched with interest,the other thing I'm surprised at is no Wigan fan on here bemoaning they done nothing wrong and the Rfl are just picking on them etc etc etc.

Re: Tautai and Charnley : Mon Jul 18, 2016 5:57 pm  

Fantastic Mr Catpiss wrote:

apologies then, the tuesday line up was what has since been doing the rounds.

John Stankevitch made quite a big thing of Fieldens presence on the committee on social media. I think he made a very good point.

Re: Tautai and Charnley : Mon Jul 18, 2016 6:42 pm  

The problem is this:
The panel are selected well in advance. How are those who select the panel meant to know who will be appearing so that nobody is 'judged' by an ex-player who once played for the same club as the charged player?
If the ex-players on the panel can't take part in a case involving one of their ex-clubs, you would be ruling out a lot them as most players appear for 3/4 clubs during their career.

Re: Tautai and Charnley : Mon Jul 18, 2016 9:10 pm  

nottinghamtiger wrote:

The problem is this:
The panel are selected well in advance. How are those who select the panel meant to know who will be appearing so that nobody is 'judged' by an ex-player who once played for the same club as the charged player?
If the ex-players on the panel can't take part in a case involving one of their ex-clubs, you would be ruling out a lot them as most players appear for 3/4 clubs during their career.

Can't see its insurmountable to choose ex player when they know who is up before the beak?
The issue isn't whether they are biased but whether they may be (reasonably) thought to be biased. Why take the risk. On the other hand the Wigan fans will no doubt take the view that any player who didn't play for them will be biased against them...then again "every one hates us we don't care"...