Re: 2024 Dream Team : Sun Sep 22, 2024 8:02 pm  

Fantastic Mr Catpiss wrote:

Byrne has been garbage for wigan this year, he's almost been enemy #1 for their fans.

He hasn't been garbage but he has had more average games than good. About on par with Lees. Havard and Ellis have walked all over Lees though as have a multitude of props throughout the league. The wildest selection for me is putting another #7 in over French. Can't get over that one. Not even Salford fans would have Sneyd over Bevan. It's all about trying to get players in from across the teams rather than rewarding the actual best players. If they have been the best players then they have been the best players. French has won games on his own.

Re: 2024 Dream Team : Sun Sep 22, 2024 8:12 pm  

No doubt French is a much better player than sneyd, but probably missed too many matches. Lees is totally baffling, Byrne nearly as baffling. George Williams can feel unlucky in my opinion.

Re: 2024 Dream Team : Sun Sep 22, 2024 8:22 pm  

Captain Hook wrote:

No doubt French is a much better player than sneyd, but probably missed too many matches. Lees is totally baffling, Byrne nearly as baffling. George Williams can feel unlucky in my opinion.

Byrne isn't in it Hook. Even Wigan fans would have questioned that one

Re: 2024 Dream Team : Mon Sep 23, 2024 2:45 pm  

French gets in if he plays more games... no doubt.
Lees over Sue at HKR or Mulhearn at Leigh or Harrison for us is perplexing... I guess they needed to pick at least 1 Saints player.